click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




The Fashion Police
Mom with a View

The Fashion Police

I'm grateful that my girls wear uniforms to school.

by

The problem of bullying is getting a lot of attention these days. And rightly so. Both the pain of the aggressor as well as that of the victim frequently has deep-rooted sources that need to be addressed. But have we gone too far when we now need to worry about "fashion bullies"? (See recent Wall Street Journal article, 10/25/07.)

Apparently it's a real issue in middle school. And it's not enough that working-class parents spend their hard-earned income on designer clothes (not to mention their precious time schlepping from mall to mall), they have to be the right designer. Just imagine the chagrin of wearing Dolce and Gabbana and finding out it was Juicy Couture that was in vogue that day. Or, in the case cited in the paper, Apple bottoms jeans and Air Force 1 sneakers by Nike (no commercial plug intended).

Teenagers who take pride in their non-conformity are perhaps the most conforming of all.

It's an inescapable irony that teenagers who take pride in their non-conformity are perhaps the most conforming of all. Everyone must dress alike -- in what the crowd deems cool. Acknowledging this reality eliminates one of the most pressing arguments against school uniforms, namely that clothes are an expression of individuality. Stand in any high school parking lot at the end of the day and try to seriously promote that theory.

I would even take it one step further. Why should clothes be such a significant expression of individuality? Shouldn't our personality be? Shouldn't our actions, our character, and ultimately our souls be the true reflections of our uniqueness?

In a paradoxical twist, it seems to me that individuality is most marked in a school where uniforms are worn. Since the clothing no longer distinguishes one girl from the other, it has to be their behavior and their character traits that do. It's easier to notice who's always kind, who works hard, whose hand is in the air and who is eager to help when not blocked by clothing that screams "look at me".

And it's an important lesson for the girls (and boys too). If all that energy isn't needed for shopping and deciding what to wear in the morning, it can be focused on more important things like...sleeping in, I mean, like character development, like studying, like helping overwhelmed neighborhood mothers, like tutoring, like cooking, like helping their own overwhelmed mothers. Our daughters can run Chinese auctions for charity and after-school programs for younger kids. They can visit the elderly and the sick. They can develop into real mensches.

The amount of time and energy we all put into our appearances is staggering. Multiply by at least one hundred to imagine the life of an adolescent. It's a time when mirrors and scales should really be banned from all homes and public areas. I think it relieves our children of a tremendous social pressure to insist on school uniforms. Even if they balk, they benefit.

The Wall Street Journal piece suggests that girls may end friendships over another's poor choice of clothing. Even People magazine's section on style gaffes doesn't advocate such an extreme. Is this really how we want to raise our girls? Instead of lectures and workshops dealing with fashion bullying, why not eliminate it entirely? Don't we have more important things to deal with? Don't we have higher aspirations for our daughters?

I'm grateful that my girls wear uniforms to school. It saves time, it's easier on the pocketbook and most of all, it's easier on them. Don't all mothers and fathers want that for their daughters? It's up to us -- to pressure the schools and put up with the protests from our kids. The ultimate gain in character, peace of mind, and personal growth makes it worth it. Now if I can only figure out what the in-crowd is wearing on Sundays...

Published: November 17, 2007


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 18

(18) MESA, May 16, 2011 3:55 PM

We always preach that when women wear higher necklines, longer sleeves, and longer hemlines, they get into the mindset of "I'm more than just a body." And when women wear nice clothes and makeup and look good, they get into the mindset of "I look and feel good." My point is that how you dress and groom yourself does affect how you see yourself, and when girls wear uniforms, they get into that uniform mindset. I have NEVER seen uniformed schoolgirls showing the kind of creativity and individuality that they show when they dress in their own unique style. If you say that school uniforms ensure tzniut and prevent embarrassment, I believe that. And if you say that they are cheaper and easier on the parents, I believe that too. But to say that having everyone dress the same makes it easier to think individually... well, I just don't believe that.

(17) jennifer, December 12, 2007 11:46 PM

"hollister" line of clothing

i've been known to tell people how funny i find it that it's so fashionable to wear Hollister clothing. why? because there is a company called "Holister" that makes colostomy supplies. yes, i'm talking about people who've had their bowels rerouted to their abdominal walls. i'm thinking most teens wouldn't wear that brand of clothing if they knew what else the name stood for.

(16) Ronelle, November 29, 2007 12:16 AM

I agree with the sentiments expressed in this essay.

I applaud Emuna Braverman for her essay on the "Fashion Police." I thought my sixth grade daughter was exaggerating the emphasis on clothing at her middle school until I volunteered at a program last week. The cafeteria looked like a showroom for Ugg boots and sweatshirts that cost upwards of $40 because they bear names like Abercrombie, Hollister and Pink. As a single mother of three, I can't afford to "keep up with the Schwartz's." It's disturbing when kids feel they need a closetful of designer clothes in order to measure up. I agree that uniforms would help put the focus on a person's inner qualities instead of on what he or she is wearing on the outside.

(15) Janice, November 24, 2007 7:43 PM

Uniforms?

Sometime in American history the word "teenager" was invented. Before then we called them youth or young people.

Around the sametime, Youth culture developed. Their own clothes, music, hairstyles, stuff. Then parents were told there was a generation gap, we believed it. All this was designed to put a wedge between parents, family and it's youth; hence the age of rebellion. I believe Nikita Kruchave of the Soviet Union declared they would destroy us without firing a shot. One method to undermine people in leadership roles and to promote rebellion in youths.

Youths were not meant to have culture apart from their family; so uniforms should be fine.

(14) Mikha'el Makovi, November 24, 2007 3:12 PM

Social status based on clothing, since when?

I must have had a strange childhood. I graduated from high school in June 2006, and NEVER did I experience any social status problems based on clothing.

My fashion status has always been rainbow colors that I think match and that everyone else invariably disagrees, but the most I got was playful criticism from my friends. It was only joking, and besides this, no one ever said anything one way or another.

Now, I often wear pajama pants as if they are normal pants, and again, my friends playfully rib me, and that's it.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!