Are Jews X-Men?
click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Are Jews X-Men?

Are Jews X-Men?

The movie "X-Men" describes a group of mutants who are rejected by the rest of humanity. For me, it hit very close to home.

by

One of the ways I know if I have seen a good movie, is if I can see aspects of my own life in its story-line and characters. When I saw "X-Men," I felt exactly that. Really -- it was a good movie. And no, I am not a comic book geek, or a video game freak, I just enjoy a good mutant duel as much as the next guy.

The plot goes something like this: human biology has reached a stage where random mutations are occurring and creating "mutants" with certain powers. Some gather at a special school for gifted mutants where they learn to harness their powers and are taught by the X-men. The X-men are not only teachers, but also moonlight as super heroes who protect the planet from the evil renegade mutants.

Meanwhile, American society has become so scared of the mutants simply because they are different. As a result, a charismatic politician, Senator Kelly, is gaining notoriety solely on a platform which is vehemently anti-mutant. Sure it sounds strange -- it's science fiction. Star Trek screenplays don't exactly read like Chaucer either.

The opening scene, which sets the stage for the movie, takes place in a concentration camp during the Holocaust.

The similarities between the mutants and the Jewish people are obvious. The opening scene, which sets the stage for the movie, takes place in a concentration camp during the Holocaust. Both mutant and Jew are seen as different. Although externally both may not really look that different from "normal people," beneath the surface, everyone knows that they are different. This was one of Germany's greatest fears concerning the Jews -- that they could no longer be distinguished from "regular" Germans. The Jews spoke German, acted German, and even looked German, and Hitler was furious that the Jews were quietly infiltrating the highest ranks of German society.

This fear is perhaps exemplified in the character Mystique, skillfully played by Rebecca Romajin-Stamos, in tandem with some kind of female Jackie Chan stunt double. Mystique had the power to transform identically into any human being that she sees. Using this power, Mystique has assimilated into society and even has infiltrated the upper echelon of American politics.

This was one of the fears that the Germans had about the Jews before the Holocaust. However, I should add that if all Jews looked like Rebecca Romajin-Stamos and pranced around the streets painted in blue, I think that we would have been a much more popular people.

Perhaps I may be reading into the X-Men a little too much, but I also found a personal metaphor contained in the movie. One of the story-lines focuses on a young girl named Rogue, who always knew that she was different. She wasn't completely aware of her identity as a mutant, but she knew that there were certain things that other kids did that she could never do. In an attempt to discover what it was that made her feel different, she planned a road trip after she finished high school. Her first stop was Northern Alberta, and it seemed like something was drawing her there.

As an aside, I've been to Northern Alberta, and there is nothing there besides for a friendly family of moose, and a small Eskimo man, so I have no idea what she was feeling. Nonetheless, when she arrived, she met up with Wolverine, and through a set of fortuitous circumstances she ended up at the school for mutant children run by Patrick "I-can't-shake-the-Sci-fi-type-cast" Stewart. There, she realized that she had felt different for all of these years because she was indeed different. She learned about what it meant to be a mutant, and how exactly to harness and control her powers.

Over the years, there were people at the school who had become experts in their powers, the X-men, and they were the ones who taught the children. Rogue, like the others, finally understood herself, and finally felt at home.

I, along with many other Jews have gone through similar experiences as Rogue, the mutant.

I, along with many other Jews, have gone through similar experiences. We have always felt something pulling at us, but could never quite explain it. For some, this urge has taken them to India, Southeast Asia, or perhaps South America. For others, it has taken them to Israel where they've been able to explore what it really means to be Jewish and to finally understand what it was that made them feel so different all of these years.

I had that feeling when I started learning in Jerusalem about four years ago. My teachers certainly didn't look like Hale Berry (Storm) or Famke Jansen (Dr. Gray), but they were just as much experts in Judaism as the X-men were in Mutantism.

At the end of the film, as is presumably evidenced by her funky new hairdo, Rogue goes through a transition. She finds a place in the mutant community, and seems to be finally at peace with herself.

Although unfortunately I didn't get a new hairdo (I was hoping for the religious equivalent of a mo-hawk), I too finally felt a sense of inner peace after my time in Israel. Nagging questions were finally answered, and feelings of uncertainty were gone. I knew why I had felt different all of these years, and I was confident and proud of those differences.

There was a time that I thought that because of my new religious observances, people would look at me like I was a "mutant." But I came to realize that Judaism was something to be proud of, not ashamed of. If that were the way that I viewed myself, then that is the way others would see me as well.

After all, one man's mutant, is another man's X-Man.

Published: July 29, 2000


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 17

(15) Ra'anan, August 13, 2014 8:43 PM

scripts & story lines & Jews

DC & Marvel comics almost EXCLUSIVELY employed Jews. X-Men as a film should have Jewish elements of the other people w/special gifts (DC's version is superman, but also batman is similar). The thing is that Mr. Stan at Marvel has made deals w/some Islamic folk to create a Muslim version of his material. I wonder if that didn't influence the Jewishness of the X-Men in a negative way? Alternatively, Marvel was never as melodramatic as DC & therefore demanded more complexity. I tend more towards the former than the latter.

(14) Shalom, June 4, 2011 4:13 PM

This is the Most Anti-Semitic movie I have ever seen!!!

I just watched the new X-Men movie. This is the Most Anti-Semitic movie I have ever seen!!! The fact the you write about this, even question the comparison and contrast of Jews to X-Men and NOT SEE The Anti-Semitism message in the movie, brings serious question to your judgment! This is the first movie I have ever seen that I would suggest Boycotting! For those that have already seen it or think they can’t miss it, I ask to recall or closely watch the Jewish Holocaust Survivor/Mutant transition throughout the film. The ending scenes were horrific to me in the way this Jewish caricature was portrayed. It is disturbing, disgusting, and totally degrading of Jewish representation. I will not even write down how the caricature is portrayed and what his final messages suggest! It was That troubling! There was another mutant caricature portraying a devil that had disturbing relations with the Jewish caricature. And the ending view of the Jewish caricature depicted with horns on his helmet should validate all Anti-Semitic notions! How can “any” Jew make content comments about this movie, not see the blatant distrust and hate of our people, and not make comment about that, is beyond any reasonable explanation!! This Movie AND its message SUCKS!!!!

Anonymous, June 16, 2011 1:41 AM

yeah, new movie is anti-israeli or anti-semitic or both

i think you're picking up on some points that maybe i didn't or might not fully agree on. i don't think the holocaust is fair ground to insert into just any movie. the way magneto is portrayed - a vengeful holocaust victim that uses his suffering against others - is just sick. how they had him trivialize the meaning of "Never Again" as he kills his tormentor and goes on to seek war against the rest of the world. it feels like the script is coming from the radical Arab world claiming that we use the holocaust as an excuse to abuse them or take 'their' land. you have to see to understand, but yes, i feel like this should be boycotted. i don't look for these things, but it was just so blatant and disturbing. just wrong.

Rachmiel Shraga, June 18, 2012 4:20 PM

the director of X-men recognized Israel back in 2000 when most Hollywood Jews were leftists

In the scene of the international summit underneath the statue of liberty, a point is made of showing the Israeli flag.

(13) Esther, February 19, 2009 2:16 PM

An excellent point of view

The first time I saw this movie, I thought in a similar way. The people of G-d are equiped with the power of Torah, and are able to change the world with this wisdom, kindness and holiness, that is why the world has not collapsed yet.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub