click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Join 400,000 Aish subscribers
Get Email Updates




The Jewish Ethicist: Was this Stolen?

The Jewish Ethicist: Was this Stolen?

Good-faith purchasers shouldn't suffer monetary loss.

by

Q. I bought a book through an on-line bookstore and it says inside it belongs to a well-known yeshiva. I contacted the yeshiva and they confirmed that it belongs to them. What do I do?

A. In general, the rule in Torah law is that anytime an object makes its way into our hands, we have an obligation to return it to the owner. The Torah commands this return in two places:

    If you encounter the ox of [even] your enemy, or his ass, straying in the way, surely return it to him. (Exodus 23:4)

    Don't see your brother's ox, or his sheep, straying and ignore them; surely return them to your brother. (Deuteronomy 22:1)

From the point of view of the original Torah law, there is really no difference how the lost object made it into your hands. If it was lost and you can identify the owner, you have to take steps to return the object. (As we explained in previous columns, you are not required to incur net expenses to do so.)

However, Jewish law, just like civil law, makes certain provisions for objects obtained in good faith in an open marketplace. The Talmudic sages made a regulation known as "rectification of the market" (takanat hashuk) that enables a person to recover lost property yet prevents a person from suffering a loss if he makes a purchase in good faith. Good faith means that he did not know, and had no reason to know, that the merchandise was stolen. They were worried that if inadvertently buying a stolen object would result in a total loss, people would be reluctant to buy and general commerce would suffer.

In this case, the buyer still has to fulfill the commandment of returning the lost object, but the original owner has to reimburse him for the price of his purchase (assuming it is a fair market price). Any legal action against the thief will be taken by the original owner, who is left with a monetary loss.(1)

The logic behind requiring the payment is to encourage market activity; the logic behind the return is that the original owner values the object particularly highly. There are many different justifications for this idea. From an economic standpoint, we would say that the fact that the original owner refrained from selling the object even though he could have obtained the same price as the thief proves that he values it more highly than the thief did and more than we know the purchaser does. From a psychological point of view, we know that people develop an attachment to their property over time. There is also a spiritual element that until ownership is uprooted we view a special providential connection between a person and his possession.

This rule is subject to various conditions. First of all, if the original owner can be assumed to have given up hope of ever recovering the object, the subsequent owner may obtain full ownership, what is sometimes known in secular law as "clear title". Second of all, the acquisition must really be in good faith. If the site, or the particular vendor, involved have a shady reputation which you could have verified, this condition may not hold. If you had reason for suspicion you may be obligated simply to return the book. Finally, what we just explained is the Jewish law approach. There may be various secular laws and regulations which would change the picture. Since this column does not discuss issues of secular law, we cannot even relate to these.

Note that actual application of takanat hashuk in your case would be problematic. In your case we are discussing a standard object. The book that you obtained is exactly identical to another copy the yeshiva would obtain. It is true that a private individual develops a special attachment to his books, and particularly to religious books, and probably most people would be very reluctant to trade their familiar prayer books for a new and "better" one. But this consideration rarely applies to an institution such as a yeshiva.

In other words, the yeshiva would probably find the prospect of receiving your copy of the book and returning you the money very unattractive. It is probably better for both of you if the book remains in your hands, though you should certainly notify them and give them the option. The yeshiva will probably want to obtain from you the contact details of the seller so that they can try and obtain recompense from him. Even if the book was taken inadvertently, the taker still has to return it to the original owner. That is the essence of the mitzvah to return lost objects.

According to Jewish law, you should offer to return the book to the yeshiva and obtain recompense, but probably they will be more interested in the contact details of the seller so that they can try to recover the value of the book.

SOURCES: (1) Babylonian Talmud Bava Kamma 141a

Published: March 21, 2010


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 10

(10) Anonymous, March 4, 2013 9:40 PM

Correction

Just a correction to ensure the accuracy of this article. There is no Bava Kama 141a. I believe the correct Daf that the article relates to is Bava Kama 115a.

(9) SusanE, March 29, 2010 2:36 PM

What Should I do? Depends on if They Want it Back.

To the author.... what do you think you should do? You have contacted the Yeshiva and they said it was a current book they owned and it had not been sold? Did they state that it had been stolen? Sending stolen property through the mail is mail fraud, so better to find out if it was lost or stolen. It is your choice. If I were in that situation, I would have an email or letter from the yeshiva stating it was their lost book and that they wanted it back, and would reimburse me for my costs.. I would return it to the yeshiva by mail and insure it and send it signature confirmation. -- If you are concerned about the book enough to Ask The Ethicist, why not spend the few dollars it cost and send it back anyway whether they reimburse or not?

(8) Anonymous, March 26, 2010 3:59 PM

No Yeshiva but.....

I have a friend who buys a lot of books at thrift stores. After reading them, she sometimes gives them away to others she thinks might like them. She always writes her name in every single book and I've often wondered why she does this, particularly if she's going to turn around and give them to someone else to read.

(7) Jeff, March 25, 2010 7:13 AM

Lots of issues raised here

Wow! A rather complex and potentially volatile situation. A few wrong words can ruffle a lot of feathers, so proceed with care: 1. Was the book stolen? Or was it sold off as yeshiva "surplus"? 2. If stolen, did the online book seller acquire it in good faith? Some online book sellers have real-world used book stores. If this is how the online seller acquired the book, did he use due diligence to establish that it wasn't stolen? A cursory inspection would have revealed the yeshiva's stamp. 3. Does the online bookseller know the identity of the person from whom he acquired the book? Lots of these purchases are made for "cash", without many formalities. So, assuming the book was stolen, who bears the loss? Do nothing, and the yeshiva is out one book. Offer the book for resale to the yeshiva and it accepts, then the yeshiva is out the money... then if the yeshiva pursues the online seller, then he can be out the money, even if he bought the book in good faith... and so on, assuming the chain of custody can be further pursued. This can end up expending more effort than the book is worth. As Rabbi Meir says, offer to sell the book back to the yeshiva. Hopefully the matter ends there and no further action is required! Chag sameach.

(6) Anonymous, March 22, 2010 6:26 PM

What if you accidentally lose someone's item?

I accidently lost a school's item during the time of a move.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!