click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Daughter-in-Law Badmouthing My Son
Dear Emuna

Daughter-in-Law Badmouthing My Son

My daughter-in-law talks to me negatively about my son. How do I set a boundary?

by

Dear Emuna,

My daughter-in-law talks to me negatively about my son. How do I set a boundary?

Troubled

Dear Troubled,

First the good news. Obviously your daughter-in-law feels close to you and trusts you. She is not going behind your back to talk about your son and she is trying to work it out with you. So stop and take pleasure in the fact that you have created a warm and trusting relationship with your daughter-in-law. This is extremely rare (see most of the letters to Dear Emuna!) and is something you should appreciate.

That said, of course you can’t allow this behavior to continue. Not only should she not be speaking negatively about your son, but you are not the right person to help her resolve the issue. Don’t be seduced into playing the middleman in trying to redirect your son. It will not work out well for your relationship with either of them. You need to tell her gently but firmly that you love both of them very much and that you are neither comfortable with her criticism of your son nor qualified to help them resolve their issues. You should refer them to an appropriate teacher/counselor/rabbi.

Although speaking derogatorily is always a bad habit and your daughter-in-law shouldn’t be voicing her criticism of anyone, let alone her husband and your son, it is not your role to rebuke her either. You don’t want to push her away. We have a principle in Judaism that we bring close with the right hand (compassion) and push away with the left hand (discipline). Compassion trumps discipline. Even when suggesting that you are the wrong address for her comments, and even if done gently, she may be offended. Try your best to do something loving the same day – suggest a lunch, a shopping trip, a fun “girls” activity, something you can do together – that will take any potential sting out of your words. May your efforts meet with success!

Family Rupture over Baby Naming

Dear Emuna,

Thank you for your wonderful insight. I have a dilemma regarding the birth of my first grandchild – my oldest daughter's child. She is due in two weeks. Thirty-three years ago my grandmother passed away – 10 days before my oldest daughter was born. I was best friends with my grandmother and devastated that she died so suddenly. During shiva, the rabbi discussed with me and my family that there is no law stating that I had to name the baby with my grandmother’s English name or use the first letter. I could name her with the Hebrew name at shul to honor my grandmother. So I picked a name that I loved It began with an L and my grandmothers name began with an F.

From the day this beautiful child was born my mother and her entire family stopped speaking to me. I sat day after day with my new baby, crying my eyes out and all alone. No one would visit except my father. My father finally told my mother that if she did not start speaking to me he would divorce her. She finally started speaking to me after a month or two (it felt like a lifetime).

Now my mother has passed away and I of course would love to have this baby named after her – either first or middle name. My daughter point blank said, “If I don’t, will you stop speaking to me like your mother did to you?” I said that will never happen. She refuses to tell me names she has picked and briefly mentioned that I will be pleased with their choices. My daughter and I are best friends. At this point I just want a healthy baby and for my daughter to be healthy as well, but it is such an odd feeling that all this pain I lived with is coming back. I know my family will be angry at both of us and I am trying to figure out how to deal with this! Why has it become such a powerful force that breaks up relationships?

Anxious Grandmother-to-Be

Dear Anxious,

By this point, I assume the baby has been born and I pray that he or she is healthy and that the name issue was resolve to everyone’s pleasure. At least I hope so. I can’t answer the why question at the end of your letter. People’s emotions remain elusive and difficult to understand.

It seems to me there is really only one issue here that you need to have clarity about. The naming of a child is the sole decision of the parents of that child. I feel like I should write that again and scream it from the rooftops. It is NOT the purview of the grandparents or any other relatives. They had their turn with their own children.

This is hard for many people (not just your family!) to accept. That is NOT your problem. People have a hard time accepting all sorts of things. But, much as grandparents would like their grandchild named after a particular relative, it is NOT up to them. A wise grandparent recognizes this and, like you, only wants a healthy baby and a close relationship with their child. A foolish grandparent (I’m sorry but I can’t think of a better word) does not. How self-defeating to destroy the relationships you do have – with your children and grandchildren – in a fit of pique over the child’s name!

I confess that it is incomprehensible to me. Your job is to understand clearly that you did nothing wrong. It was not your job to please your parents with your child’s name just as it is not your daughter’s job to please you with her child’s name. I’m sorry if the situation evokes bad memories but perhaps you can take comfort from the fact that you did nothing wrong and that you are not responsible for the reactions of others. The most important lesson of course is that whatever your daughter names her child and however any other relatives behave, you will be only happy and will do your best to deepen your bond with your daughter (who is presumably exhausted and overwhelmed and needs you now more than ever!) and to create a warm and lasting bond with your grandchild, whatever his or her name is! I hope I can safely wish you Mazel Tov!!

Ask Emuna a Question (Click here)

Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 4

(4) Dina Leah, January 12, 2017 2:54 AM

I agree about the baby naming

My son who was born in Israel, has a first Hebrew name that uses a letter after his father's aunt who died in the Holocaust. His middle name is my paternal grandfather's Hebrew name, and my son hates it. He will only use the initial!

I use my Hebrew name now more and it's one that I chose. My mom couldn't remember what Hebrew name she gave me, so I chose one when I lived in Israel.

B"H I have three lovely grandchildren with names that have absolutely nothing to do with any relatives. When my first granddaughter was born, I asked how they came up with her name. My son said it was the only Hebrew name in the baby book that he and my daughter in law were able to agree on!

Emuna is right. We had our chance with our own children. And, grandparents and great grandparents may have suggestions, but ultimately it's up to the parents to choose.

On the other hand, my niece and husband followed more American type transition and not Jewish. Their son's first name is her husband's grandfather's name (still living) and his middle name is her grandfathers (my father's) name and he is still living, I made them a baby quilt & wrote only the baby's first & last name. Well, my dad was furious since his being the middle name wasn't on the label. I only had so much space, but I think I just didn't feel right putting my father's name on the label. Besides, I know why they chose these names, so grandpa (my dad) would give them money. (I know it's doesn't sound right, but it has turned out to be true) My father seems to forget my grandchildren (also his great grandchildren) whereas he remembers the one with his name.

Parents give your children names that you hope they will be happy to be called. I always hated my American names!

(3) Aviva, January 10, 2017 7:06 PM

advice to in-laws about names

My in-laws interfered with every name we gave. Even when it was a name they wanted, it wasn't good enough for them and if I called a Rivka "Rivki" they carried on like mad ones.

Then came our children's weddings. Again, always interference and blemishing the simcha.

My father-in-law passed away some years ago , my mother-in-law is still alive and continuing to interfere with the names of her great grand-children (my grandchildren).

If any of you parents/in-laws think this is smart, you should know that we all have very bad feelings toward them which go down through the generations. so I would advise you to take Emuna's advice and leave your children alone, unless you don't care how you are remembered.

I have a friend who refused to name any of her daughters after her paternal grandmother because of the misery the grandmother caused her daughter-in-law (my friend's mother.)
So what did that terrible mother-in-law gain? To have her name forgotten.

(2) Anonymous, January 10, 2017 5:10 PM

Daughter In Law Not so Wrong

Re:DIL. I disagree. A few well thought out remarks to son might help before it needs to go to therapy. As you said, it is positive she felt comfortable to approach her MIL. The DIL is seeking help from the one person she believes her husband might listen to. That is why DIL is letting her know the problem. The fact that she is not a therapist is not the issue, nor the fact that she should not be drawn in. The DIL could have confided in friends, business associates etc,. a much worse choice. As both a MIL and DIL, I feel a few gentle remarks to son could help put the marriage on track before it requires far more outside assistance.

(1) Nancy, January 8, 2017 12:28 PM

Names are a very personal issue

I am sorry that the letter writer got so much grief from her family members regarding this issue. Their behavior was egregious.

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub