click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

It's Already Broken

It's Already Broken

If having possessions means living in fear and loss, we are not richer for them.


Yesterday my family buried my great aunt who, at 86, had lived her entire life without owning a home or a car. Her life was characterized by extreme frugality, her character shaped by her childhood in the Depression. When she had moved from the apartment she shared with her husband of 60 years, who predeceased her by just a short time, it was discovered that she had never discarded an empty jar or paper bag. Like many of her generation, nothing was ever wasted. Yet, unable to have children of her own, she never let a great-niece or great-nephew's birthday pass without a card and a check.

Hours later, after the mourners dispersed, I arranged to meet my parents back at my house for a visit. As I turned left onto a narrow street that leads to my home, a woman in a parked car on a cell phone opened her car door into the line of traffic, directly in front of my oncoming car. The front passenger corner of my car caught the outside edge of her open car door. I felt an impact and stopped.

The other car's driver began screaming at me, "It's a brand new car! I just bought it!" She demanded that we make a police report.

I called the police on my cell phone and described the accident.

"Is anyone hurt?" the police asked me.

"No," I responded, "and we both have insurance, but the other participant in the accident is distraught and would like a police report."

The officer suggested we simply exchange insurance information. The woman then called her insurance agent and cried to him, "My new car! My new car! It's been hit!" I also heard her say, grudgingly, "No, I'm not hurt," and "No, she's a nice lady."

The insurance agent asked to speak to me. I explained again that we had had a non-injury accident, and that there was slight damage to the door of her car. (Mine was undriveable.) He asked if there was any damage to the body of her car, or if anyone's airbag had deployed, or if there were skid marks from my car. When I said no to all these questions, he too suggested we simply exchange insurance information.

She then insisted on calling the police herself on her own cell phone. Again, they told her they wouldn't come, which sent her further crying, angrily, "I want a police report! It's a brand new car!" She then called her husband and cried and screamed at him.

"It's very upsetting. Do you need a hug?" She fell into my arms and cried.

She finally agreed to give me her insurance information, crying hysterically the entire time.

"Have you ever been in a car accident?" I asked.


"It's very upsetting. Do you need a hug?" She fell into my arms and cried. Moments later, she seemed to realize that she preferred her distress to the comfort of a hug and pulled away, reviving her tears and screams.

I finally made arrangements to leave the scene, as my father (in his 70s) would by this time be standing outside my home waiting for me, in the harsh Los Angeles summer heat. As I left, she was arranging to have a tow truck come for her car, which she insisted was also undriveable, although the body of the car had not been hit. I somehow got my disabled car home, and then called the tow truck, my agent, my insurance company, and her insurance company to make the necessary reports.

At home with my parents, the discussion tapered off after they confirmed that no one was hurt. An automobile accident with two insured drivers is a financial loss (of the insurance deductible) and an inconvenience, nothing more.

My father lost a brother in World War II, and still recalls the day the military envoy came to tell my grandmother the news. Bombs are exploding in Jerusalem buses and cafes, killing brides and young children. Two years ago, airplanes drove into the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, killing thousands and destroying a nation's sense of security forever. And just that morning, we had buried a childless woman who had lived 86 years without ever owning a car.

It was disturbing that the woman yelled at me so long and so hard, but mostly I just felt sad. What a life she must be living, that this non-injury, minor damage accident between two insured drivers so destroyed her composure. To me, the deductible on my car insurance seemed like a speed bump on the highway of our lives.

One of my favorite authors, Geneen Roth, advises us to treat every new thing as if it is already broken. "The nature of things is that if they don't get lost, they get stolen, and if they don't get stolen, they get broken, and if they don't get broken, they fade or fall apart. This law applies to teacups, cars, people, sweaters, pets, computers, earrings, and just about everything you can touch or buy or have." This simple idea permits us to enjoy things fully when they are new, and not mourn them terribly when they are no longer pristine.

With this in mind, I have tried to live by the maxim that if I know I couldn't bear to lose something, I don't buy it. If I would be upset if a baby spit up on an outfit, I don't buy it, because I'd rather be available to hold a baby than wear the most delicate fabric in the room.

The total price of things is not just the purchase price, but also the energy we expend to protect, preserve, insure and grieve them.

When I drove my car home from the dealer, I deliberately imagined it in an accident to get over the loss of "perfectness" that would inevitably occur, and which of course did occur a month later when I found my car in a parking lot with a gash in it, and no note. Of course I regret the wasted money, but I don't want to add to the loss by missing the beauty of another moment of life while I mourn the paint job on my car.

If having possessions means we live in fear and loss, we are not richer for them.

In Pirkei Avot, the Ethics of the Fathers, it is written, "The more possessions, the more worries." The total price of things is not just the purchase price, but also the energy we expend to protect, preserve and insure them, and to grieve them when they are destroyed or just ravaged by ordinary use or passage of time. The new dress gets torn or stained; the sweater is left behind at school or lost; the book is borrowed and never returned.

Our sages are cautioning us not to be consumed with worry over our possessions, not because we shouldn't care about wasted money, but because after we have spent our money, we lose much more by investing our time, our mind, and our spirit in reliving the loss. In this way, we lose the opportunity to live in the current moment by being attached to material things we have lost.

Like many of her generation, my Aunt Betty lived frugally but died with a substantial net worth, hard-won money from saving carefully of her telephone operator's salary and her husband's pay as a parking attendant. Some people think she was "too cheap" to buy a car. But I can't help thinking Aunt Betty spared herself a lot of grief by taking the bus.

September 13, 2003

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 8

(8) Anonymous, November 7, 2003 12:00 AM

brilliant perspective

I think what you've written is very true - that nothing stays new and perfect forever so why think of things in that way when they will be damaged or worn out more likely than not? If we could assimilate this philosophy into our lives, we'd be much happier and content with life and it's minor 'bumps'.

(7) Yechiel Warman, September 17, 2003 12:00 AM


This reminds of a joke. This lady opens her car door into an oncoming car and hears a loud crash. Her car door came off. She didn't even notice that the car also took off her hand. When the policeman pulled up the lady shrieked 'my car, my car'! The officer turns to her and says 'Lady you are so materialistic, look at your hand'! The lady looks down and screams "Oh my Gosh, MY ROLEX'!

We say in the morning prayers "The one who is merciful on the land. The one who is merciful on the creations." This could be explained in a cute way. Some have mercy on the land (i.e. the floor must be spotless..) and some of have mercy on people.

(6) Anonymous, September 16, 2003 12:00 AM

Hail the philosopher queen!

It's nice to see Ms. Faber add another "hat" to her wardrobe: from lawyer to law-school instructor, stand-up comic, Ghanian teacher, and now philosopher. My goodness gracious, what a multi-talented young lady. Thanks for this very instructive reminder of what's really important in life. P.S.: The other driver is undoubtedly liable for opening her door into traffic. I think you should mail a copy of the article to her.

(5) sarah, September 16, 2003 12:00 AM

A great lesson to learn...

If only more people could learn this lesson! Where I live, most are consumed by their own desires for material things, to the point where you stand out like a beacon if you DON'T worry too much about which car you have, or what clothes you wear, or if you rent your house or own it. It's said that we live in a 'throw away' society, and yet there is a lot of reluctance when it comes to actually parting with something, for whatever reason. Maybe the thing that has become 'throw away' is the ability to acknowledge the difference between what we need and what we want.

(4) Anonymous, September 16, 2003 12:00 AM

A thoughtful reminder to establish and maintain healthy priorities. I mention one exception. Animals (pets) are certainly not to be equated with inanimate, feelingless objects, like old sweaters and tea cups. Life is life, and we are obligated to honor and love all of it. Shelters are filled with discarded, abused and neglected animals, the detritus of people who appear to have absolutely no values or priorities (other than self) at all. Do you really suppose the children of such people fare any better?

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment