click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Mel's Teshuva, and Ours

Mel's Teshuva, and Ours

Owning up to our mistakes, without the excuses.


'Tis the season for many things: Renewal, repentance, re-jew-venation. Jews the world over are busy taking stock, setting new resolutions, and casting high hopes for the year ahead. We are also very busy with forgiveness. We seek and extend forgiveness for any wrongs that we may have committed against each other, whether in thought, word, or deed. The Torah teaches us that to the extent that we forgive others, so God will be forgiving of us.

So, speaking about forgiveness, what about Mel? Do we forgive Mel Gibson for his anti-Semitic outburst this past July, when he was stopped for speeding and DUI? The question is complex:

On the one hand, the Jewish people are known for the trait of kindness. Generosity of spirit and loving-kindness have been hallmarks of every Jewish community throughout history. Do we extend that kindness to Mel?

We also have a strong conviction in the concept of self-transformation through repentance. Even before Creation, God saw that mortal man's path to perfection would be riddled with blunders. To remedy this inevitable situation, God created the mechanism of teshuva -- repentance, through which we would be able "to clean up our mess". The Torah promises us that if we engage in teshuva, we can be granted complete forgiveness from God. So do we now extend forgiveness to Mel, in effect saying that we accept his "teshuva"?

Perhaps absolving Mel would be a wonderful opportunity to demonstrate our tolerance and mercy upon all people, including even those who openly express their enmity towards us.

Yet, we are also a people very committed to the idea of honesty and sincerity. Although it may be noble to dispense forgiveness graciously and freely, there is a limit past which this nobility may start to resemble foolishness. The question then becomes, are we to trust Mel's apology as a sincere one?

An interesting ritual of the Yom Kippur prayers might offer us some perspective on the "Mel Dilemma". There is a custom to pound our fist over our heart during the Viduy – Confession segment of the liturgy. Perhaps a reason for this custom is to bring our awareness to the fact that the root of our mistakes is inside of us. There is no external factor upon which to place the blame -- not environment, not a poor education, nor less-than-perfect parenting. At the end of the day, we must place the accountability for our mistakes squarely upon ourselves. Without the recognition that we are ultimately responsible for our actions, our teshuva is fundamentally flawed, and will not work.

At the moment we take full responsibility for our mistakes, we empower ourselves to fix them.

"Because" is a word that thwarts a lot of well-intentioned teshuva. I lost my temper with the kids because... I was disrespectful to my wife because... "Because" is an introduction to any myriad of excuses. If we could take out that word and just say, "I lost my temper -- and it was wrong of me," we open a doorway to real growth. At the moment we take full responsibility for our mistakes, we empower ourselves to fix them.

Although many have attempted to soften the sharpness of Mel's caustic remarks, contending that the alcohol made him say things he didn't really mean, the well-known dictum in the Talmud disagrees: "When the wine comes in, the secrets come out." In fact, being drunk allowed Mel to say precisely what he really did mean, but would be too afraid/smart to say when sober.

And although Mel did apologize for the harmful repercussions of his hateful words, he has not acknowledged that his vicious words are rooted in their own disease -- not alcoholism, but anti-Semitism. Gibson states, "Please know from my heart that I am not an anti-Semite. I am not a bigot." I'd rather hear Mel say, "I have anti-Semitic viewpoints, but I'd like to change them." A statement like that, along with proactive steps to remedy his warped views, positions Mel for a meaningful dialogue with the Jewish community about forgiveness.


Mel Gibson's hateful comments have drawn much media attention, as well as our own personal attention. We debate about it, argue over it, Google the headlines, and wonder, do we forgive him or don't we? Though I do not wish to minimize the severity of his outburst, and the poisonous effect his words have likely had on many thousands of people who heard them, I wonder if God is as worried about us forgiving Mel as He is about us forgiving each other.

I doubt that on our deathbeds we will tearfully regret forgiving or not forgiving Mel. But perhaps we will regret never getting that last chance to say "I'm sorry" to our spouse, parents, or children. Perhaps we will have great remorse for bearing resentment towards that friend that we stopped calling, that uncle whom we stopped inviting, or that child, from whom we cut ourselves off.

The Gibson incident is an important one, but let's not allow it to distract us from the more important affairs going on right now -- the relationships between us and our loved ones that need a little healing. Let's not allow Mel's deficient teshuva distract us from perfecting our own.

September 24, 2006

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 49

(49) Consuelo, November 7, 2016 1:33 AM


There are people who apologize out of one side of their mouth and then say something else out of the other side So we forgive and we move on to focus on what the Almighty will have us to do Prayerfully Mel"s heart toward us will soften and then he will do real teshuvah and not just say something to get the "Jews" off his back about it..

(48) Aaron, November 6, 2016 3:05 PM

Mel Gibson's Apology

Mel Gibson's case for me is complicated. While drunk in the custody of police, for an alleged DUI, Gibson allegedly made an anti-Semitic remark. That remark by law was confidential at the time, as a part of an arrest record, and it was illegal for any official to release it when it was released. Other than this statement, if you look at Mr. Gibson's movies, he treats women and blacks respectfully and actually made a movie showing South African Embassy's white diplomats as criminals and racists. I am not aware of any movie where Gibson directed or was an actor where he expresses anti-Semitic sentiments. Whether we like his apology or not, he did make an apology.

(47) SUZICLARK, October 15, 2006 12:54 AM

We, ourselves are responsible for our actions, not our food, drink, parents, or any outside influences.

On Mel, it is quite simple. I agree with the Rabbi. Mel is an anti-semite. Mel knows it. He is smart enough, no let's change that to cunning enough and scared of reprisals enough, to not speak his mind when sober. It is not really for me to fogive, it is for my supreme being G-d. I can say I forgive, if it means to no longer burden myself with hate and negativity that he arouses. I can not say I forgive, it it means absolving him and accepting such hate and un-remorseful thoughts and deeds. To me, such disdain, cruelty, prejudice, and stupidity should be pain enough to carry, especially when you know the entire world knows you for who you are Mr. Gibson. The saddest thing of all for him is he thinks he is a good Christian. He can fool himself and wrap himself in a cloak of denial, but he doesn't fool me or any other thinking human on the planet. At least if he could admit what he is, maybe then he could really begin to heal himself. I do believe it is a disease, and unfortunately it is contagious.

I am not that good a person to pray for him, I have just divorced him and his career from my life.

I thank you Mr. Gibson for reminding us we still have evil serpents with forked tongues among us, just dressed up wearing the face of an ordinary person.

(46) RichyG., October 3, 2006 12:06 PM

You said it right!

This is one of the best pieces I have ever read on this website.
Thank you AISH for providing a variety of authors, Rabbi Gelber has a strong message.

(45) Caroly, September 29, 2006 10:28 PM

Only G-d knows our heart

To me unforgiveness is the same as wishing a person in Hell. While a person may not repent to our personal satisfaction, our lack of forgiveness harms our own soul, causing a bitter root. I think it is not for us to decide whether Mel Gibson has "really" repented, but rather to pray that he will use this incident to search his own heart that he might be forgiven by G-d, and live in peace.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment