click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Abuse of Power

Abuse of Power

Does wealth dehumanize people?

by

An interesting experiment took place at Berkeley recently. It involved a game of monopoly - but with unusual rules. (I have a hard enough time holding onto my hotels and railroads with the regular rules!) One player was given $2000 to start and $200 every time he passed Go. The other participant was given half that. Initially the player with the unfair advantage felt uncomfortable. But soon he began to feel powerful and dismissive. Ultimately he became dispassionate and emotionless, focused solely on winning.

The psychologist, Paul Piff, who constructed this experiment, believes it supports his thesis that living high on the socioeconomic ladder dehumanizes people. He suggests that the rich are more selfish and less empathic than others.

This seems to reflect a belief that altruism and empathy are innate qualities, destroyed by life's circumstances, particularly the financial ones. I believe the Torah would suggest otherwise, that people are innately self-centered and lacking empathy and that part of the goal of life is to work to develop these qualities. It is a fundamental tenet of Jewish life that every situation has its challenges - some are unique to being rich and others specific to being poor. Our job is to do the best we can with whatever hand we are dealt.

But back to Professor Piff's experiment. Acknowledging that I don't know all the controls or variables involved, I could suggest a few other possible explanations of the wealthier player's behavior. These are certainly qualities to be concerned about but not as reductive as possessing significant financial resources.

You don't have to rule a country to take advantage of people or brutalize them.

One is the desire for power. From the snake's approach to Eve in the Garden of Eden (Don't you want to be just like God?) and throughout history, we have seen how power can seduce and corrupt. And it doesn't have to be a lot of power. The loan officer at the bank, the TSA worker at the airport, your doctor, the school principal - there are many people in our lives with power and not all of them wield it fairly and reasonably, thoughtfully and considerately.

Some love to lord it over others. You don't have to rule a country to take advantage of people or brutalize them. Sometimes it's more subtle. But whatever small amount of power people have, the tendency is to manipulate and demean others. This is an innate human tendency that we need to fight against. This experiment demonstrates, albeit in a small way, what happens when we are not vigilant in that battle.

There is another Jewish idea that may be at play here: one mitzvah leads to another. If you accustom yourself to doing good deeds, more good deeds will follow. Jewish behavior modification, if you will.

Misusing power and lack of empathy are not the sole purview of the wealthy.

Unfortunately, the opposite is also true: one negative action leads to another . And we get used to them. I still remember a fellow law student who went to work for a large real estate firm after graduation. As part of her job, she needed to evict some elderly tenants from their homes. (I'm not commenting on the legality or social issues here, only the empathy quotient.) The first time she did it, she found it very painful and difficult. She cried in recounting the story. The second time it was easier - no tears. The third time, she was laughing about it.

We are adaptive creatures - for good and for bad. In this experiment, we see how easily we can demean the needs, almost the existence even, of others.

It's too easy to attack the rich. Then we never have to introspect; then we never have to do any work ourselves. But if we look at this experiment from a broader perspective, we can see that we could all fall into this trap, that we all need to be on our guard. Misusing power and lack of empathy are not the sole purview of the wealthy. I don't believe, as Piff says, that "the rich are way more likely to prioritize their own self-interests about the interests of other people." I think this is human nature. It’s a battle we all need to constantly wage.

Published: July 14, 2012


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 29

(23) Anonymous, November 14, 2013 1:11 AM

Very Interesting

Until I moved to the burbs I didn't know rich people could be so kind. So generous, and with so little envy. I met people who inspired me. And made me proud to be Jewish. I also met more than one or two who were very unfriendly. Money changes you if you let it.The part about the person who evicted tenants & got used to it, very very very sad. To the point that I almost wish I didn't read that. But that is how life is, we have the choice to take or give. I choose to receive in order to give away more all the time.

(22) mike north, September 6, 2012 10:22 PM

different values

just heard about a group of Jewish yuppies that flew half the way around the world for the weekend to celebrate a bachelor's party- then I glanced at the local newspaper to see a couple who had no money to celebrate the chagim

(21) Shoshana- Jerusalem, September 3, 2012 6:29 PM

misusing one's power

Soon it will be Yom Kippur. One of the sins which we will confess in the "al chait" list is misuse of one's power: "for the sin that we did before You with chozek yad" . (number 15 on lthe list). I am quoting my Viduy booklet : " Chozek yad is using one's power to harm others in any way. The mere lording over another human being is in itself a sin, for all human beings are created in the image of G-d." Also included is taking advantage of weaker peole.

(20) Lisa, September 3, 2012 3:22 AM

Please sir, without the ego!

In my tiny shul where I am in charge of the " sisterhood" , life was going just fine! All of a sudden they chose ( what I thought was) a really nice normal guy to work with the rest of the shul.... Stand back!! Boy did the power go to his head!! It was scary to see how an ounce of power can turn into a pound of fury & arrogance !

(19) Lordcsmith, July 18, 2012 3:11 PM

Relax

One of the things I've noticed about these kinds of experiments is the scientist tends to have an idea of the result that they want, then they write the experiment that best achieves it. In this instance, someone gave the power-hungry player an advantage. The intention, from the start, is based on an unproven premise: that people are given a continuing unknown advantage throughout life and that is why "you" can't succeed. The underlying emotion is : you're mad because you wish you were getting the advantage. Greed vs. Envy. Neither side will win. So, before you start filling bottles with gasoline and chucking them at the police, you might stop and look at this "evil" system. You plug away at you computer, yap into your iPhone, and munch on your Doritos, and complain about people getting rich. How'd they get rich? By creating the things you decided to spend your money on. You gave them your cash because you wanted what they created. It might help if you recognized your place in this system. You could save, invest, spend wisely, develop a marketable skill and some self-control and you'll have an unfair advantage over the rest of us, but then again, I think that was Enuma's point.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!