Beheading James Foley
click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Beheading James Foley
Chief Editor's Blog

Beheading James Foley

How can I be of the same species as the person who saws off a man's head with a 6-inch knife?

by

Growing up in Toronto I had a tough time imagining that there was a country called the Soviet Union that existed behind some impenetrable iron curtain where innocent civilians lived in fear, held captive by a regime that robbed them of their basic liberties like freedom of press, speech, assembly, religion, conscience, travel, emigration, and property. A government responsible for the death of tens of millions of people who Ronald Reagan called "the evil empire."

It was like the good guys versus the bad guys in Stars Wars, but for real.

I was unsure of the reality of God's existence, but I was equally uncertain of the reality of evil. I was a naïve, sheltered teenager, unable to square the reality that seemingly normal people were capable and willing to murder six million Jews. How could people perpetrate such heinous acts? I remember my father sitting me down before I left home for the first time to study in Israel for the year, and telling me, "Be careful. There are bad people out there." He knew I had a lot of learning to do.

Well I’m no longer so naïve. A cursory look at world history and Jewish history gives ample evidence of the evil man will do. Even one day’s worth of news will suffice. There are plenty people right around the corner from where I live in Jerusalem who would gladly butcher me, and even more a few miles south in Gaza, and even more across the globe.

But there are still times when I am utterly flabbergasted at the sheer monstrosity of evil. That's how I felt today reading about the horrific beheading of journalist James Foley by an ISIS militant. What kind of person can saw off a living man's head with a 6-inch knife? How can he and I be of the same species?

Yet we are. God created human beings with free will; we can do incredible acts of heroism and kindness, and we can do unspeakable evil, harm and degradation. Good and evil are two sides of the same coin. And an educated person with a proper British accent can use that power of choice to decapitate a fellow human being.

How are we to respond to such evil?

The first obvious step is to recognize that it exists. We cannot fight evil if we don’t acknowledge it. The world expressed outrage at the gruesome beheading of James Foley. No one tried to temper the monstrosity of the act or offer mitigating reasons to understand the ISIS murderer. The same clear-eyed abhorrence needs to be expressed at Hamas’ sheer evil of using innocent children as shields in the attempt to kill Israeli citizens. Call a spade a spade; Hamas is sacrificing their children and women, and that is evil.

Secondly, we need to fight against evil. It cannot be tolerated, it cannot be accommodated. Being moral means not remaining silent in the face of injustice. We need to stand up to evil and eradicate it. This applies to the individual who sees the bully at school, the domestic violence next door, the anti-Israel rally in your city. And it applies to the nations of the world who know about genocide in Iraq, Syria, the Congo, the upsurge of virulent anti-Semitism, the threat of radical Islam.

Each and every one of us is given the moral challenge to exercise our free will to build a good life and a just world. And if we refuse to acknowledge evil and fight it, we fail the test.

Edmund Burke once said, “One who confounds good and evil is an enemy to good.” Because my father was right, there really are bad people out there.

Published: August 21, 2014


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 43

(35) Jake, August 28, 2014 2:48 PM

The Western spin to explain this and all the Moslem beheadings

"No one tried to temper the monstrosity of the act or offer mitigating reasons to understand the ISIS murderer." Not true -- starting with the NY Times. The NYT and millions of Western, mostly liberal apologists for Islamic fanatics look the other way while gays, women and Christians, as well as Jews, are murdered and oppressed. The millions who call Israel "fascist" don't utter a single word when ISIS and Boko Haram and Hamas and Hezbollah and the Iranian basij kill tens of thousands of their opponents. And who are their opponents? Women. Gays. Atheists. Non-Moslems.

(34) psmith, August 27, 2014 9:59 PM

Hell has a warm place waiting for the infidel that did this cowardly, base, barbarian, infidel act.

This Isis man will go to Hell and have his head cut off with a dull six inch knife by a demon only to have it grow back and have it cut off again, over and over again for all time. Isn't Isis the name of an Egyptian god? No wonder; they are barbarians and infidels to their own religion.

(33) Anonymous, August 25, 2014 11:52 PM

violence is their creed

No matter what you think,say or do;no matter their education or place of birth,be it in the moon and no matter how much you reform them,they can never change from violence and beastly instincts for that is their belief and the foundation their religion.

(32) ahmed, August 25, 2014 9:54 PM

What are this monsters looking for?using this method to take innocent people's lives.All I know is we can stand up against them all,we are keeping cool to much that is the reason they are spreading across all countries.

(31) kb, August 25, 2014 11:16 AM

There are too many people in armies 'misunderstanding' Islam

IS, Al-Quaida, Boko Haram, Hizballah, FATAH, HAMAS - yes, it's all Islam, read their charter, MORO Resistance fighters, Uighers &....it's happening because they're actually not misunderstanding it at all. They are the devout who are bothered enough to read their own scriptures and follow it to the letter; which shows people aren't basically 'good', as our version of 'good' is merely comparative to those who are less 'good' than ourselves. If Hashem is good, then good means perfect.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!