click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Circumcision in the 21st Century

Circumcision in the 21st Century

Judaism is not a market driven religion.


It’s easy to dismiss the supporters of a November ballot initiative in San Francisco to make it “unlawful to circumcise, excise, cut, or mutilate the whole or any part of the foreskin, testicles, or penis of another person who has not attained the age of 18 years.” Like all true believers, these “intactivists” engage in junk science and exaggerated rhetoric about “male genital mutilation”. Further discrediting the anti-circumcision cause is the fact that the movement’s leadership peddles propaganda that borders on the anti-Semitic, such as the anti-circumcision comic book “Foreskin Man”, which reads like a sophomoric plagiary of a superhero cartoon and Der Sturmer. One could imagine that after November the intactivist movement will quickly pass from center stage. But that would be a mistake.

Circumcision is unsettling. As the actor Russell Crowe wrote on Twitter: "I love my Jewish friends, I love the apples and the honey and the funny little hats but stop cutting yr babies." Despite the politically incorrect tone, Crowe makes it clear why the anti-circumcision movement is here to stay: circumcisions are bloody and make babies cry. Even the committed among us are uncomfortable, and most of us look down nervously when the mohel begins the ceremony. It’s painful to enter the Covenant of Abraham.

Related Article: A Ban on Circumcision?

In the past, circumcision was considered attractive because of its health benefits, and even many non-Jews were routinely circumcised. Today, it’s debatable if circumcision’s health benefits warrant it being a standard procedure. Without a clear medical rationale, non-Jews will stop circumcising their children, and marginally affiliated Jews are sure to follow. The Jewish community can no longer rely on doctors to do the mohel’s job, and regardless of the outcome in San Francisco, it will be a lot harder to convince apathetic Jewish parents to perform circumcisions. Why would any parent want to endure the blood, pain and tears of their baby’s circumcision for no reason?

Circumcision is incompatible with the times, as is much of Judaism. Jews should be proud of how different we are.

In short, circumcision is a marketing nightmare; outside of a deep commitment to Judaism, there’s no good reason to do them. This point is significant, because the Jewish community is intoxicated with marketing. Federations commission countless surveys to find out what young Jews want. Jewish professionals search for ways to make their programs “hipper”. The almighty “social media” must be deployed in the battle for the hearts of the younger members of the tribe. Grant money flows liberally to market driven, cutting edge, jargon laden programs with a social media presence.

I can’t argue against good marketing; representatives of a religion that has prized ideas should be able to communicate well. But there’s a thin line between marketing well and being “market driven”. The market driven vision believes that the customer is always right. So if it’s Yiddish or yoga or Jewish jokes that turn young Jews on, let’s pour community resources into a Yiddish Yoga Yuckfest. (With bagels, lox and cream cheese, of course). Instead of challenging young Jews, a market driven vision of Judaism seeks to produce a 21st century Judaism that will make our customers happy.

But here comes the problem. Aspects of Judaism like circumcision will always be unpopular in customer surveys. If we leave the future of Judaism in the hands of marketing experts, challenging rituals like circumcision or Passover or Yom Kippur will be ignored, and we will end up with a smooth syncretistic mumbo jumbo that has no resemblance to our 3,000 year old tradition.

I’m a modern Orthodox rabbi who talks a great deal about the place of Judaism in the 21st century. But increasingly I’ve come to realize that circumcision is incompatible with the times, as is much of Judaism. But Jews should be proud of how different we are. In an era of unprecedented individualism and hedonism, Jews declare that community is critical, even for an eight day old baby. We take pride in a ritual that affirms that sexual desire is not meant to be left unrestrained, but must be shaped by values of fidelity and devotion. When others seek endless comfort, we are willing to say that doing the right thing might be painful, but it’s still worthwhile.

Over the years, I’ve met inspiring people from the Former Soviet Union who performed circumcisions under heroic circumstances. Defying the Communist dictatorship, they would huddle surreptitiously and perform the covenant of Abraham on children of varying ages. The amazing thing is that these Jews in the FSU had no Jewish education whatsoever. But even with only a rudimentary knowledge of Judaism, they understood that being Jewish means going against the current, and being Jewish requires personal sacrifice.

Even though North American Jews enjoy freedom and prosperity, we need to explain to young Jews that they too have to be willing to defy the spirit of the times to be Jewish. After all, Judaism is more than apples, honey and funny little hats.

July 3, 2011

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 28

(18) Anonymous, July 3, 2012 5:05 PM


I was surprised when my husband who passed away at 81 years of age about his circumcision and his Father wanted this done. We were not married at that time we were engaged. We are not Jewish but both of us agreed with circumcision. My good doctor wanted to know if we had a son would we want circumcision and I said yes knowing my husband would want this just like I did. Of course the baby boy will be sore for a while and this is taken care of. There are enough reasons to have this done if a couple wished to have this done. My son is 44 years old now. This is why I do not want my name to be displayed. No one has the right to tell the Jewish people or others not to do this at all! Don't they read to see the benifits? I am with the Jewish people and others and not those people!

(17) edson, July 17, 2011 9:24 PM

judaism has be respected

the tradition is realy important, i am not jew i am jessenio,and i understand that the important matter is the tradition,the tradition,the tradition.

(16) Anonymous, July 17, 2011 3:14 AM

Last November, we were given the choice by the hospital in which my children were born (and were patients in the NICU) to have our son circumcised while undergoing surgery for something else. Although it was not the bris I imagined, my son was a preemie, and, it being cold and flu season, we wanted him to undergo this important religious ceremony while not being exposed to germs via a celebration. Our solution was thus: we said yes to the circumcision, and, right before the surgery, my father-in-law, a rabbi, said the required prayers and blessings, and named our son. Was it a highly unorthodox bris? Yes. Is my son any less Jewish? In my eyes, no. He and his twin sister (who was later named in a joint Simchat Chai'im) are being brought up in a Jewish home, where we celebrate the Jewish holidays. They will have a Jewish education, attend Jewish camps, become B'nai Mitzvot, and hopefully feel the need, as we did, to marry Jews and raise their own children Jewish. We must educate those as to the health benefits that Hashem has wisely commanded us to follow through circumcision, and maintaining a healthy lifestyle and sustainable planet. We are not mutilists.

(15) Harold, July 12, 2011 12:41 AM

Terrible article!

Okay; he says (or admits) that brit milah may not be consistent with today's secular values. But nowhere in the article does he give the authentic, positive reasons for doing it! All he says is that it makes us different, and it "affirms that sexual desire is not meant to be left unrestrained", and "we are willing to say that doing the right thing might be painful, but it’s still worthwhile". But other rituals already affirm these things. You don't need circumcision to accomplish them.!

Anonymous, June 10, 2014 7:30 PM

missing the point

We don't do brit milah just to affirm "these things." When it comes down to it, we do brit milah because Gd commanded us to. Period.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment