click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Egypt, Ishmael & the Fight for Self-Respect

Egypt, Ishmael & the Fight for Self-Respect

Solving the Palestinian-Israel conflict isn't the lynch pin. Dignity is.

by

A lot has happened in the Middle East and where it is ultimately heading nobody knows. But one thing is for sure – it is now clear that Israel never really was the problem for the frustration on the "Arab street." Numerous so-called experts and politicians have repeated the mantra that if the Palestinian-Israel problem would be solved, then that would be the lynch pin in resolving all the problems in the region. What complete nonsense.

The people who have turned out in the tens of thousands in Egypt, Yemen, Jordan, Tunisia and other countries are not there to protest for their Palestinian brethren. They are there because they are sick and tired of being treated like dogs by their oppressive leaders. They are there because they are finally fed up with living in a part of the world where the leaders have created a culture and life that is arguably the most backward and primitive in the entire world. They are protesting because all they want is to have a little self-respect in their daily lives.

Self-respect and dignity; words that are used over and over again in the Arab world. It is a common theme that appears regularly among the descendants of Ishmael. Judaism always knew this to be true and expressed it by the Torah's description of the events that animate their forebearers, Hagar and Ishmael. Dignity, status and position were central in the lives of the Arab nation from the very beginning.

Related Article: Egypt, Again

Dignity, status and position were central in the lives of the Arab nation from the very beginning.

According to Jewish tradition the mother of this people, Hagar, was a princess of Egypt. She came from royalty and lived a life of opulence. But her father encouraged her to join Abraham's family as a servant figuring "it is better to be a servant to the prophet Abraham than a princess in Egypt." But Hagar was never fully comfortable in that role. The moment the opportunity arose for her to break out of it, she did.

That happened when Abraham, under the insistence of Sarah who was barren, married Hagar who became pregnant right away, something Sarah could not provide. The Torah narrates that she immediately seized on the opportunity that her new status conferred and began to treat Sarah with disdain. This led to friction between the two women and Sarah humbled Hagar and effectively put her back in her place. Alas, Hagar did not wish to return to her previous status so she fled from Sarah. She did not get far before an angel of God appeared and told her to resubmit herself to Sarah's authority. He also told her that she shall give birth to a boy, Ishmael, who will be a "wild-ass of a man whose hand will be against everyone, and everyone's hand against him."

Hagar, demoted from princess to servant, was then promoted to being the wife and progenitor for the great leader, Abraham ― only to be demoted once again and finally dismissed all together with her son later on from the house of Abraham. Hagar and Ishmael, bouncing between two worlds of grandeur and servitude, and never really certain where exactly they belong.

In an article in this week's New York Times mentions:

"The street is not afraid of governments anymore," said Shawki al-Qadi, an opposition lawmaker in Yemen, itself roiled by change. "It is the opposite. Governments and their security forces are afraid of the people now. The new generation, the generation of the Internet, is fearless. They want their full rights, and they want life, a dignified life."

"Dignity" was a word often used Wednesday, and its emphasis underlined the breadth of a movement that is, so far, leaderless. Neither the Brotherhood nor a handful of opposition leaders ― men like Mohammed ElBaradei ― have managed to articulate hopelessness, the humiliations at the hands of the police and the outrage at having too little money to marry...

Indeed this is all the children of Hagar ever wanted, the only thing that Ishmael ever craves – a little honor, some dignity and respect.

Perhaps they will finally get it. If and when they do, maybe, just maybe, they will be happy enough with themselves to finally leave their Jewish cousins alone.

Published: February 6, 2011


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 12

(12) Edwina, August 1, 2014 2:29 PM

We must stand

No one has suffer like the Jews the Jewish people are living in hostile conditions all around them all around them their enemies, remember they want to wipe Israel off the face of the earth given a chance almighty tells Israel never to trust them be strong like king David for God is with you fight on do not be bulled nor shall ever be afford you have every right to exist stand your ground no matter what May GOd Bless Israel always

(11) Baruch, January 18, 2012 1:21 AM

This article is racist and simplisic

Don't we all crave a little respect and dignity? Why is that a distinctly Arab need? It is a value enshrined in Human Rights laws. The streets of New York are full of black eyed youths who 'disrespected' their peers and were made to pay for it with a fisting. So for cry it out loud gimme a break with the 'give the poor, confused Arab kid some respect he craves' . It's just so bigoted. And the last sentence is probably just as bad. The typical Joe average living in an Arab country couldn't give a toss about politics other than as it pertains to his next meal. Any Israeli tourist to Jordan and to other Arab countries can attest to the friendliness of the average man in the street. The first step to peace is for both sides to show each other tolerance, understanding and respect. The kind of prejudiced and antagonistic attitude reflected in this article probably goes some way in explaining why we are quite unloved by many on the other side who view us as quite a condescending, brazen bunch.

(10) charles muchina, February 15, 2011 7:34 AM

Muslims should know the truth to be free from hatred and fear.

GOD created all human being and gave them the capacity to love or to hate.Everything that we do will be brought to judgment. Therefore i urge the Muslim to remove hatred of Jews and Christians from their hearts and koran because GOD will judge them for it,GOD is love and we must love our fellow human being.

(9) Do Lern Hwei, February 12, 2011 8:35 AM

Isaac and Ishmael

There is no reason for the Palestinians and Arabs to demand more dignity and respect. They have a lot to be thankful for and be content. As in the book of Genesis, Abraham had received a prophecy about Ishmael being "the father of 12 princes" ( Gen 17:20) and that his descendents will be a great nation. Isaac had only 2 sons, Jacob and Esau who could not live with each other, but it is also promised that the Messaiah will be a descendant of Isaac.

(8) saul, February 11, 2011 3:52 PM

Comments

Rabbi, Are you trying to say that if Jews give dignity to Muslims then we will get their respect and love in return? Why did God in the first place make Hagar pregnant and if it was known that the would be child be a danger to the future seed of Avraham then why was he permitted to enter this world? Awaiting your feedback.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub