click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Outsourcing Life
Rabbi Benjamin Blech

Outsourcing Life

A look behind the new phenomenon of mourners for hire and friends for rent.


The following story is completely outlandish – and true.

A congregant of a rabbi lost his mother. After the funeral, the man turned to his spiritual leader with a question. "I know that I am now supposed to sit shiva. I'm aware of my religious obligation to stay home and refrain from work for seven days. But this is really my busy season. I’m wondering if it’s possible for me to hire someone to sit shiva for me."

At first I didn’t believe the story, but after reading the remarkable new book by sociologist Arlie Russell Hochschild, The Outsourced Self, I changed my mind. "Mourners for rent" is an outgrowth of the new reality of "personal outsourcing" that is gaining greater popularity and acceptance.

Yes, people today are hard pressed for time and are willing to pay for the privilege of having someone do things for them faster and better instead. I have no problem with people going to an accountant to file their taxes or to a manicurist to file their nails. Outsourcing these onerous tasks are well deserved benefits of being able to afford them.

But in addition to mourners for hire, the following intimate life services are now available: friends for rent, grandmas for rent, holiday gift buyer, photo album assembler, gravesite tenders, dog walkers, personal chefs, closet organizers, interactive motivators at parties, potty trainers, thumb-sucking specialists, dating service checkers, nameologists, wantologists and so much more.

What’s a nameologists? That's a specialist who will expertly guide you to the right name to give to your newborn child, which will save you from the difficult task of choosing a beloved ancestor whose memory you want to perpetuate. And what's a wantologist? That’s someone you can hire to help you figure out what you really want! (I'm not making this up.)

The common denominator in all of this outsourcing – from the personal to the commercial realm – is the tragic loss of the emotional component that ought to be the key to our relationships. The gift that I buy for a loved one because I chose it expresses my feelings far better than what my "holiday gift buyer" expert deems perfect because it's in fashion. The photos I put together in my album may not be the ones chosen by the “professional photo album assembler," but they will reflect the memories precious to me as I see them, not the ones I'm told to treasure by a stranger.

And the incredible category of "friends for rent" – have we lost all sense of the very meaning of the word friend? According to the ancient proverb, friends are one mind in two bodies. By the friend-for-rent standard, they are no more than a commercial transaction between a payer and a payee.

Related Article: The Cheerio King

Transferring Emotional Involvement

Jewish law long ago set the parameters for when it is permissible to delegate a task and when personal responsibility trumps this possibility. There is the role of a “shaliach” in Hebrew, a personal agent that acts on your behalf in certain situations. A writ of divorce, for example, may be sent from husband to wife by way of a messenger. The goal here is merely to have something delivered.

But when the great 18th-century Rabbi Yechezkel Landau, known by the name of his greatest work Noda B’Yehudah, was asked why the Talmudic principle of "the agent of a person is like himself” wouldn't apply to delegating someone to perform a mitzvah on his behalf, he clarified the distinction by way of a simple concept: A responsibility predicated on personal and emotional involvement can never be passed over to another. The person must perform it himself.

No one can listen to the shofar for you. You would never personally experience its call to repentance. No one can sit in the sukkah in your stead. You would not gain the feeling of the frailty of the walls you count on to protect you and your total dependence on the heavens beneath which you dwell. No one can put on tefillin – the phylacteries bound on hand and head – for you. It is the works of your hand and the thoughts of your mind that must be made subservient to the greater power of God.

Mourning requires personal grieving. The tears must be our tears.

So too, the mourning process for our departed loved ones requires personal grieving. The tears must be our tears. They cannot be counterfeit products of purchase. Any mitzvah rooted in emotion demands that it not be delegated.

It’s a mistake to think that professionals who get paid will do everything better. When it comes to the most important relationships of life, the most meaningful expressions of what we believe, as well as the most powerful demonstrations of our spiritual values, God has commanded us personally.

We are to be good parents.

We are to be faithful and loving mates.

We are to be supportive and grateful children.

Attaining the inspiration, elevation and refinement that comes through fulfilling the mitzvahs can’t be done by proxy. There are no shortcuts to spiritual growth. We need to take the time and care to be personally engaged and perform these treasured tasks ourselves.

June 23, 2012

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 11

(7) SusanE, June 26, 2012 4:03 PM

Everything That Money Can Buy.

Full time Nannys, Professional escorts, Tutors, Coaches, Child Psychologists, Marriage counselors, Interior Decorators, Wedding and Bar Mitzvah Guests, Mourners, the list of people who are for hire goes on forever. Including hiring Food and Cleaning servants for Passover and Hanukkah, and Yom Kippur. These are accepted practices, but not sure if that makes them ethical decisions if you simply don't want to do the required work yourself. Many don't want to go to the trouble of fixing anything about personal actions, personal characters or personal responsibilities. Time restraints is not a valid reason for not attending or for not doing a mitzvah and hiring someone in your place.. So... mourners and 'friends' for rent hired by people who won't do the work themselves will exhibit the character of those people. There can be great dignity in small numbers. There can be even greater dignity in doing ones' own personal best. Money can't buy dignity. (Moses didn't hire a mountain climber)

(6) Inbar, June 25, 2012 3:27 PM

pray for such people

How terrible it must be to be so far from your self. Please pray for this person - and let us also pray that we do not make this mistake, too!

(5) Anonymous, June 25, 2012 12:37 AM


While saying Kaddish for my mother, a man in shul said to me, you know, you can hire someone to say Kaddish for you. I was horrified at the prospect. As a woman, I felt it my duty to say Kaddish for my mother who both gave me life and who selflessly dedicated hers to her husband and children. She also raised 3 children without the help of a nanny or llivein, but by her own determination to raise law-abiding educated children. She did her own ironing, cooking and everything else and later even had a partner in business. She was also my best friend. So hire someone to say Kaddish, not on your life. And by the way, i repeated this again 2 years later for my father. Though my dad religiously attended shul excuse the pun, whereas I do not, my feeling is that at the very least, I could honour my parents by taking time out of my day (I went to work after services). to show them the respect that they deserved. If one is physically able to do so, I dont buy it that a person is too busy that they couldn't do this too, I think it comes down to the fact that if one does not make the time to do so, one has simply chosen not to do so.

(4) Deborah Bach, June 24, 2012 6:06 PM

Yes and

Wonderful article. And I would like to add that that if I'm not mistaken someone who suffers from an illness such as Parkinson's can have someone help him wrap the Tfillin around his own body.

Anonymous, June 25, 2012 4:22 PM


There are many handicapped people who are not able to put on tfilin by themelves, and it it %100 permitted and proper to do this for them. Because in the end result, it is the handicapped man himself who is wearng the tfilin, and not the helper. Noone can wear the tfillin for him but they can and should put them on for him.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment