click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Radio Prank Gone Wrong

Radio Prank Gone Wrong

Kate Middleton's nurse and the unpredictable consequences of one’s actions.

by

By now you’ve probably heard: Two radio hosts in Australia – pretending to be Queen Elizabeth and Prince Charles – phoned the London hospital where Kate Middleton was recovering from hyperemesis gravidarum (“serious morning sickness”).

Jacintha Saldanha, a 46-year-old nurse, was manning the hospital switchboard and connected them to a second gullible nurse who provided details of Kate's condition.

As recordings of the prank call rocketed around the Internet, she surely felt like a laughing stock and a failure – “traumatized” according to hospital sources.

Three days later, Jacintha committed suicide.

In the days since there's been a torrent of criticism directed at the DJs, Mel Greig and Michael Christian. Their radio station issued an abject apology and suspended the pair indefinitely.

Jacintha SaldanhaThe opprobrium seems logical, but would we still be indignant if somehow Nurse Saldanha had not killed herself? What would we be saying if Mrs. Saldanha was still utterly miserable, embarrassed and depressed, but had stopped short of that dramatic suicidal step?

If Mrs. Saldanha had never had her second, fatal, brush with fame, it's fair to say that most of the world would still be laughing over the improbable joke: a pair of goofy Australians, with terrible English accents, tricking a gullible nurse into divulging medical details on the air. After the hoax, one of the radio hosts said: "This is by far the best prank I've ever been involved in… it's definitely a career highlight."

From reality shows to morning radio, laughing at someone else’s expense is a common guilty pleasure.

Rhys Holleran, CEO of the radio station, defended the whole thing as a joke which never intended such an outcome. ”I think prank calls as a craft in radio have been going for decades... No one could have reasonably foreseen what ended up being an incredibly tragic day.”

Holleran also emphasized that the station had done nothing illegal.

But that’s surely not the point. Whether TV shows with hidden cameras or any comedy aimed at embarrassing others, the media has frequently overstepped its bounds. In its pursuit of sensationalism and big headlines, the media pushes the ethical envelope – and in some instances pushes way too far.

Our decisions in life have to be based on more than just what’s technically legal or on “what we can get away with.”

Time to Stop

The Torah has a lot say about this type of humor. Specifically, we are instructed not to startle people. We're not to embarrass them. We're not to speak negatively of others, even as part of a joke. We're not to laugh at others' expense. We're not to shame them.

The Jewish people are known for their great sense of humor, but our Sages long ago realized that the temptation to make fun of others in search of a joke – while may be funny at the time – ultimately cheapens and degrades us.

Humor reveals whether a person is refined or coarse.

The Talmud teaches that humor is one of the essential ways we can know another person's nature. It's a window into their truest essence. It reveals whether a person is refined or coarse, and how sensitive they are to the needs and feelings of others.

Here are four steps to start working on ourselves today.

  1. What do you find funny? Spend some time thinking about the jokes you tell and laugh at. What do they say about you? Do you routinely find yourself laughing at others' expense?
  2. Drop the sarcasm. It's destructive and tears people – including the speaker – down.
  3. Avoid humor that alienates. It's easy to feel that celebrities or people on TV contests (remember “The Gong Show”?) are asking to be made fun of, but this prevents us from viewing others as real people, with real needs and feelings.
  4. You never know. The Talmud (Bava Metzia 58b) compares one who humiliates another person to one who sheds their blood. People react differently to circumstances and they may not see the funny side of a prank. Sometimes people laugh along at jokes at their own expense, but humor can do lasting damage in the guise of fun.

Further: Despair is not a Jewish concept. Situations often look hopeless, we see no way out – but circumstances can change. As bad as things might be, redemption may be right around the corner. And it often is.

In the Kate Middleton case, there was a confluence of factors: a breakdown in hospital security, a vulnerable nurse, and a media more concerned with cheap “entertainment” than the adverse affect their actions may have on others. The result was a moral failing and, ultimately, disaster.

Those of us striving to be sensitive and caring should foreswear once and for all  indulging in any form of toxic humor.

Published: December 9, 2012


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 32

(22) Jerry, February 7, 2013 8:31 PM

This authors here just keep...

...surprising me with their insights. This has redefined the way I look at "humor". Our American society is immersed in this laughing at someone else's expense. A clear example is the singing competitions where it's not enough to sarcastically destroy someone's hopes, but then shove a camera in their face as they're trying to run away from the humiliation. Thank you Yvette Alt Miller for opening my eyes. I'm ashamed I've not only partaken in this mess, but laughed right along with it.

(21) As the Chofetz Chaim reminds and warns us, December 17, 2012 8:23 AM

Sadly a typical example of Mishlei 18:21

Death and Life are in the power of the tongue

(20) Brian Bergman, December 12, 2012 7:38 PM

We are instructed not to startle people...

People defending this prank and the cheap humor offered by radio and 'reality' television shows are missing the point. "We're not to laugh at others' expense. We're not to shame them." Our character is often defined by WHAT we laugh at. Jacintha Saldanha is not the point, what you laugh at is...

(19) Christopher, December 12, 2012 5:02 AM

Nurse Suicide

All this nurse did was answer a phone and transfer a call; the whole incident was already forgotten and no one remembered her name in any event; more is going on in this nurse's life than meets the eye. If she was that fragile then anything could have triggered such an horrendous event: don't blame the radio people

Sheldon Liberman, December 12, 2012 6:44 PM

It is perfectly foreseeable...

...that the person you are trying to embarrass might be someone who has other issues. We all have them to one extent of the other, and the very fact that you would even defend someone who builds himself through the embarrassment of others makes you a gold card member of that category.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub