click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Thanking the Invisible Hand

Thanking the Invisible Hand

Thanksgiving weekend is made possible by a vast number of strangers. Don’t take it for granted.


Gratitude to the Almighty is the theme of Thanksgiving, and has been ever since the Pilgrims of Plymouth brought in their first good harvest. "Instead of famine, now God gave them plenty," Governor William Bradford later wrote, "and the face of things was changed to the rejoicing of the hearts of many, for which they blessed God."

The annual presidential Thanksgiving proclamations always invoke God, and they frequently itemize the blessings for which we owe Him thanks.

"Let us remember," urged Andrew Johnson in 1867, "that He has covered our land... with greatly needed and very abundant harvests; that He has caused industry to prosper, not only in our fields, but also in our workshops, in our mines, and in our forests. He has permitted us to multiply ships upon our lakes and rivers and upon the high seas, and at the same time to extend our iron roads to far into the secluded places of the continent... He has inclined our hearts to turn away from domestic contentions and commotions... and to walk more and more in the ancient ways of loyalty, conciliation, and brotherly love."

Today, in millions of homes across the nation, God will be thanked for many gifts – for the feast on the table and the company of loved ones, for health and good fortune in the year gone by, for peace at home in a time of war, for the incalculable privilege of having been born – or having become – American.

But it probably won't occur to too many of us to give thanks for the fact that the local supermarket had plenty of turkey for sale this week. Even the devout aren't likely to thank God for airline schedules that made it possible for some of those loved ones to fly home for Thanksgiving. Or for the arrival of Skyfall at the local movie theater in time for the holiday weekend. Or for that great cranberry-apple pie recipe in the food section of the newspaper.

Those things we take more or less for granted. It hardly takes a miracle to explain why grocery stores stock up on turkey before Thanksgiving, or why Hollywood releases big movies in time for big holidays. That's what they do. Where is God in that?

And yet, isn't there something wondrous – something almost inexplicable – in the way your Thanksgiving weekend is made possible by the skill and labor of vast numbers of total strangers?

To bring that turkey to the dining room table, for example, required the efforts of thousands of people – the poultry farmers who raised the birds, of course, but also the feed distributors who supplied their nourishment and the truckers who brought it to the farm, not to mention the architect who designed the hatchery, the workmen who built it, and the technicians who keep it running.

The bird had to be slaughtered and defeathered and inspected and transported and unloaded and wrapped and priced and displayed. The people who accomplished those tasks were supported in turn by armies of other people accomplishing other tasks – from refining the gasoline that fueled the trucks to manufacturing the plastic in which the meat was packaged.

The activities of countless far-flung men and women over the course of many months had to be intricately choreographed and precisely timed, so that when you showed up to buy a fresh Thanksgiving turkey, there would be one – or more likely, a few dozen – waiting. The level of coordination that was required to pull it off is mind-boggling. But what is even more mind-boggling is this: No one coordinated it.

No turkey czar sat in a command post somewhere, consulting a master plan and issuing orders. No one rode herd on all those people, forcing them to cooperate for your benefit. And yet they did cooperate. When you arrived at the supermarket, your turkey was there. You didn't have to do anything but show up to buy it. If that isn't a miracle, what should we call it?

Adam Smith called it "the invisible hand" – the mysterious power that leads innumerable people, each working for his own gain, to promote ends that benefit many. Out of the seeming chaos of millions of uncoordinated private transactions emerges the spontaneous order of the market. Free human beings freely interact, and the result is an array of goods and services more immense than the human mind can comprehend. No dictator, no bureaucracy, no supercomputer plans it in advance. Indeed, the more an economy is planned, the more it is plagued by shortages, dislocation, and failure.

It is commonplace to speak of seeing God's signature in the intricacy of a spider's web or the animation of a beehive. But they pale in comparison to the kaleidoscopic energy and productivity of the free market. If it is a blessing from Heaven when seeds are transformed into grain, how much more of a blessing is it when our private, voluntary exchanges are transformed – without our ever intending it – into prosperity, innovation, and growth?

The social order of freedom, like the wealth and the progress it makes possible, is an extraordinary gift from above. On this Thanksgiving Day and every day, may we be grateful.

This article originally appeared in The Boston Globe.

November 17, 2012

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 8

(6) Joey, November 25, 2012 9:40 PM

Interesting thoughts! We should thank God for all the little miracles He sends us, inclding through other people. Thanks for writing. ;-) God bless!

(5) Anonymous, November 25, 2012 2:57 AM

Invisible hand doesn't hear

The reason we thank G-d is because if He exists, He HEARS us. My thanking the turkey growers, truckers and architects from my dinner table is irrational; they can't hear me. It's important to appreciate the "invisible hands" that drive our economy and provide for our well being but it can't be compared to thanking Hashem.

(4) Anonymous, November 23, 2012 6:05 AM

Turkey day

No, this wrong. the holiday of thanks giving is actually a celebration of a massacre. Meaning the the pilgrims who came to America wanted to end indigenous life in the Americas, As Jewish we are all about L'Chaim! We give thanks to G-d every day, we dont need thanksgiving as a reminder.

(3) Simon, November 19, 2012 3:03 PM

God commands a blessing to Unity, God help us stay united.

In the book of Psalms 133 How nice all the faces we see around the table during thanksgiving dwell in unity regardless of the differences, who knows what God's blessing will entail - l pray for peace to the children of Sarah, all of them. That the temper-atures will calm down and that the cake of blessings be eaten in Peace. Happy Thanksgiving Day. Thank you our loving Father for seating at the head of the table, shoveling blessings to all of us in your perfect Love and Peace that is beyond our understanding.

(2) Melanie Vliet, November 18, 2012 6:04 PM

And What Does the Turkey Have for which to Be Thankful?

This article concentrates on our privilege of eating turkey. Although I admit that I shall likely eat some turkey Thursday, I am not proud of it. What right do we have to end a life unnecessarily? We should all give serious thought to the cruelty of our eating habits and to the possibility of altering them.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment