click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




The Cult of Self Esteem

The Cult of Self Esteem

In real life, not everyone is a winner.

by

June isn't just a perfect time for weddings; it’s also the season for caps and gowns.

Our calendars seem to be filled with invitations to participate in the glorious moment of graduation for our children, as well as the progeny of our families, our friends and our loved ones.

Today the pomp and ceremony of graduations start with kindergarten. Every small step of maturation is accompanied by the pageantry of public rejoicing and the seemingly indispensable awards handed out for excellence in almost every imaginable category.

Who could possibly find any fault with these universal happy occasions filled with more and more opportunities to pay tribute to our youngsters?

Well, I don't want to sound like a grouch, but somebody has to point out one of the unfortunate consequences of what appears to be our unqualified – and very often our undeserved - outpourings of praise for our children.

It was a front page “think piece" story in the New York Times last week that led me to my conclusion. In a fascinating analysis of public response to current Broadway plays, Ben Brantley, the Times theater critic, bewailed the recent practice of standing ovations for any and every play, no matter what their merit.

What particularly disturbed him was, as he put it, that "We really reached the point at which a standing ovation doesn't mean a thing. Pretty much every show you attend on Broadway these days ends with people jumping to their feet and beating their flippers together like captive sea lions when the zookeeper arrives with a bucket of fish. This is true even for doomed stinkers that find the cast taking their curtain calls with the pale, hopeless mien of patients who just received a terminal diagnosis."

Brantley doesn't understand the phenomenon. Why do audiences who have every reason to demonstrate disapproval for an obviously inferior work rise to their feet as if they had just witnessed a masterpiece? Why must everything be acknowledged with the kind of praise that ought to be earned instead of indiscriminately granted?

I think one of the respondents hit the nail on the head. It isn't just something about our reaction to plays on Broadway. It's a far more profound reflection on an attitude that has become part and parcel of our culture, in particular with regard to the way in which we relate to our children.

In a letter following the appearance of the article, a reader offered the suggestion that it's actually the result of the "everyone's a winner" culture that infects our child worshiping society of "affirmation." If you don't praise every child to the skies, no matter how poor his or her performance, you are considered "overly critical" and "unsupportive." For more than a decade we've been guided by the mantra that what children need most is to be lauded for their effort; results don't really matter. Not strange at all then that this becomes our standard for other areas of life as well.

The truth of the matter though is that effort is bound to fail if every action is equally lauded. Why struggle to be better if even the mediocre is more than satisfactory?

There are school systems today which don't allow sports that keep score because no one should ever feel the bitter taste of being a loser. In similar vein, the new policy of many progressive educational institutions is to eliminate the selection of a valedictorian, to spare the hurt of any runner-ups for the honor who were unsuccessful in achieving it.

Everyone has to be a winner.

Winners are those who struggle harder.

But that's not the reality of life. Nor should it be. Winners are those who struggle harder. Winners are those who have learned that achievement comes at a price, with heavy demands for personal sacrifice.

I don't want my doctor to be someone who never took his work seriously but kept being passed - and even praised - just because he or she felt a calling to go to medical school. I want the people who I respect and who I need to help me by way of their professional expertise to have been judged, criticized, and evaluated by the tough standards that would make them competent to fulfill the demands of their jobs.

And I don't want my children to be rewarded unnecessarily to the point where they believe that everything is coming to them just because they're breathing.

I personally think parents share some of the blame when they make it clear that they take it as a personal insult if their "one and only" doesn't walk away with some kind of certificate of achievement at a graduation ceremony. Not everyone deserves a standing ovation. But those moments also serve as points of inspiration. They make clear what is possible for those who aspire to greatness. They indicate how life rewards those who achieve the maximum. And instead of "dumbing down" expectations by honoring everyone equally, we ought to take pride in the role models who deserve to be winners.

So my advice to all of this year's graduates is to be grateful for what they have accomplished, but at the same time to find inspiration from those who have done better. Success is achieved not by envying those with greater achievements but rather by emulating them.

And our role as observers ought to be guided not by constantly heaping undeserved honor no matter the effort, but rather of giving wise counsel and criticism until we create disciples who truly deserve standing ovations.

Published: June 2, 2012


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 39

(23) Russel, June 10, 2012 11:12 PM

Self-Esteem???

You may be right in calling this the CULT of self-esteem. I believe the term self-esteem was coined by Nathaniel Branden and he should be considered the father of self-esteem and true self-esteem has NOTHING to do with the "everybody is a winner" nonsense perpetuated in schools and elsewhere. “Self-esteem is the reputation we acquire with ourselves.” ― Nathaniel Branden The key elements of self-esteem, Branden tells us, are self-efficacy, which is "a sense of basic confidence in the face of life's challenges," and self-respect, "a sense of being worthy of happiness." It is not an emotion which fluctuates from moment to moment, but a continuing disposition to experience a sense of efficacy and respect for oneself. Thus, it is something which is built over a long period of time, not just wished into existence. It is reality-based; undeserved praise, whether it comes from oneself or others, will not provide it. Just about every library i know has at least one of his books.

(22) Anonymous, June 6, 2012 10:58 PM

Jewish celebrations...

Some of the most profoundly joyous occasions are celebrated without accomplishment: birth/bris/kiddush, bar/bat mitzvah, weddings: these are not celebratory rewards for effort or achievement, but milestones, markers of significant passages in life. These as well as what seems like "achievement" (graduations, siyumim) are all just expressions of gratitude to G-d of "shehechyanu"- thank u for getting me to this time and place. And yes, celebrating life, joy, potential, and even doting on it, builds satisfaction and good health.

(21) Anonymous, June 6, 2012 10:20 PM

Rabbi Blech, as usual, right on!

The Rabbi is right on in what he says but what I am about to say should not be seen as part of his message. The self-esteem industry's big proponents were Ayn Rand, atheist, and her adulterous boyfriend, atheist Nathaniel Branden. Adultery was not a problem for either one since it could be explained by the self-esteem ethic until Branden fooled around on Rand (and his wife). Then it became a problem for the self-esteem stars. Our society is as massed up morally as it is because of the self-esteem movement. Self-esteem movement would like to tell you that things are messed up because of lack of self-esteem. Wrong! They are messed up because of self-esteem. Psychology is the new secular religion (Fromm). Its god is the self. And self-esteem is the way to that god. The new mitzvot are being lovable regardless of how we behave; being admirable regardless what we do; being deserving even though we treat others poorly. We have wants which automatically guarantees us rights. Nobody had better stand in the way of our needs and wants. People (read - things) are there to ensure that we get what we want. If not, then we have been victimized. I can go on but it is refined idolatry. Remember teshuva? Well, do you really need it if you have self-esteem? If you do something wrong (sorry, that is an abusive term) you are just growing. You see, even though we require scientific proof for everything, when it comes to self-esteem, we don't need it. It does not matter that our new secular psychology cannot even define the self or that no scientific experiments have ever been done on this. Why? Because we are dealing with values. If they could be done then there would not be atheists. The faster we accept this the better we shall get rid of this god of self.

(20) L.S., June 6, 2012 1:21 PM

Thank You!

The other day, I JUST put a Facebook post recently about how I am sick and tired of the self-esteem movement nonsense. I am sick of a world where everyone is a winner, everyone is beautiful, everyone is smart, special, etc. There ARE winners and losers in life, and I am sick of everything being glorified as an accomplishment. REAL accomplishment comes from hard work, innovation, and intelligence. We've become a nation of whiners and I am sick and tired of it. Thank you Rabbi Blech for putting this all out in the open.

(19) Anonymous, June 6, 2012 12:01 AM

Oy...

R. Blech's thought-provoking articles generally resonate with me, but this one really irked me. Would that our society's worst problem were too much positive feedback! If only the worst evil was unconditional goodwill! Yes, we've become soft. Yes, we tip rude waiters, applaud poor performances, and gush at our children's trivial displays of goodness or occasions. But life is short, let's save critical articles for what's really wrong with the world and cut people who really just want to be kind, even if it's in overdose, some slack. And btw, winners are not necessarily those who work harder; theyare often simply those gifted with greater talent, privilege and opporunity. So yes, equality as a value is imperfect, but it trumps intolerance and hypercriticism any day.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub