What Was Aish.com Thinking?
click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




What Was Aish.com Thinking?
Chief Editor's Blog

What Was Aish.com Thinking?

Readers want to know: Why did Aish.com post Tal Fortgang’s article, “Checking My Privilege”?

by

Many readers were flabbergasted that Aish.com posted Tal Fortgang’s article “Checking My Privilege.” The article generated a flood of comments and debate. While some readers agreed with the brunt of the article (including some African-American readers), many readers took offense at the Princeton student’s apparent lack of empathy, vehemently disagreeing with his position.

And some asked “What was Aish.com thinking?” Others said that we should avoid controversial pieces and just stick to the inspirational articles that we’re very proficient at. Are we posting inflammatory articles just for the sake of controversy?

Well, here’s what we were thinking. A dedicated supporter of the site sent me a link to the article days before the piece went viral and was posted on Time magazine. Tal was not yet the whipping boy in one article after another on various websites.

The primary message I got from the article was: We should all be judged as individuals. "Reverse discrimination" and labeling of any kind is shallow and hurtful. We don’t really know anyone’s back story. And I appreciated the Jewish angle and connection to the Holocaust. I did not think he was denying the disadvantages minorities have; he was expressing his resentment of being unfairly labeled as well.

It was an interesting take on prejudice that I thought was thought-provoking, and would serve as an effective launching point for discussion. Could Tal have done a better job at showing more sensitivity and giving a more nuanced argument? Yes, but chalk that up to youth (he’s only a freshman) and readers will appreciate his primary point that we should not discriminate against anyone, including white males.

Out of Hand

The Internet, unfortunately, has generated two serious drawbacks that I think are to some extent at play here. The first is that we don’t read as carefully as we used to; we quickly scan a piece instead and get just a superficial read of the article. As Nicholas Carr has argued, “Google is making us stupid.” We are forgetting how to slow down and read carefully. Our attention spans are in decline, as any teacher will tell you.

I wonder how many readers, before dismissing the piece out of hand, actually understood the main point that Tal Fortgang was trying to make. (This also helps to explain how readers could think that Aish.com was defending Donald Sterling’s racist rant by posting Jeff Jacoby’s article which clearly denounced it.)

The second issue to be aware of is that the Internet creates what Eli Pariser calls a “filter bubble,” where we stay inside a constricted universe of information that conforms to our previously held views. Search engines filter information, giving us results based on our Internet habits that offer content we are more likely to agree with. We stay inside our insular group of Facebook friends and are rarely exposed to contrary positions that force us to think. (Click here to watch Eli Pariser’s Ted Talk where he explains this phenomenon in more detail.)

Readers may disagree with Tal Fortgang; you don’t have to agree with every article on Aish.com. We think it’s productive to post thought-provoking articles that spark a discussion. We don’t only post inspirational stories on Aish.com. Our mandate is to encourage people to think about important issues of the day affecting Jews, Judaism and Israel. And many issues are not cut and dry; there is room for debate.

And yes, we'd be willing to post a rebuttal to Tal’s article.

Click here to read other recent blog entries:

Published: May 12, 2014


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 60

(51) moriah, May 19, 2014 1:12 AM

Shoking is right

Shocking that anyone took offense to such a blatant truth. Shocking that there are some people that don't see that minorities, African Americans in particular have carte blanche when it comes to punishing White people for wrongs done in the past. Jews were once slave and we're forced to wander through the desert until the slave mentality died out and people were able to think like free men. Maybe if we'd had a political party who told us we couldn't make it without welfare, HUD, affirmative action, and all the other so-called 'entitlements' that come from the political parties who want to maintain their voting leverage- we'd still be wandering that barren desert. Here is the Emes. If it weren't for White America, Barack Obama would not have had two terms in office because without the White vote he never would have gotten elected.

Milly, May 30, 2014 10:48 PM

Really

I am African American and I take offense to your comment. I have and never will blame any race for the things my ancestors or myself have endured. Yes, we are still passed over and degraded on a daily basis. Other groups also face the same daily battle. I hope you realize that most people on welfare are white. Affirmative action now includes white women as minority. Yes, President Obama would not have had two terms in office without the white vote, but he would not have had two terms without the BLACK vote either. You seem pretty angry and I don't know why. I really hope you are not Jewish. In reading the articles on this site they portray Jewish people as joyful and giving people. It seems that they leave the judging to God. I agreed with most of the article, but to say that America does not look at race is absurd. My help comes from God. Man can deny the physical and material, but not the spiritual. God supplies the increase!
Have a Blessed Day :-)

(50) Gary Rosen, May 18, 2014 6:49 AM

Flabbergasted

Tal's article was wonderful. I am for more "flabbergasted" that anyone, especially anyone Jewish, would object to it. Several years ago I wrote something similar, though not nearly as eloquent, in response to a controversy that erupted at Duke University when an opinion piece was published in the school newspaper complaining about Jewish "privilege".

(49) Anonymous, May 17, 2014 3:15 PM

Great!

Could not agree more! Thank you for posting this!

(48) Leah, May 15, 2014 3:53 PM

What was Aish thinking? Aish was and is thinking correctly. Please, may Aish continue to think correctly as they have been doing for decades. Hats off to Aish!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!