click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




13 Reasons Why Pushback
Q&A for Teens

13 Reasons Why Pushback

By committing suicide, Hannah Baker took the selfish route that hurt many people, most of all herself.

by

Dear Lauren,

I don’t want to give life a chance anymore.

Lauren Roth

Lauren Roth's Answer

Dear readers, I did receive this email about a year ago, from across the world. And she and I still email each other to this day. I think we exchanged four short emails just today (hers were long, mine short, but loving).

Why do we still email? Because she chose to live.

I just finished reading 13 Reasons Why (Please note: I’m writing about the book 13 Reasons Why, not the Netflix series. It could be that the movie version depicts the ideas differently.) and like many readers, I was sorely disappointed. Disappointed that Hannah chose to take her own life. Yes, you read that right: chose. Judaism teaches us the most important lesson of all: we are responsible for choosing our own actions.

I’m getting quite tired of the “poor me, I’m a victim” mentality in our culture. I really, really understand that being an adolescent is very, very hard. Hey, I understand that being a living human being is often very, very hard. But shying away from difficulties, running away from our responsibility to keep on keeping on? I don’t believe in that.

There are so many things I would want to tell Hannah Baker. In fact, I’ve told many of them to my across-the-world email friend. Things like: “this too shall pass.” Most difficulties in life do. We think high school will last forever, in all of its awfulness, but it won’t. We think we’ll be in our painful situation forever, but usually we’re not. Usually, life has great difficulties and life has beautiful moments, and “this too shall pass.”

I remember when I was in high school, and a friend of mine said: “They say high school years are the best years of your life. If these are the best years of my life, I’m completely messed up.” Just as he said that, I realized: high school years might be good years for some people, but for most of us, they were (are) really tough times. You don’t have much control over whom you spend most of your day with, you don’t have much control over where you have to be and when, and you don’t have a mature enough sense of self to be okay in any social situation thrown at you.

I promise you: This too shall pass.

Hannah Baker chose not to stick it out. It was a selfish decision on her part, one that hurt many people. God gave us our life, and we are not allowed to kill ourselves. I know the pain can, at times, seem unbearable. But sticking it out is doing the courageous and kind and strong thing. For ourselves and for those around us.

Hannah could have grown up to have a lovely life, helping many other people because of the difficulties she had endured and survived. Taking herself away was selfish and weak.

I know it’s a simplistic example, but I’m going to use it anyway, because it illustrates the point so well. My parents came to visit us for a week. They had concert tickets, weddings to attend, grandchildren and children to go and visit.... My father hurt his back just before their trip (moving tables and chairs in their synagogue with the 20-year-olds!) and spent the entire week on his back on the bed in our guest room, in a tremendous amount of pain. He missed the concerts. He missed the weddings. He couldn’t even sit up, stand, or walk without searing pain.

How do you think you or I would react if we were in that situation? I think I, personally, might have a lot of grumbling and complaining going on. Not my father. He was good-natured, kind, polite, gentle. Whatever I brought him to eat was fine! Whenever we came to visit was fine! Whenever we left was fine! No grumbling. No self-pity. How incredibly refreshing. He didn’t pity himself. He had brought a dense, difficult book, and he read it for hours on end. He listened to music from his phone. He conducted business with his clients on his back on the guest room bed on his phone. He didn’t pity himself. No pity parties for him.

This is the same father who says his goal is to dance at all of his grandchildren’s weddings. Not just attend, but dance. You don’t accomplish that kind of goal of longevity with joy by moping around, saying “Poor me,” and feeling sorry for yourself.

Another important point: Hannah Baker allowed other people’s behaviors towards her to emotionally destabilize her to a fatal degree. Yes, when people are mean to us, it hurts. Yes, it can make us feel like we’re going to fall apart. But the most important thing to remember about mean, nasty, or even “just kidding” people is: their bad behavior is their problem, not ours. The particularly insensitive boy in the book who tried to make Hannah into just an object? “No one can make you feel inferior without your consent.” (Attributed to Eleanor Roosevelt)

Over the course of my lifetime, I have read countless true stories of people in impossible situations who maintained their sense of self, their sense of hope, their pride, their humanity. To my clients, to my children, I rally often: “You are strong enough to handle this well.” Mean, nasty, demeaning people can only break you if you allow them to.

Another idea I wish I could tell Hannah Baker: get up and help yourself. Hannah didn’t tell Clay what was wrong. She had the opportunity, and she didn’t open up. She didn’t speak to her parents about her pain. If your parents are anywhere near normal, talk to them about your difficult times. They may be able to help. Hannah gave only one therapist only one short shot at helping her. Sometimes it takes a couple of sessions to connect to a therapist. Sometimes you have to try a different therapist if you can’t connect to one.

But certainly don’t take your own life. God put you here for a reason, for a purpose, which you will figure out once the pain has gone. And “this too shall pass.” Whatever it might be.

July 22, 2017

Submit a Question to Q&A for Teens (Click here)

Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 12

(7) Anonymous, July 27, 2017 11:03 AM

Thank u

Hey.. Ur article on aish saved me today.. was seriously considering ending it. Was shaking. Self harmed a lot. Like. A lot. And couldn't breathe and wtvr.. To distract myself went to read random stuff. Idk why but hit this one. 13 reasons... and was exactly what needed to hear. Thank u..

(6) Anonymous, July 26, 2017 8:01 PM

IN THE WAKE OF THE RECENT STORY ABOUT "MALKY" I AM GLAD TO HEAR YOUR TAKE.

i feel there is something unhealthy about the way the story of "malky" is being presented. she obviously had understanding parents, and friends. you hit the nail on the head when you said she made a choice in her life - a poor choice. somehow, all the loving people close to her were not able to really get through to her. it was she who ultimately made the choice of how to run her life.

Yael, July 27, 2017 10:28 AM

I think you're mistaken.

She didn't commit suicide. She was addicted. We have no idea how much courage, strength and superhuman determination it took for her to go as far as she did. We have no idea of how much pain, agony and sheer hell her life, inside her brain, endured.
Lauren's speaking of something different here. She's speaking of a society that doesn't value life. The same society that idolizes assisted suicide is breeding young people who have no value for life.
Malky's life was hellish for her and she took an escape hatch of drugs. Could be we'll get up to heaven and see her in a very exalted place, close to Hashem, because of all the superhuman efforts she did make to come as far as she did come.
I think you might have misunderstood her story.

(5) Yael, July 26, 2017 11:09 AM

I appreciate Lauren's article

because I think there is a glorification of suicide and an inability to take responsibility for our life's choices in our society. No one's saying life cannot be brutal. It can. But when we know that it is our responsibility to do the best we can and act responsibly and maturely and accomplish whenever and however we can, we can rise above.
Past generations of Jews have lived through unthinkable horror, terror and torture, and never took their lives. I can't understand how they did it and don't know if I would have passed the test.
They understood the value of life. They understood their responsibility and potential no matter how horrific life was.
Obviously, we don't judge people who took the escape route. But I agree with Lauren that today's generation needs to learn about choices, and that living is a definite choice.
As the Torah, the Bible, says straight out a human obligation: "Vechai bahem", "And live with them" (with the commandments). We are obligated to choose life.
See the interview of Pearl Benisch on Aish where she tells over how, on the way to being gassed in the gas chambers, some of her friends were going to lean on the barbed wire and die. They said they'd save the Nazis the job. Pearl told them they must live, as the Torah says "Choose life". They listened to her and miraculously, the group was not gassed but sent to barracks.
Pearl survived the war, raised a gorgeous family, wrote books, and recently passed away at a very old age.
Laren's right. People with mental illness are a different story. But a society that has the inability to inspire its adherents to hold on to life...is tragic.

(4) Ruth Hartman, July 25, 2017 11:33 PM

This too shall pass..... inadequate

This too shall pass... Truly is inadequate for someone with a permanent disability. Or for someone who has had an abusive past, and is still dealing with critical people. It is VERY hard to change psyche/perspective. Yes God loves us. But sometimes it is very hard to love yourself.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub