Q&A for Teens: Disconnected Jew
click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Q&A for Teens: Disconnected Jew

Q&A for Teens: Disconnected Jew

I don’t feel a spiritual connection with God or the Jewish community. How do I start feeling that I belong?

by

Dear Lauren,

I am Jewish by birth, but growing up I wasn't raised with a great emphasis on my Jewishness. I knew it was there, and occasionally we celebrated holidays (Chanukah and Passover, mostly), and I know many of the stories and parables of our ancestors. I love my Jewishness. But I don't feel a spiritual connection with God or with the Jewish community. I didn't go to Hebrew school growing up, I don't have many Jewish friends, and despite my mother being Israeli and most of my family living there, I don't know any Hebrew.

I'm starting college in a few months and I know I'll have opportunities to make connections there. But I always feel like I don't belong with the other Jewish kids due to my lack of knowledge, a Hebrew/Jewish sounding name, and the fact that I'm multi-racial. I don't know where to start to get a better grasp on the more religious part of Judaism, and where to insert myself in the community. What should I do?

Lauren Roth's Answer

Let me start with the last part of your question, in which, basically, you say, “I don’t feel I belong with other Jewish kids because I’m not perfectly like them.” Do you know how many experiences and relationships we humans miss out on because we’re nervous: “I won’t be able to do it perfectly, so I’d rather not try”?

I read an interview with Karl Lagerfeld (of Chanel and Fendi). He said the most extraordinary statement:

“I like antique lace, antique sheets, beautiful quilted covers, but everything is white. In white you can hide nothing. I have everything – sheets and nightshirt and robes – changed every day. It’s such a pleasure to go to bed in the evening in a beautiful bed with beautiful sheets and beautiful pillows, everything flawless, in a freshly pressed, long white smock. It’s perfect.”

Everything white? Everything “flawless?” A freshly-pressed nightshirt? “Perfect?” Those words doesn’t describe Real Life. You can’t live an authentic life in a white house with white sheets and white clothes and white furniture. Real Life is never perfect or flawless or clean or white. It’s messy and dirty and complicated and full of imperfect fits and stubborn stains that won’t come out – and even more stains yet to come.

Just because you’re not perfectly like the other Jewish people you see doesn’t mean you don’t belong.

Also, I think that most people these days (at least the people I decide to associate myself with) are open-minded, and even actively looking for diversity in their lives. Personally, I love the fact that my friends are all very different from each other. I would find it extremely boring to have a bunch of Stepford wives in my social sphere. Variety is definitely the spice of my life.

I am so impressed that you have the desire to know what your heritage is all about. Self-knowledge is an extremely empowering path to personal peace. You are avoiding the fate of so many Jews today whose Judaism is a mere relic in the attic of their lives.

I just attended a 25th reunion for a Jewish summer program I attended in high school. I was talking with three other men who had attended the program the same year I had, and we were discussing work, and children, and quality time with our families, and work-life balance…. After an hour and a half, one of the men made a statement which revealed to me that his wife was not Jewish. He said, “My wife doesn’t mind if I raise our kids Jewish.” And then the second man of the three said, “Mine doesn’t mind either.” And then the third lamented, “Mine does. She minds very much.”

I was stunned! Out of three nice, Jewish boys, all three had married non-Jews! According to Jewish law, Judaism flows through the mother, not the father; for all three of those men, their Jewish heritage ended with them. I am so happy for you that you – through your desire to connect to your roots – are avoiding that sad ending, and, instead, embarking on an exciting, invigorating journey.

I am certain that in your area, wherever you live, there are Torah classes and Torah-observant Jews. In some cities and communities there are more Jewish educational programs than in others. And in different locales the classes will be given by either more or less knowledgeable teachers and rabbis than in others. Wherever you live, you can find a mentor online through TorahMates or through Partners in Torah; they will connect you to a mentor/teacher at a time and venue which works for you. You can also find host families for an entire Shabbat, or just for a Shabbat meal, at Shabbat.com. Also, Artscroll has thousands of books about authentic Judaism in English, and of course don’t forget Aish.com, where you can learn oodles about your roots!

My dear, your heritage awaits; the entire Jewish world is open to you. How exciting!

Bon voyage!

Published: October 28, 2012

Submit a Question to Q&A for Teens (Click here)


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 10

(6) Esther, November 12, 2012 3:50 PM

Resonse to Comments 3 and 4

It's unfortunate that David (of Comment 4) and the individual or Comment 3 seem to miss some of what Dr. Roth was trying to convey - that ALL Jews are indeed welcome in the Jewish community, no matter the background of level of knowledge; and she lists some sources where to begin one's connection if one is looking for it. I come from a completely non-observant home (my parents had never been to shul having come from the Soviet Union), and I married a non-Jewish man. Nontheless, when I came upon Aish HaTorah a number of years ago, both me and my son (and even now ex-husband) were treated like we had just come home, always being invited to meals and to stay. And he just leined the Torah at his bar mitzvah this summer! And indeed, it seems that many people from our entire community have diverse and interesting backgrounds - and we are all loved and supported, perhaps even more so because of it! After all - we are Jews! Scattered over the world, and this is one of our challenges if we want to continue our survival. Seeing the kindness in this time of Sandy reminds us of how we are all connected no matter where we come from.

(5) דונה, October 31, 2012 3:43 AM

Wow! Could not believe, yes,my,ears

Three nice Jewish boys... I get it! Not sure Ezra got it right?? My gut tells me protectionism in the face of exile. Despite the rejection, I stay with you guys because my Nashema says to. No one is perfect; but your up there! I have Paternal lineage and my intention is to learn all that I can so that when my husband dies ( G-d forbid) I can be ready to convert. I am a practical person married to a Roman... Don't ask!

(4) David, October 30, 2012 9:42 PM

How about applying this title to children of mixed marriages?

I find the author to be somewhat hypocritical: Bemoaning her detachment from the Jewish community yet castigating men of mixed relationships--which is a phenomenon among all ethnic and even some racial groups-- even in Israel. Did she even consider the detatchment of those million of children of mixed marriages who feel detatched because one parent -- especially the mother-- isn't Jewish? Does Aish try reaching out to these 'imperfect' souls? Or by such writing is it implied that only those born to 2 Jewish parents deserve to be given an ear when their lives aren't going so perfect? The Jewish community of every strata should be reaching out to those children of mixed marriages if we as a people want to to strengthen our community.

Dvirah, October 31, 2012 4:42 PM

Clarification

David, the article consists of a question asked by one person (young and female) and answered by an older person. There should have been a header marking where the question ended and the reply began - this is missing, probably due to some technical error. To clarify, the "bemoaning" is being done by the questioner and the "castigating" by the replier - these are two separate people, thus no hypocrisy.

Miriam, November 1, 2012 8:56 PM

Nobody said a child of a Jewish father and non-Jewish mother is imperfect

The child might be the most wonderful, amazing, perfect child on earth! He or she just happens not to be Jewish according to Jewish law.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!