Q&A for Teens: Bach & the Shouting Match
click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Q&A for Teens: Bach & the Shouting Match

Q&A for Teens: Bach & the Shouting Match

Help! My family makes me explode with anger.

by

Dear Lauren,

I'm tired of my family. They’re always fighting and shouting at each other, especially at me. They’re always criticizing me, yelling at me for any stupid thing and making a big deal out of nothing, until they get the best of me and I shout at them in return, no matter how hard I try not to. What bothers me most is that when they finally make me explode, they always tell me: "Why do you yell at your family?" and they make me feel really bad. They’re the ones that make me explode. They don't get that I try really hard to keep calm, but with their shouts, insults, and attitude it's almost impossible. Please give me some advice!

What’s your favorite piece of classical music? (No, “Oops!...I Did It Again” does not qualify as classical music—and neither does “Born in the USA” or even “Sweet Child O’Mine!”) The classical pieces I love best are the Brandenburg Concertos by Johann Sebastian Bach. If you’ve never heard them, do yourself a favor and listen to them (especially No. 5). They’re absolutely divine! (And I bet many of you agree.)

Would you believe they were rejected by the Governor of Brandenburg? Bach composed the pieces and sent them to said governor, querying whether he would like to hire Bach to create music for him on an ongoing basis. In a “Don’t call us, we’ll call you” move, Bach never heard back from the governor. Good thing he kept a copy of the Brandenburg Concertos! The full score was left, unused, in the governor’s library until his death in 1734, when it was sold for what today would be $22!

My point is this: many great things aren’t recognized, ever, for their greatness. And many great things are only recognized much, much later. Your family might unfairly criticize you. They might yell at you when yelling isn’t called for. Your job is to do the right thing, no matter whether you receive approval from those around you or not.

So your family criticizes, yells, and hurls insults. I’m sorry for you that you have to deal with the unpleasantness of antagonism. I feel for you because of the pain that must cause you. However, their bad behavior and your reaction to their behavior should be two different entities. I know how hard it is to stand strong in the face of disapproval, but, like Bach, your job in your family circle (your job as a person in this world) is to try your own personal hardest to do what you believe is right, no matter what those around you are doing, and no matter whether you receive accolades from them or emotional rotten tomatoes.

When I talk with children of any age (from age 10 to age 70) who are not getting the approval and positive attention from their parents and other family members that they crave, I try to empower them with the following idea: YOU are the one talking to me, ergo YOU are the one noticing the incorrectness of your family’s behavior, and YOU are the one seeking a better way. Therefore, YOU can absolutely be the one to turn the family dynamic around.

It doesn’t matter that you’re the child and the instigators are the parents; anyone can change the negative cycle of criticism and fighting to a peaceful cycle of giving, sharing, and caring. All it takes is one strong person to have enough self-awareness to pull himself or herself out of the mélange of antagonism, keep his or her head above water, stay calm, and say, respectfully and lovingly, “This is really hurting my feelings. Let’s all be kinder to one another. Can we please talk, instead of yelling?”

It only takes one strong, courageous person with a vision of serenity and peace to change a family dynamic.

The first time you say that, expect the others to yell some expletives, make fun of you, tell you you’re the most unkind of all of them, tell you your “better than thou” attitude is really annoying, or all of the above. But if you consistently stay calm and loving and respectful and refuse to be pulled into the swirling angry maelstrom of emotions, your calming presence can eventually bring the tension levels down and can quiet the inflammatory responses.

It only takes one strong, courageous person with a vision of serenity and peace to change a family dynamic. I’ve seen it happen many times.

I have a good idea: get a copy of Bach’s Brandenburg Concertos. When you feel stressed out and frazzled and horribly angry at your family, go to a calm place and listen to that music. Take many deep breaths. Get yourself centered and calm. Then focus on your goal. Your goal is to do the right thing, no matter what anyone around you is pushing you towards. Think about the fact that this uplifting music was totally rejected, and what an incorrect assessment of the music that was. Realize that your family can make mistakes. They can yell and insult and criticize, but it doesn’t have to push your buttons because you can choose to be better than that. Get yourself calm so you can have a calm discussion with them instead of a shouting match.

I have a favorite quote from Victor Frankl, the founder of a branch of psychology called Logotherapy, and a concentration camp survivor: “Between stimulus and response there is a space. In that space is our power to choose our response. In our response lies our growth and our freedom.” In that space between stimulus and response lies our humanity. In that space between stimulus and response lies our personal spiritual journey that God put us here on Earth for.

You can be the one in your family to change the tune.

Published: February 4, 2012

Submit a Question to Q&A for Teens (Click here)


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 8

(5) Anonymous, February 28, 2012 2:52 AM

just what i needed

wow this really gave me the strength to not give up even though its really hard to communicate with my parents. thanks so much

(4) Tintin, February 9, 2012 12:25 PM

Don't speak when you are angry

Dear Teen My husband gets angry at me but when I get angry he is very upset with how I speak to him, even if it is only a slight annoyed tone and nothing else. HE of course feels free to speak angrily and even rudely to me... with G-d's help we will work on things and they will improve. In the mean time I have practiced to be able to NOT speak when I am angry. It is much better to walk away (use any excuse like going to the bathroom if walking away would get them upset) and trying to stay away for a while. Later when you have calmed down think about what you wanna say and of course YOU only say I. I feel hurt/stressed/frustrated when I am spoken to with high tone/shouts. I get angry instead of being able to listen to what is being said. I would like to be spoken to in this and that way - calmly/no shouts/no insults. This may NOT work BUT 1. with time YOU would get less angry and that is a lot 2. THEY might tone in down a bit 3. You would learn how to express yourself in a way that doe snot get rejected immediately (saying YOU , blaming, finger pointing is a bad way and the other side does not really listen) In my experience saying what Lauren suggested (“This is really hurting my feelings. Let’s all be kinder to one another. Can we please talk, instead of yelling?) is better said NOT while your family is shouting, at least in the beginning b/c they want to be heard and would feel blocked. Try first saying these things while things are calm, see how they accept it and if it later say it right after they finished shouting. VERY RECOMMENDED: to speak to an understanding adult about it to at least get sympathy if nothing else. Hatzlacha!

(3) Anonymous, February 8, 2012 6:12 PM

rlly rlly helpfull

thank u for writing this article. i dont get on well with my parents and like 10 minutes before i went on here i was thinking "o God plz get me out of here" thanx!

(2) Phyllis, February 6, 2012 9:55 PM

Ganging Up On Mom Is Unacceptable

somewhere along the line Mom let it be know she can be bullyed and goaded into exploding, giving the family the excuse not to respect Mom because she goes "crazy". I agree that taking a totally different approach is necessary but consequenses for not respecting the mother also have to be included, such as not driving the children somewhere, or not making dinner one night, or leaving laundry. Any one of these things say, you can not treat me this way and still have me do nice things for you. Where is Dad in all this, not standing up for his wife, or is he also part of the problem? I hope Mom has the courage to take back her self respect and expect more from her family.

T, February 9, 2012 8:21 PM

Misunderstanding

I think there may have been a misunderstanding here - the person who wrote the question and who the response is aimed at is not the mother. This is a forum for teenagers to ask questions. Just clarifying.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!