click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Holding Back Our Daughters

Holding Back Our Daughters

Are we hurting our daughters’ future?

by

I thought I was entering a time warp, stepping back to the 60’s and 70’s, when I read the piece in Forbes online “7 Ways You’re Hurting Your Daughter’s Future” (6/28/2012). It was a list of supposed societal and parental behaviors that impede the full growth and potential of our daughters. The ideas seemed so passé – and so out of touch with reality.

Here are just a few to ponder – and dismiss.

1. We teach our daughters to be polite and quiet.

If only! I wish everyone’s daughters were more polite. My experience of public discourse suggests otherwise. And quiet? Clearly the author has never heard my daughter and her friends rehearsing the latest dance or song from their school performance –at midnight! The girls I know are loud and boisterous and confident – and I pray they are polite.

2. We buy her gender-specific toys.

Does this idea really still have traction? First of all, I know many boys (my grandsons included) who love playing with dolls and playing house. And I don’t think it has any impact on their future choices any more than when female children choose dolls as gifts. When they walk through a toy store, their eyes just don’t alight on the Lego and other building toys the way they do on the dolls. Maybe we should blame the packaging. I don’t think (as the article seems to suggest) that more “male-oriented” toys encourage invention and creativity than do female-oriented ones. Anyone that thinks that has obviously never heard their daughters play house or school!

Related Article: Banishing Barbie

3. We tell her she’s pretty to the exclusion of everything else.

I’m not sure which parents the author is addressing here. Of course little girls, and big girls, and their mommies, like to be told they look pretty. But they also like to be told they did a good job on a test or project, that they performed well on the soccer field or ice rink, that it was kind of them to share they toy and be considerate of others, that their character matters. I’ve noticed that schools give awards for sports and grades and sometimes character; I haven’t noticed any for looks. So I’m not sure who’s supporting this message.

4. We indoctrinate her into the princess cult.

Perhaps it is true that there has been a glut of princess parties – although certainly not in my home where birthday parties in general were deemed more trouble than they were worth. But haven’t princesses and brides always been little girls’ fantasies? And have they really shaped their future goals and visions? While I certainly find Sleeping Beauty to be a troubling story (not sure what the prince could determine about her character while she was sleeping), I don’t know any young women who honestly expect a prince to come riding up and sweep them off their feet (any more than they would expect a wicked stepmother who plots their death, a poisoned apple or talking mirrors or any other fairy tale phenomena). Can’t little girls just be little girls? They’ll grow up soon enough.

5. We give Dad all the physical tasks around the house.

I feel like I just stepped out of a scene from Father Knows Best. I know many women who do the physical tasks, just as I know many men who do the nurturing ones. The most logical seems to be that whoever is around when something needs doing should just take care of it. Every Friday night, we sing Eshet Chayil, a song about a woman of valor. The list of her accomplishments and abilities (prescribed by King Solomon many hundreds of years ago) suggests that we never believed in leaving all the physical labor to Dad. The truth is that the more common request these days is that Dad would do at least some of the physical labor!

6. She only spends time with other girls.

Guilty as charged. But I don’t accept any negative implications. In fact, the opposite seems to be true. Girls educated around only girls seem to be more confident and more advanced academically. No Reviving Ophelia dumbing down to make the boys feel better. And it’s not just scholastically; girls who spend their time with other girls seem happier, more secure, less pressured and more able to just enjoy their time and make the most of it. The author’s contention that girls need coed high school education in order to be successful in business seems to lack focus on the qualities that actually lead to success.

7. We criticize our bodies and other women’s bodies.

This is indeed a battle but I certainly don’t know any homes where other women’s bodies are criticized or where anyone would consider that an acceptable pastime. Yes the media reinforces some negative stereotypes about body image that we need to counteract, but if we really mean it, perhaps we should stop buying the products that are marketing by half-dressed women and watching the television shows (most of them) that continue to objectify us.

I don’t believe that today’s young women are limited by anything except the necessity in life to make tough choices – and perhaps by articles like this that makes them feel like hapless and helpless victims of a sexist society instead of the strong, capable, confident and self-possessed women that they, in fact, are.

Published: August 4, 2012


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 17

(14) Dana Klein, May 21, 2013 6:08 PM

Education is the key

Thankfully I grew up in a family where my father encouraged our education. He also encouraged us to participate in the community and sports. The greatest words told to me were...Dana when you win we all win. When you lose we all lose. We are here to help you on your journey......I am thankful that this was the family chosen for me to enter the world.

(13) Anonymous, August 30, 2012 3:41 PM

the frum community does share these issues

There are those in the frum community who do put an emphasis on marriage above other things-our version of the prince on the white horse. i.e. Why bother getting an education or a good job...you'll get married anyway i.e. once you get married, your problem will go away (for boys and girls) Stay thin so somebody will want to marry you....

(12) Esther, August 10, 2012 7:55 AM

A couple of remark on the subject

a. I was educated at a girls' school and I didn't know about boys until I was 18. I had a very unrealistic view of society and it took many years to adjust. Bad for the girls! b. In Eshet Chayil the woman works night and day while the husband sits with the wise of the land and sings her praises. What kind of division of labour is that?

(11) Esther, August 10, 2012 6:24 AM

a. I was educated at a girls' school and I didn't know about boys until I was 18. I had a very unrealistic view of society and it took many years to adjust. Bad for the girls! b. In Eshet Chayil the woman works night and day while the husband sits with the wise of the land and sings her praises. What kind of division of labour is that?

Sarah, August 10, 2012 4:54 PM

Girls only private school shouldn't be an issue

I went to a private girls' school from grade school through college. Even without having many brothers or even boy cousins, I had no problem adjusting to the business world, where I work as a manager with and over many male (and female) employees. If anything, I am more reserved and not reduced to pathetic flirting (whether conscious or unconscious) when conversing with the guys. My schools taught us girls to have self respect and be confident in a modest manner, tools that are vital in any relationship. As for Eshet Chayil, it describes the woman who is a role-model wife and mother- and enumerating her strengths has nothing to do with detracting from what her husband does. Although not everyone is on that level, I'm sure that any 'good wife' loves her husband and will do whatever she can for him- without feeling resentful and envious of the 'division of labor'. Doing something for another does not require expectations of getting something equal in return. Thanks for the article. Being a 'princess' kind of girl myself, I don't think this has distorted my visions of reality at all- it's just a personality thing. I love creating (I'm a go-to person for fixing things) and designing (not necessarily girly things considering the percentages of male designers). The truth of the matter is that girls and boys are intrinsically different. If they were meant to be the same, then why would G-d create two different genders?

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub