click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Dating Advice #78 - The Perfect Fit
Dating Advice 78

Dating Advice #78 - The Perfect Fit

She is the Super-Woman, but can't find the Super-Man. The clock is ticking and she's getting impatient...


Dear Rosie & Sherry,

I read your advice to Mitchell, regarding "The Bookworm Quandary" (Dating Maze #58). It really struck a chord for me because I, too, am a bookworm and am concerned about finding my intellectual partner in marriage.

All the Jewish men I meet and date seem to fall into one of two categories, either: A) I can have wonderful conversations with them and feel that they are my intellectual equal, or B) I find them physically attractive. These groups seem to be mutually exclusive! I keep pursuing both "types" because I still dream that I will eventually find a man who falls into both categories and is Jewish.

I'm 36 now and feel my biological clock ticking. I would like to raise children in a Jewish home and therefore am very reluctant to start considering non-Jewish men to expand my "dating pool." But I'm also afraid that if I keep waiting for Mr. A+B, I'll still be single when my child-bearing years come to an end!

I should mention that I don't categorize myself as a female "geek." I go out frequently, am physically active, and in great shape. Most of the men I date who are as physically fit as I am are not very well-read, like to watch TV (I never do), and are quite unintellectual.

On the other hand, I am an avid reader, keep up with politics and world issues, teach a foreign language and study others, and am your typical perpetual student. The men with whom I can have very interesting conversations on a variety of topics and really experience a "meeting of the minds," tend to be overweight, inactive physically, quite unattractive and can't understand why I swim a mile every day.

I'm afraid that if I end up marrying someone from group A, I will always long for a man with whom I could have real physical chemistry, and will eventually feel repelled by physical intimacy with my husband. I was married briefly when I was very young, to an intellectual, and the marriage ended for this very reason!

Then again, how can I choose group B and marry a man whom I don't even want to talk to?! The "old wise people" always say that marriage is ultimately a long conversation, so choose your partner carefully.



Dear Nanci,

The two types of men you describe are not mutually exclusive. There are many fine Jewish men who have a mix of qualities, and we know for a fact that they are not all taken!

At the same time, it may be helpful for you to review the qualities you feel are important in a mate and see if the categories you have established aren't too numerous or rigid. For example, while you definitely need to respect the intelligence of your partner, you are making a mistake that many highly educated people make. They focus on finding someone whose intellectual interests are the same as theirs, instead of looking for an intelligent person.

A spouse doesn't have to fill your every need. You can obtain intellectual stimulation from friends and work colleagues, too. We don't know any married couples who do everything together and who share all the same interests. The two of you should be able to communicate well with each other, but you can have stimulating and interesting conversations that are not necessarily "intellectual" in nature.

We know that physical attraction is important in a relationship. However, that doesn't mean that you need an athletic husband. Have you tried focusing on non-athletic physical attributes, such as a man's eyes and his smile? You don't have to have a spouse who will swim with you each day or play tennis once a week. We know from personal and professional experience, of many happily married couples in which one spouse is very physically active and the other only moderately so. We think that you would be happier loosening the criteria in this category so that you emphasize finding someone you can relate to.

We're not suggesting that by modifying your criteria you will be "settling." However, you don't need a super-athlete or a super-intellectual to find a good marriage partner. In fact, there are many more vital qualities in marriage that you didn't mention in your letter -- the inner qualities of kindness, compassion, etc. If you focus more on these, rather than intellectualism or physical fitness, you might find a well-rounded man who makes you much more happy.

Rosie & Sherry

January 19, 2003

Submit Your Dating Advice Question (Click here)

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 5

(5) Anonymous, March 20, 2007 1:24 PM

try another venue?

Maybe Nanci should place a personal ad on rightstuffdating (for ivy league grads) or in the New York Review of Books to attract a pool of eligibly intellectual men, and state she is looking for someone who is both intellectually and physically fit and active. Make sure you state what you want up front, and keep focused on that. Are your friends setting you up with anyone in your age group who just happens to be single, without regard to your two top criteria? Make sure they are aware of what your criteria are. You have a better chance of getting what you want if you ask for it, frequently and consistently.

(4) Anonymous, June 30, 2003 12:00 AM

I found my soulmate!!!

I found this article very interesting to read on expectations in finding the one. I wasn't willing to settle for less and after much hard work I posted my profile on and met the most amazing single man and we are in so much awe of each other. We both felt

that we wouldn't meet someone and we have found each other.

Keep working at it, and you will meet someone very special as long as you maintain focus and know what you are looking for.

Beth Vane.

(3) Ronald Gillhaus, April 25, 2002 12:00 AM

Loves Super Woman

I found Your web page by looking under SuperWoman who i find attractive.

(2) Anonymous, September 6, 2001 12:00 AM

thanks for good advice

I read your comments and letters all the time and find them good advice for relationship issues. Recently, response for advice touched a strong nerve. Thanks for the good, well-balanced advice.

Oh, well, looks like I can go on a bit longer. Well, the inquiry from the woman who dated a recently-divorced man hit a nerve w/me. I tried, really tried to pretend, to ignore your advice but I could not. Instead, I sprung into action for my own situation. Your advice e-mails are very, very powerful.


(1) Anonymous, September 2, 2001 12:00 AM

It sounds like you expect too much

You may be expecting too much, and may be very disappointed if you get married again? As a single man in his early 40s, I can honestly say that I find women who have very high expectations to be extremely undesirable. You should not be so obsessed with a man's weight. People can gain or lose weight, and as long as the weight is not serious enough to damage a person's health(more than 40% or 50% overweight), than the weight shouldn't really matter. If you marry a man who is thin, and he later gains 50 pounds, will you divorce him? I have been thin at times in my life, and have been overweight at other times. I am starting to think that perhaps people who have unreasonably high expectations really want to remain single?

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment