click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Dating Advice #131 - Sabotage Path
Dating Advice 131

Dating Advice #131 - Sabotage Path

Why can't she get past the first date?


Dear Rosie & Sherry,

I am a 29-year-old woman. I am very passionate about all that I do in life. That includes "first dates." I'm aware that it is not always a good thing to show too much to a man, or come on too strong too fast, because it may turn him off.

I don't know what to do anymore. I've been dating for a long time now. I've gotten hurt, and once had a broken engagement close to my wedding. I am scared to open up too much. I don't think that it's me showing too much emotion, rather me being too strong and aggressive to start. I think it's partly a defense mechanism to protect myself from getting hurt.

Meanwhile, I am turning off and rarely getting past a first date. What can I do to end this cycle and find myself that great man out there?


Dear Melanie,

It seems that all of the negative experiences you've been through have led to your being in a real dating rut -- too unsure of yourself, not knowing anymore how to act on a date, and even sabotaging your dates so that you won't get hurt again.

The good thing is that you have started to realize what is happening and are beginning to understand the unproductive pattern you've been falling into. If you're willing to put in the effort, we believe you can definitely get out of your rut and turn your dating experiences into positive ones that will lead to a good and healthy marriage.

Our first suggestion is that you get a notebook and pen, and spend some quiet, private time writing down your thoughts about your dating experiences over the past few years. When did you start changing from being very open and perhaps coming on too strong, to being too quiet and subdued? When you went on dates, what were the expectations you had before you went out with someone new? What went on that led or didn't lead to a second date? What did you do or say that may have discouraged your dating partner from asking you out a second time? What would you have wanted to do or say differently?

Think about what occurred, how you felt, what you said. Write everything down and wait a few days to look over what you wrote.

When you read over what you have written in a stream of consciousness, see if you can identify any patterns in feelings, words and behavior. You might be able to see what feelings triggered certain actions, or that you unwittingly keep reacting to certain stimuli in the same unproductive way. When you start to understand what you have been doing and why, you can start to focus on solutions.

Another suggestion is to do some reading to help you understand what you've been going through, and how to change your dating style to something more positive. We suggest the books, "Emotional Unavailability," by Bryn C. Collins, and well as "Keeping The Love You Find," by Harville Hendricks. Shaya Ostrov's "The Inner Circle" suggests a 7-step method to help you open up to a dating partner and build a strong emotional connection over time. If you find a method that sounds comfortable, try to adapt it to your own dating style.

Our last piece of advice is equally valuable. We think that you, like many singles we know who have been hurt a lot in the past (and even singles who haven't), would benefit from the support and encouragement of a dating mentor. We have trained mentors in several U.S. cities and in Israel, and if you live near one of those cities we can recommend someone to you. Or, you can find a happily married friend, rabbi, neighbor, or relative (but not a parent, who will be too close to be very helpful) to be your sounding board and hand-holder, and can dispense practical advice. We have found that dating mentors are excellent resources, especially for someone who has gotten into a rut.

We hope this has been helpful, and wish you the best of success,

Rosie & Sherry

July 12, 2003

Submit Your Dating Advice Question (Click here)

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 4

(4) Olga, July 22, 2003 12:00 AM

other problem

I think I sometimes wish I would have the same problem...I am doing active dating right now with a purpoce of finding a life long partner and I obviously have many first dates. 99.99% of the time men want second date with me and are really interested, however I have no interest in most of them . I feel sensitive about constantly rejecting people especially if a guy is nice. maybe I am too selective but honestly rejecting other people as almost as painful as being rejected. When they don't call you, there is nothing you can do. But if they always do and you have to come up with handing them polite "no" it takes a lot of your energy and makes you responcible for someone's feelings. And I feel guilty a lot. So I don't know what is better...

(3) Ines Lebel, July 17, 2003 12:00 AM


Thanks for your good work dear friends. Love. Ines

(2) Diana, July 15, 2003 12:00 AM

Why is it always something the girl is doing?

Why can't it be that maybe the guys are so mixed up that they don't know what they want?

I've had the same experience as Melanie where I go out on almost all first dates and never get called back. I've analized what I've said and how I behaved and I even shared this with a psychiatrist and he concluded that many men get scared when they meet a nice woman, because at the end of the date unconsciously they realize that they could built a life together with this person and and that scares them. That's why they don't call back in some cases.

This behaviour does not exist when a man is emotionally mature and really wants to get married.

My pattern has been that I'm always very nice with the men I go out with, and we have nice conversations. They treat me very well during the date, but as soon as they bring me home they turn cold.

I know that it takes two to tango, but I'm tired of hearing that it's the woman's fault if she doesn't get called back.

How is it that I can relate perfectly well with everybody in my life (job, family and friends), but as soon as I go out on a blind date, there must be something wrong with me if he doesn't call back?

(1) Anonymous, July 14, 2003 12:00 AM

Who's your mentor?

If a happily married person is asked to become someone's dating mentor, it's extremely important that they try to understand how hard it is to have to date so many people. I have often found that people who are happily married who didn't have to date a lot before finding their spouses can't relate and just don't get it. Also, I often get a feeling that they think there may be something wrong with me if I have to date so many guys and obviously that does not make me want to confide in them. I get the feeling they start thinking maybe I'll just have to marry someone less suitable for myself than the people they married were suitable for them because it's just taking so long.

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment