click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Dating Advice #159 - Time to Move On
Dating Advice 159

Dating Advice #159 - Time to Move On

After a broken engagement, he has built a new live for himself. She's stuck.


Dear Rosie & Sherry,

I'm 24 and have been unattached now for over a year after being engaged to someone for about nine months. The whole courtship lasted two years. Since then I've been out on a few dates, but nothing serious, and I just don't really know what to do. My former fiance has moved on, is going on lots of dates, and is living in the home we planned to live in when we were married. I can't seem to stop resenting him and I actually feel sometimes like I hate him for forgetting about me so easily and being so mean when we broke up. He seems to have everything while I feel like I have nothing.

I used to have a tendency to be attracted to not-so-nice guys who treated me badly. I find it easier to spot this now and turn down dates with that type of person. All I want is someone kind with a good heart. Yet that seems to be too much to ask, as all the nice guys seem to be taken!

I just wonder how to get over my broken engagement and move on. I would like to get married, but I am scared of getting hurt.

I am happy in the other areas of my life. I have a good job, nice friends and am moving forward in my Judaism. I miss my ex, but there is no way we will get back together. I can't keep punishing myself for it not working. As much as I can, I have come to terms with that and want to move on. I hope you can advise me.


Dear Deborah,

You are right that enough time has passed since the break up for you to move on and find the man who really is right for you. However, as you have found through your own experience, everyone mourns differently and it takes some people longer to get over a loss than others. What is holding you back from doing so is the fact that the man you once planned to marry moved on faster than you did, and it hurts you a great deal that he has seemingly gotten on so easily with the rest of his life.

We do not know whose decision it was to end your engagement, but we do know that both parties experience pain whenever an engagement ends. Some people agonize over the decision to end an engagement, and when they actually go through with it they have already completed a good part of their mourning process. Others grieve after the break-up, and even if they are able to return to the dating world relatively soon afterward, it is because they're finished grieving.

It seems to us that in order for you to be able to move forward in your own life, you will need to do more than merely complete the mourning process you have been living through. You will also have to let go of the resentment you feel toward you ex for moving on before you were ready. You need to acknowledge that he's already dealt with his loss. In addition, it is time for you to let go of the nagging belief that the two of you really should be together. We know that it has been hard for you to do this; on an intellectual level you understand that since he has moved on you aren't going to be reunited, but on an emotional level you hope that he will retrace his steps. You need to look at the reasons you aren't together anymore so that you can understand why you really weren't right for each other for the long term.

You started seeing this man when you were 21. Many couples who begin dating as young adults do not endure, even though they develop a close emotional connection and at some point genuinely believe that they will spend their lives together. Often, this is because one or both of the parties experiences a great deal of personal development during this time, discovering aspects of themselves for the first time, while fine-tuning aspects of their personalities as well as their values, expectations about the future, and long- and short-term goals. Looking back, can you see how much you and your ex each changed and grew as individuals from the time you first met, until the time your engagement ended? At some point, the relationship was no longer right for one or both of you. That's why the two of you can't recapture what you once had.

We hope that ultimately you can view your two years together with the mixed emotions it deserves. Despite the pain you experienced when it ended, your courtship filled an emotional need at the time, contributed to making you the person you are today, and helped bring you closer to meeting the man with whom you will be able to build an enduring life together.

Working these feelings through will help you move through the final stages of grieving your loss. You may be inspired by the book What Doesn't Kill You Makes You Stronger: Turning Bad Breaks Into Blessings by Maxine Schnall. And if you find that you aren't making any progress, you may need a therapist to help you along.

We have one piece of insight that may help you leave your broken engagement behind and move forward. It could be that the reason that you are having such a hard time getting over your broken engagement is that you never completely dealt with another loss in your life. Your telling us a bit about your history, having been attracted to mean men, being badly treated by them and their families, giving us the sense that this aspect of your life may also not have been fully resolved, and may be tied in with your sense of loss. These experiences may also contribute to the sense of betrayal you feel now that your ex has moved on. These issues may be a little too heavy to deal with on your own. A trained mental health professional who specializes in focused or goal-oriented therapy is the best person to help you deal with all these issues and move on with your life.

Additionally, you need to remember that you are still young, and there are plenty of great guys out there. You are truly blessed to have so much going for you right now -- happy about yourself and your job, enjoying the companionship and emotional support of good friends, and growing spiritually. We hope that within a short time, you'll meet the right man for you, and build a beautiful life together.

All the best,

Rosie & Sherry

June 26, 2004

Submit Your Dating Advice Question (Click here)

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 7

(7) Kate, April 30, 2009 2:44 AM

It,s a Mad World

My marriage is breaking up. WE met online 4 years ago. I truly thought that I had found "him" - the man I've waited for for a very long time. He's someone else now - he was everything once upon a time and now he's nothing. A stranger. Can't help. Thanks.

(6) Anonymous, February 10, 2006 12:00 AM

It takes time, that's for sure

We are smart women,and yet we still believe in blind faith. It has been a long time for me (3 yrs) and I still long for something. Something that if we look inside ourselves was never there. But, you will find someone for you and accept you for who you are and vica versa. Open your heart when you are ready, not when someone suggests to you that you are ready.

(5) NI, August 29, 2004 12:00 AM

Deborah's situation

Like you, I went/going through a very similar situation. If you'd like to talk and discuss issues, email me at

(4) Anonymous, July 1, 2004 12:00 AM

another possible solution

Rosie & Sherry
One of the questions posed to you was from Deborah who asked how she should get over the breakup of her boyfriend she feels resentment that he got over it so quickly.
She also mentioned that she used to be attracted to guys who did not treat her nicely.

To me the real problem seems to be that she has a low self esteem, it could be that she never really loved her original boyfriend, rather she for whatever reason looked up to people who did not treat her so nicely, possibly because she feels they are "cool" and wants them to like her.
This could also explain why she was angry at him for moving on. If she had proper self esteem she would be able to move on a little easier even though its obviously always difficult to have an engagement broken off as those are basic human emotions. Wishing Deborah the best of luck
A fond reader

(3) Anonymous, June 29, 2004 12:00 AM

I just want to add to your advice to the girl who can't seem to get over her broken engagement.

You gave a long and thoughtful answer, which is nice, but to put it quite simply. its just gonna take time. Time is the only healer.

So my advice I would say to these young girls who are in deep pain.

1) Realize it take time to heal and allow yourself the pain. There's nothing wrong with that. Some days will be good and others not so good. That's life.

2) Get involved in a new hobby. When I was going through horrible pain from a break up, I started singing and practicing playing an instrument. It helped to ease my pain but nothing will hurry the healing along any faster than Good Old Fashioned "Time" itself.

3) Pray and find ways to get closer to HaShem. He is there for us when we are in pain. He wants us to ask Him for his guidance and His healing. Realize this is the perfect time to get to know your creator.
He has given you this time to get to know Him. Don't take it for granted. One day, you will have a husband and children, and you will not be able to enjoy this "alone" time. Cherish it. Respect it.

One day I realized I was not hurting as much as I had the week before, eventually, before I knew it. I was back to my old self. But you know
what was cool about it? through all my numbness and through all my alone time with my creator, I learned how to play the piano, I knew more words to my favorite songs, I had a stronger more connected relationship with HaShem. As Martha Stewart says "that's a good thing".

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment