click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Dating Advice #196 - Of Fireworks and Butterflies
Dating Advice 196

Dating Advice #196 - Of Fireworks and Butterflies

How can she know if he's the right one?


Dear Rosie & Sherry,

I have been dating a man for six months, but we have been talking on the phone for over a year. I don't know how long I should give it. He likes me very much, and I like him, but do not have strong feelings or love. People always tell me I will know if he is the right one. I never know.

Is there any easy way to know? Is everyone "in love" when they get married? Maybe I'm just not the type of person to have butterflies in my stomach every time I see him. I hope there is some simple answer. Thank you.


Dear Jacqueline,

It isn't always easy to "know" if someone is the right person for you. This is because we've been conditioned by contemporary culture to expect to feel emotional reactions that are more intense than most people experience. For most people, "love" is a feeling that grows gradually. The idea of being "head over heels" in love sounds exciting, but it is very uncommon. Further, this emotion fades relatively quickly, and does not predict whether a couple will have a loving and successful marriage.

Hollywood's ideal is dangerous because it does not exist in many happy marriages.

We've all seen movies and read novels that describe "love" in terms of "fireworks," "butterflies in the stomach," thinking about each other every minute, and blindly idealizing each other. These concepts are very dangerous because they do not occur in many relationships that lead to good marriages. As a result, people sometimes give up on a courtship that has great potential because they aren't feeling what they have been led to believe they should feel.

Yes, some people experience fireworks and butterflies, but they are signs of infatuation, which is based on "chemistry" rather than on really knowing another person. These feelings always fade over time. Sometimes, two people who experience this intensity when they first meet replace that feeling with a true emotional connection. However, the majority of successful dating couples don't start out this way. They get to know each other and come to a gradual realization that they care about each other, and are developing an emotional connection that can grow into a loving marriage.

What feelings should a person expect to experience? You should like the individual you are dating and enjoy being with them. You should look forward to the times that you get together, and experience a feeling of contentment to have that person in your life. You should feel affection toward them. You should want to spend a lot of time together, and gradually look forward to the idea of being together as a couple on a long-term basis. These feelings tend to grow stronger over time.

There are other important elements to a courtship that point to the potential for a loving and stable marriage. You can ask yourself:

  • Are our lives moving in the same direction? Are our expectations for the future, our goals for ourselves personally and as a couple, compatible? Do we have value systems and world views that are also compatible?

  • Do I think that he is a good person, and that he has the personality and character traits to be a good spouse?

  • Am I physically attracted to him? (That doesn't mean that you feel he is movie-star handsome -- rather that he looks good to you and you like the idea of being with him.)

  • Do we respect each other as people? Does he also have certain character traits that I admire?

  • Am I comfortable with his background, his imperfections, and the things he does that annoy me? Do I accept him as he is, without expecting him to change?

  • Do I feel a close sense of friendship? Can I trust him and do I believe he is responsible and will be there for me? Do I want to be there for him?

Sometimes, we have to do a lot of thinking before we can recognize that someone is right for us. We don't always immediately "know." If you see that all the qualities we have discussed are present, then this might be the right one for you.

We hope this helps you navigate the dating maze,

Rosie & Sherry

January 7, 2006

Submit Your Dating Advice Question (Click here)

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 7

(7) Boca Mom, February 26, 2013 5:31 PM

good advice

I married the guy who gave me heart palpitations, but he also gave me heart aches. Finally after a long painful marriage we divorced and i later met a man who gradually stole my heart, and I love him more than I thought possible because I didn't really want to fall in love again after the pain I had endured. This man doesn't take my emotions on crazy roller coaster rides of thrills and depressions, but rather he is a steady, loving constant source of happiness. I smile when I see him, I relax completely in his arms even when I am having a rough day. He accepts me for who I am and never judges me. I do the same for him. This is true love, this is what lasts. If you feel peaceful and happy with your partner, and want to curl up next to them every night, you are in love.

(6) Radha, February 9, 2009 9:23 PM

One man's "fireworks" is another man's "joy" ... what's in a name?

Thanks for this article ... my husband and I have been married for seven wonderful years. Not without trials or disagreements, but with love and respect and mutual joy in each other. We laugh and love together as a family with our beautiful children. And you know, we nearly didn't get married. He had been taught by his parents (now divorced!) to wait for "fireworks" and he didn't think what he felt qualified. This caused so much pain, so much doubt and mistrust. In the end, he said "I want you to be the one" and we got married. I knew I loved him, but for months into our marriage I doubted that he was really in love with me. I worried that he had "settled". When our daughter nearly died after birth, I saw the love and devotion in him and I knew that it didn't matter what you called it - what he feels for me is love. I feel sorry for others who give up on their courtship because of this "fireworks" myth. What a beautiful life they miss out on. For us, our love just gets deeper and stronger and better. Thank you for this article!

(5) Mary Zachariah, January 17, 2006 12:00 AM

very good and useful advice

I loved all the advice supplied here, brilliant advice!! keep it up.

(4) Rodrigo Volpe, January 3, 2006 12:00 AM

I agree

Hello everyboby. I´m from Brazil, catolic, but I like your way, your filosophy and your religion. I´ll be jewish, someday.

I´m writing in this site because I liked this article about dating. It gives a great way to not make mistakes anymore with a relationship or to not imagine or dream with the wrong person.


Rodrigo Volpe


(3) BF, January 3, 2006 12:00 AM

Sage, sobering advice

What a fine column of sage advice! Pair it with Gila Manolson's "What is Love" essay/excerpt, also on

It's sobering to realize that many divorced people will confirm that "butterflies" do "not predict whether a couple will have a loving and successful marriage." Neither does a bevy of well-wishers congratulating a couple on having found their "basherts/soulmates."

Good point about the importance of character (aka "a good heart" as per R'n Jungreis) and beauty - one need only be subjectively, not objectively attractive. How sad that so many cute "Mary Anns" think they need to be glamorous "Gingers" and how sad that so many normal women think they need to be model-thin (but obese singles should lose weight and not disparage as "lookists" those who overlook them.)

May G-d soon bless us all with long, happy marriages, whether or not the butterflies tarry.

- BF

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment