click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Dating Maze #225 - What's Wrong?
Dating Advice 225

Dating Maze #225 - What's Wrong?

She's plagued by a nagging feeling that "something is off."


Dear Rosie & Sherry,

What are the differences between 'attraction' and 'chemistry'? What I mean is, when dating, if all your 'boxes' are ticked about a person's personality and view on life, and you are attracted to them, does there need to be something more?

From the time I first started dating Adam, I saw potential. So much about him seemed to fit. I was attracted to him and I liked his personality. There also are no major bumps in the road, although there are still some minor issues that I still have to work out.

However, I think something is missing. We've been going out for many months, and I believe that a promising courtship should progress to engagement rather quickly. I'm not looking at a timetable, but even so I don't feel an overwhelming sense of "I want to be with him all the time." In fact, for the past month my feelings about him have been sort of static. I feel that there might not be enough chemistry, but I'm not sure what that is. All I know is that something doesn't feel wholly right.

Is ‘attraction' the same as ‘chemistry'? Or is it an independent thing that makes two people always want to see each other and be with one another? I'm very confused and have this tight nervous feeling that I can't seem to get rid of. Are my concerns justified, or am I expecting more from than is realistic? I have to sort things through. I don't think I can go on like this much longer.


Dear Natalie,

It sounds like you began your present courtship with a realistic attitude: "This person seems to have the basics that I am looking for, and let's see where it goes." You liked his personality, and you were attracted to him. That's a good way to feel at the beginning of a courtship. The fact that there were no major bumps in the road is also a plus. "Minor bumps" are okay, and are often par for the course.

However, after many months of dating-for-marriage, we've got some concerns. One is that you haven't yet been able to resolve the minor "bumps" in the road. These are issues you should be able to come to terms with over the course of a few weeks. If you aren't, then maybe they are more significant than you first thought.

What concerns us more is that you haven't developed more affection for him over the past month or so. Most of the time, when a couple is right for each other, their mutual feelings continue to grow. The fact that this isn't happening leads us to think that you may be trying hard to make something work that just isn't right.

Let's try to distinguish between ‘attraction' and ‘depth of affection.' The latter is something that should be present before two people become engaged. You can be physically attracted to someone, feel they are right for you on paper, admire qualities about them, respect them, and even feel that you are connecting to them on a certain level, but still fall short of feeling that "I like him so much... I look forward to being with him... I miss him often when we are not together... I feel a sense of comfort with him... I like the idea of building a life with him."

After months of dating, you should be feeling some strong emotions.

You don't have to want to be with someone all of the time for him to be right for you, but after months of dating, you should be feeling stronger emotions than you have described. That underlying anxiety you feel may also be a message that this man isn't right for you. This nagging feeling that "something is off" usually isn't present in the "right" relationship.

But please, do not end your courtship solely on the basis of what we've said here. We're only responding to what you've described in your letter, and it could be that there are nuances, or factors, that you haven't described here, that would generate a different response from us. We suggest that you talk over your feelings, and our observations, with someone who can serve as a mentor -- such as a happily-married person whose wisdom you value. Hopefully, you'll be able to decide if it would be better to end the courtship, or if you do have stronger feelings for this man that you are holding back for some reason.

If you decide to end things, we'd like to give you a bit of encouragement. It can be disappointing when a courtship comes very close and then ends. However, many people draw great hope from such an experience, because it confirms for them that the right person is out there, and not too far away.

We wish you success and hopefully, the next one will be the right one.

Rosie & Sherry

February 10, 2007

Submit Your Dating Advice Question (Click here)

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 6

(6) Anonymous, December 19, 2007 5:41 PM

i think i was the person who originally wrote this letter (although due to slight editing i cant be too sure!) Either way,rosie and sherry you are completely right. If i would have submitted to social pressure i would be married and ridiculously unhappy right now!(not bc the guy wasnt great but bc he werent great for me) One of the main things that stressed me out at the time was what ppl would think of me-that theyd think i was picky, or committment phobic etc etc.. but you know what? I know Im not and thats what really counts. Thank G-d I made the decision I did. i have realised over the past couple of years that as long as i really know myself, thats all that matters. Annoying shadchanim who make silly comments, i try to ignore now. Only Hashem knows when it will happen for me,and anyone debating that fact-anyone saying that all girls need to married by the age of 23 are challenging His ratzon. Thank G-d He's helped me gain clarity and allowed me to get to know the real me.

(5) Anonymous, May 3, 2007 9:30 PM

Agreed, Nagging feeling should not be there

I have to say that the this is the best advice I've heard so far, based on a recent longterm relationship. When concerns escalate and a realtionship gets more stressful than positive, it is definately time to evaluate the relationship & what it is that is making you feel that way. It is very likely that this person is someone that you highly respect, but for some reason they are not giving you what you need in the relationship whatever that may be. If your not getting it now, chances are you will never get it. I'd recommend taking a break, or a step back and see if the stresses increase or go away. If the stresses leave with the relationship, you just saved yourself a life's worth of stress which can be very damaging. Congrats!

(4) Jack, May 1, 2007 4:13 AM

SImilar Situation

Natalie, I recently ended my relationship with a girl that I was dating for 3 months. I went through most of the same things described in your letter and I think the response from Rosie and Sherry was on point. Its still an awkaward feeling to know that my ex is dating other people but like Rosie and Sherry said it's never fun to break up someone you are close with but I found that it really helps clear your head and know what you want and don't want in the person you are going to spend of your life with G-D willing.

(3) Anonymous, March 15, 2007 3:32 PM

*red flag*

You have the Ruach inside of you for a reason, don't ignore Him. If something doesn't feel quite right, GET OUT quickly, the longer it drags on, the worse for both of you. If he is the one for you, don't worry, HaShem will not let you get too far away and your time apart will be beneficial, to see what your REAL feelings are. You don't have to force anything.

(2) Sheera, February 16, 2007 12:26 PM

Makes me feel so much better

I just broke up with a guy after dating him for 3-4 months. He has so many qualities I want in my life partner. He is a really special, good person. But even though we grew closer over the months, there were always problems and always a certain amount of discomfort on my part. So, though I am sad about breaking up with him, I have felt quite sure about my decision. But reading this helped me realize that the reasons I broke up with him are very good and true reasons to do so and so it has made me feel so much better. It is so amazingly similar to what I was going through. Thank you so much!!!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment