click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Dating Maze #245 - Dead Engine
Dating Advice 245

Dating Maze #245 - Dead Engine

He doesn't call, and doesn't care. Is the courtship over?


Dear Rosie and Sherry,

I have been in a long-distance relationship for six years. I've been as patient as I can possibly be, and now I feel like he's drifting away from me.

In the first three years, things were good and he was very attentive to me. Back then I asked him what the status of our relationship was and he said to be patient with him. He had been in a very volatile relationship before me and it scarred him. I've always been very understanding.

Over the last three years, things have changed. I am always the one to initiate, and when we are together I feel like he's just humoring me, not genuinely enjoying our time together. He spends all his spare time with his friends and doesn't include me in his activities. Plus he's criticizing little things I do and we have disagreements about stupid stuff.

I need some advice. I'm scared to lose him. But if end things now, so what were the last six years for?


Dear Veronica,

We're sorry that you've had to experience so much pain from this relationship. Relationships deteriorate when they are allowed to stagnate, whatever the reason for that stagnation. That's what we think has happened here.

During the beginning of your time together, the connection between the two of you grew in strength and depth even though you communicated over a distance and did not see each other as often as you would have liked. This man may have hoped that he could become more committed over time, but obviously something blocked him from moving things to the next level.

The time was right for him to do this 5, 4, or even 3 years ago, by being able to trust you more, opening up to you more, and being able to commit to a future together. It is a general rule never to let things go too long without each side clearly expressing his/her long-term goals.

Relationships -- whether they are dating courtships or relationships between spouses -- are not meant to stay at the status quo. When one or both partners hold back from allowing their connection to grow, what they had starts to fall apart. It starts with little things that build over time, and they accumulate enough so that both partners are dissatisfied. Often, the deterioration is exacerbated by the fact that one partner wants to deepen the connection and wants to get married, and the other isn't ready or able or willing to do this.

At this point, there is a bigger question: What was your relationship like at its peak? Did you have compatible goals and values? Did you respect and admire each other, feel a deep level of trust and friendship, accept each other's flaws, and care for each other? Could you have pictured yourselves building a life together, and was this something you both wanted (even though he said he needed more time)? Can each of you answer yes to all of these questions?

If you can, then it may be possible to resurrect what you once had and then build upon that -- as long as each of you genuinely wants to make the effort to do so. We emphasize the words "each of you" because the desire to work on this has to be a mutual one. Both partners have to want the same goal, and have to be willing to invest the time and emotional energy needed to recapture and strengthen what they once had. And they have to acknowledge that they will need an experienced relationship counselor to guide them through the process. If the two of you aren't of the same mindset, there is no chance of success. You can't drag someone to therapy and expect it to amount to anything -- if he is coming along to appease you and not because he genuinely wants to achieve a goal.

Moving Forward

And there's another big point: We both have seen how therapy can help couples rebuild and improve their relationships, but this can only happen when the underlying relationship was once a viable and promising one. Therapy won't "fix" something that wasn't working in the first place.

Our hunch is that as you look back at this courtship, you'll see that one or more of the important elements we mentioned were never present. For example, there wasn't enough reciprocation. If you hadn't taken the initiative most of the time, you wouldn't have had nearly as much contact. And we question whether you ever had a deep enough level of mutual trust.

We suggest that you do some soul searching, and perhaps some writing, to sort all this out. If you decide that the two of you did have a promising relationship, you can ask him if he also would like to participate in couple's therapy to revitalize things, and if he also wants to address issues that may keep him from being able to move your courtship to deeper levels. However, if he's not interested, it isn't worth it for you to stick around. And certainly, if you come to the realization that your relationship wasn't strong enough in the first place, you'll need to accept the fact that all of the work in the world isn't going to make it much better.

If and when you move forward, we hope that you don't berate yourself for having invested six years in a courtship that didn't progress. Yes, six years is significant, but it's only recently that you came to realize that things weren't going to change for the better on their own. It will help you move forward with a positive frame of mind if you don't focus on the ways in which you may have been disappointed, and instead acknowledge all of the positive things that came out of this period of your life, such as the fact that you learned not only how to be a good giver, but you now realize how important it is for you to be a receiver, too.

Try writing down your ideas about the ways in which this relationship enriched you. When you feel angry at this man or at yourself, review this list. It will help you maintain a more balanced perspective and a healthy frame of reference as you move forward in life, and especially as you continue to navigate the dating maze.

Rosie & Sherry

December 1, 2007

Submit Your Dating Advice Question (Click here)

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 11

(11) Anonymous, December 10, 2007 7:21 AM

a wasted year

I just wasted the better part of a year on a guy who couldn't integrate me into his life and who valued a six figure paycheck and his career over me.
It might seem like a waste, but be strong and go on with life. It was an expensive lesson but hopefully it will lead you to better things.
I know several women in your shoes and it has taught me to put a time limit on men, 6 months, usually... even though I didn't listen to my own rules this past time I will say that it helps to see a date in the near future when you commit yourself to reviewing the relationship and really looking inside yourself to see if it's worth it.
I hope you find what you are looking for soon!

(10) Jake Daubney, December 7, 2007 8:51 AM

Sunk Relationship Costs

Veronica's current situation is not one she deserves, nor that she planned for. And the long distance relationship is not meeting her needs. But, having invested six years of her life, she is reluctant to break things off.

I would refer her to the economic doctrine of sunk costs. Her six year time investment cannot be recovered, and she should not let sunk costs influence future decisions, which should be assessed exclusively on their own merits.

In other words,Veronica can't get back her six years involvement, but she can make a sound decision about the future of her relationship, based on only the current situation and what her values tell her is best for her.

(9) Anonymous, December 6, 2007 1:16 AM

You deserve better

I've been in a similar situation in the past (though I got fed up a lot sooner!). Long-distance relationships need real commitment on both sides to work. In any case, they can only work if you both agree early on that you plan to be together in the longer term. I'm happier being on my own than in a dead relationship. It's scary at first but better for your emotional well-being; don't be afraid of losing this guy you deserve better.

(8) M, December 5, 2007 10:15 PM


You're reminding me of the situation I'm in. We once had a great connection, now we don't, and I don't want to let him go. It's so hard for me to know whether to move on or not.

(7) Anonymous, December 5, 2007 5:02 PM

6 Years

Why has Veronica been in a non-relationship for 6 years? The goal of any Jewish dating is marriage. It doesn't take 6 years to figure out if the person is/isn't the person you want to spend the rest of your life with.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment