click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

DATING MAZE #261 - Turning the Tables
Dating Advice 261

DATING MAZE #261 - Turning the Tables

Should she call him back if he fails to do so?

Dear Rosie & Sherry,

I am a single man living in the sunny Southwest. I really enjoy your excellent dating advice, but I respectfully disagree with your comments to Beth in "Almost the One" (Dating Maze #258). Even though this guy was a complete coward to never call back -- after saying that he wants to see her again -- why can't she just call him herself and ask, "What's up?"

There are many reasons why this man may not have contacted her. Why do we assume that all of the pressure to initiate the phone call falls on the man? Add that to initiating the date, selecting the place to go, and following up -- all of this can be pretty overwhelming. On top of that, many men feel as though we're constantly being judged by our date. Do our choices meet with her approval -- even though we don't know her well enough to know what she'd like?!

I am in favor of a little more balance, and a little less pressure on the man. I think it is absolutely acceptable for the woman to call the man to follow-up on their discussion about a second date. So I'm wondering why you didn't advise Beth to do that?

I also want to mention that from my personal experience, there's usually a reason why someone gets into their upper 30s or 40s without being married. I've found that the some of the biggest unresolved issues with women are related to their fathers, or to men in general. Personally, I've just about given up on finding a woman who I can marry!

Anyway, I think your column is great. I just think that you advice to Beth missed the mark.


Dear Michael,

Thank you for sharing your perspective on Dating Maze #258. Some of our female readers suggested that Beth call the man who began to plan a second date and never followed through, but what really got us thinking were the letters from men offering the same advice.

You're right that no one piece of dating advice suits everyone, because each person has unique life experiences, character traits, and perspectives on life. However, the advice we offer our readers is based on years of experience working with hundreds of dating and married individuals, and it can be adapted to different life situations.

We didn't want to add to her pain with a possible rejection.

First, let us explain why we didn't encourage Beth to call this particular man. She was in a great deal of emotional pain, and we didn't want to have her add to that pain by setting herself up for a possible rejection.

In our experience, most men who don't follow up on dates are not interested in going out again. A man may give the impression that he had a great time and will tell his date that he'll call -- even though he doesn't plan on doing so -- because he feels uncomfortable turning her down.

By avoiding an awkward situation, a man creates an uncertainty that can be agonizing for the woman who awaits his phone call. She at least knows where she stands when she hears something like:

I want to thank you for our date last night. After doing some thinking, I realize that we are two very different people, and I don't believe it is a good idea for us to go out again.

But when she waits for a phone call that never comes, she goes from being hopeful, to doubting herself, to feeling disappointed. She may begin to feel angry at her date for misleading her, and question her own self-worth. As a defense mechanism, she may even start to distance herself from having positive feelings about men in general, and that -- as you pointed out at the end of your letter -- can cause permanent damage.

Honest Apology

You and some of our other readers suggested a different reason why Beth's date never called her. Perhaps he was anxious or afraid of getting rejected. Or perhaps he had to deal with an emergency situation, and then felt too embarrassed to call when the emergency passed. You're right -- any of these may have been the case, and the best thing for him to do would have been to ask for a second date, even belatedly. Yes, he may have felt embarrassed, or Beth may have turned him down, but these are some of the risks inherent in dating.

A belated phone call should begin with an honest apology, and sound something like this:

I'm sorry to have taken so long to call you again. I know that it wasn't fair to leave you hanging. Can you accept my apology? I enjoyed our date and I do want to go out with you again. Would you like to meet next Thursday night?

Indeed, if the man expressed interest in continuing to go out, but never followed up, a woman like Beth could take the initiative to contact him, as you suggested. After a few days have passed, Beth could call to say, "We spoke about plans to get together this weekend and I hoped to hear from you about it."

But here's the catch: As she musters the courage to make that call, Beth also needs to prepare for an answer she may not want to hear. So only if Beth can deal with her own embarrassment and with her date's potentially negative reaction, it would be worth it for her to make the call or to send an e-mail.

But let's get back to the core issue: Even though we live in the 21st century, and logic tells us that a woman should be able to aggressively pursue a date, most of the men we know resent those efforts when they are made at an early stage of the dating process. Since it can often take several dates before a man gets a sense that he likes and is attracted to a particular woman, he may be turned off by her making a follow-up call at an early point in the courtship.

A mutual acquaintance could play "cupid."

Given that, there's an alternative -- and "safer" -- way for Beth to see if this man wants to continue dating. If the two of them had been introduced by a friend, or have a mutual acquaintance, she might ask that person to play "cupid." This third party can call the man and mention that Beth thinks it's worthwhile to go out again, and encourage him to do so. (In Beth's particular case, since they "met" through an Internet site, this option might not have been available to her.)

Unresolved Issues

Your letter added a new dimension to our view of Beth's situation. Now, we'd like to address your own. You remarked that many unmarried people in their late 30s and 40s have unresolved issues that may be keeping them from building a relationship that will lead to marriage. That is often the case, but there can be other factors that have made it difficult for them to achieve their goal. You then concluded that because you're tired of the emotional baggage carried by many of the women you've dated, you've given up on trying to find a good woman to marry.

If you've been disappointed by certain qualities many women you've dated have displayed, it may be more a factor of who you're meeting, rather than a general truth about the dating population. So we'd like to suggest are a few small changes that could make a big difference in the type of women you date:

1) Consider re-defining the qualities you are looking for, and narrowing them down to the four most important ones? Then, think about the criteria you've used in the past to decide whether or not to date someone. Is there a qualitative difference?

2) Next, think about how you've met the women you've dated. Did you meet them through friend's introductions or networking, at parties or social events, at a bar or club, at work or synagogue, through the Internet or a dating service? Which of these methods have resulted in dates with women who are close to what you are looking for? Why not consider focusing on using more of the "better" venues in the future, and on focusing on looking for those four important qualities, rather than on all of the criteria you've used in the past?

We believe that if you adopt these few ideas, you'll see a turnaround in the type and nature of the women you date. We don't want you to give up on the hope of finding a woman to marry and of building a home and family, which is what you seem to be on the brink of doing.

We wish you success in navigating the dating maze,

Rosie & Sherry

July 12, 2008

Submit Your Dating Advice Question (Click here)

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 16

(16) David, March 13, 2009 8:28 AM

Why does it suddenly sound insane when I turn the tables?

I, too, experienced the horrors of gender-confused romance. I was initially attracted to the passive, disinterested, unassertive woman who seemed to radiate that exotic aversion to hurt and rejection we men find so incomprehensible! I successfully passed all of the traditional mating rituals necessary to ensure that I was worthy of fathering her children only to discover that she had no interest in biological role models after the courtship phase was over. The signs were at first subtle. She initially claimed to resent my refusal to do housework as if it suited me as much as being hurt and rejected! When I finally conceded to pick up after myself, she angrily rejected my compromise. By the time it dawned on me that she wasn’t kidding about working outside of the home as a professional, I could no longer deny that she had lured me into sweeping her off of her feet knowing all along that she had no intention of basking in the glory of my shadow! The relationship left me with my self-esteem in a shambles, distrustful of women, but in command of a powerful lesson: I no longer take at face value the widespread lip-service paid over the past several decades to the virtue of female unassertiveness. If a date admits to having been to university, harboring professional aspirations, driving a car, or sometimes wearing pants, I immediately make it clear to her that if she expects me to take the heat she had better get back into the kitchen. And if my observation that women are really threatened by a confident man seems like an unfair generalization, to what shall I attribute the fact that I haven’t often dated the same woman twice in the past forty years?

(15) Anonymous, August 17, 2008 8:54 AM

Why did he call if he did not ask me out again?

At 50 I met a 60-yr-old Jewish man on a Jewish dating website. At coffee I had a better time than I expected as he was very businesslike and serious on the phone. We talked and laughed and after a couple of drinks and a couple of hours he walked me to my car and told me he'd had a very good time, to which I agreed. He made no mention of a future date and I smiled. A few days later he called me, asked me about my weekend and my 'dating' but, surprisingly enough, did not invite me out. I was not very comfortable during our phone conversation and sent him a text a few minutes after we hung up saying: "You are a much better communicator in person :-). How about a coffee?" and made a comment about it not being a habit of mine to give men my phone number in relation to a comment he'd made during our coffee that women put their phone numbers in his friend's pocket. I have not heard from here, no reply to my sms (rude!). Go figure men! Cheers, Aussie Girl

(14) Kenny, August 11, 2008 2:01 AM

Right On, Rosie and Sherry: Never call for second date.

The woman drops the hankie, the man pursues. If the man is no longer interested after the first date, he will respectfully let the woman know by not calling her for a second date. (The reason he doesn't call for a second date and the reason he may even go on a second date if she calls are the same: he doesn't want to be disrespectful and say "it's not going to work, I now find you repulsive." ) If the man is interested in a second date but the woman calls him first, she shoots herself in the foot because she derails his pursuit (since she is now pursuing) and kills his interest in a second date.
The only possible things she could do if she does call (and she should not call) is to drop another hankie (e.g. "I saw an article you may be interested in") or dump him (e.g. "Thank you for the nice time, but it's not going to work" or "Do you have any friends you could set me up with?") - do not mention a second date. These are the only things that could possibly get the pursuit juices flowing again.

(13) Evelyn, August 8, 2008 12:44 AM

I agree with anonymous -- similar experience

I just want to second the comment from anonymous. I had a similar experience with a guy who did the same thing -- would end each date with a promise to make plans and then wait for me to contact him. Sometimes he came through, other times he canceled at the last minute, or was so vague it was difficult to pin him down. Oddly enough, when I stopped pursuing him, he came around -- but (fortunately) I had learned my lesson and moved on. Weeks later he renewed contact -- by forwarding a joke by email. I took the hint, and deleted it with responding.

I've discovered -- through trial and error -- that it is important to recognize and admit to myself when a man does not show respect and consideration for me, my time, and my feelings. It is easy to "test" with a short email or quick phone call. PAY ATTENTION to his response. In most cases, you will discover that his response was predictably disrespectful and inconsiderate (i.e., doesn't acknowledge your feelings, fails to apologize for not following up, etc) and it feels liberating to let go of any expectations that he will be something other than what he is.

Finally, when someone behaves like this, it's important not to take it personally. Remember that if he (or she) treats you badly, it's highly likely that he (or she) treats everyone badly.

(12) anonymous, July 24, 2008 8:57 AM

I agree.. and here's my experience to prove it

Dear Rosie and Sherry,

I read this article and it struck a cord with me. I am the type of girl that would NEVER call a guy if he didn't call me. EXCEPT just one time! The guy said he'd like to go out again and didn't call. Ten days later I emailed him. He responded that he did want to go out again. I thought this was amazing!! I really liked him. We went out again and then he didn't contact me for another ten days. Long story short, we dated for 4 months and it was the worst relationship of my life. It was 4 months of waiting and wondering. It was 4 months of torture. I fully attribute this to the fact that I contacted him. I set the tone that this behavior was acceptable. I didn't see his true colors and that he was not willing to put in a full effort for me. I think that its unnecessary torture for a girl to be chasing a guy that doesn't fall head over heels for her. It never changes, the guy always stays that way. So if he isn't contacting you now, then he'll never be the man you really want. I've dated every type of guy under the sun and that is what I have learned. Don't think that they'll suddenly become the man you want, if they aren't trying to impress and woo you in the beginning, then they most likely never will.

~A Reformed Serial Dater

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment