Their early meetings sizzled, but now he's cool. What's the message?

by Rosie Einhorn, L.C.S.W. and Sherry Zimmerman, J.D., M.Sc.

Dear Rosie & Sherry,

Following a few painful relationships, I have done a lot of work on my inner self and I have come away with a better understanding of myself, what I want and deserve. I have now rejoined the dating world and have actually met someone that I like. There was a lot of excitement and energy in the beginning, and I have been taking it slow on my end. (I have a tendency to rush into things.)

My question is: How can you tell if a man is truly interested in you or is just playing? At the beginning he text-messaged me and called me frequently, and now a day or two can pass without me hearing a word from him. I resist the urge to initiate contact, but I wonder if he's simply not that interested anymore. This is all very confusing.

Rosemary

Dear Rosemary,

You're right, it is confusing! Sometimes, a man can be very eager in the excitement of a new relationship and once he eases into it he takes things at a more relaxed pace. That's not always a bad thing. Sometimes, it can be an indication that the quality of the relationship you are building is evolving from a strong "chemical" reaction to a deeper connection based on learning who each other really is.

But the opposite can also true. Sometimes, the initial intense feelings a person has about a relationship give way to a gradual detachment. This can happen for two reasons: either someone realizes, as they get to know the other person, that the initial attraction isn't leading to something deeper, or because they are the type of person who lives for the emotional high and loses interest when the exciting newness of a relationship wears off.

We suggest that for the time being, you continue to take it slow on your end and not initiate texting or calling. At the same time, you can look for certain indications that your courtship is progressing and that you are building a relationship. These include his being attentive and interested in learning about you and your life, his wanting to do "nice" things for you, and that your opinions and feelings are important to him. He should look forward to seeing you and spending time with you. We think that it's optimal to see each other twice a week (unless you're separated by distance or you have schedules that make it difficult for you to go out that often) and if your relationship is a growing one, he will want to see you on a regular basis. Texting and calling will not be enough.

Do you know if your life goals are compatible?

You should also be sensing that the depth of your emotional connection is growing. As you continue to date, you should be able to talk about more personal subjects than you did in the past, and feel comfortable confiding in each other. Do you want to share information about your lives with each other? Have you spoken about where each of you wants to go in life and whether your objectives are compatible? Do you feel comfortable together? Does he indicate that he's attracted to you? Admires certain things about you? Respects you and your opinions? You won't see these qualities increasing if the man you are dating is a "player."

We also suggest -- even if you believe that this man is sincere and your relationship with him is moving forward -- that you discuss the reason each of you is dating as early in your courtship as possible. It's important to be able to say, "I enjoy going out with you and I know it's too early for us to know how things will develop between us. But I wanted you to know that I'm dating to find the right person to marry, and it's important to me that anyone I go out with has a similar objective in mind. What about you?" If he wants something different at this point in his life, then no matter how much you like him, your relationship will not lead to the future you hope for.

Ultimately, time will answer your question. We encourage you to be cautiously optimistic: not jumping in, not running ahead with expectations, looking for indications that your relationship is growing -- but also understanding that it's possible that each of you have different expectations about where you want your lives to go and what you want out of the courtship.

We wish you success in navigating the dating maze,

Rosie & Sherry

Published: Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Aish.com relies on your support. Click here to support us.

Visitor Comments: 20

  • (20) Arnie Singer , November 6, 2009

    Some men need to feel the thrill and challenge of the "hunt". That's why they get really excited at the beginning of a relationship, when they are still trying to win over their "prey", and cool down when they feel secure in their conquest. What I suggest you do is play your part in this game. Take your time answering his calls, texts, or messages. Be busy occasionally, when he wants to meet. I realize this is game playing, and a guy who truly serious and ready should be totally eager and into being with you. If you feel this way, then you should say goodbye and find a man who you feel is ready. But is you want to stick with what you've got, then a little game playing is necessary.

  • (19) A. Nonymous , October 16, 2009

    Play it cool!

    The best discription of courtship I ever heard was from my wife: she chases him until he catches her! Men love it when a woman acts interested. Trust me--I know! But we still want to be perceived as the aggressor. My advice--always welcome his phone calls and attention, but have a specific reason (a question, a request, or whatever) in mind when you call him, so it isn't obvious that you're calling him just to chat. Hey--it worked for my wife! Good luck!

  • (18) Anonymous , October 15, 2009

    Thanks for the great advice

    Kenny are you some kind of dating expert? Thanks for taking the time to answer some of our comments it clarifies a few things... Especially on the commitment question I had.

  • (17) Steve , October 12, 2009

    Her not initiating contact may be the problem

    I can't agree with the idea that the man should always initiate contact. Why should he if he is unsure that she likes him ? Its 2009, why would a woman not take the initiative ? I'm in a situation myself where she doesn't initiate contact, and there has been no basic affection (holding hands etc), and I want that, and it has me wondering if I will find it sooner elsewhere. If she indicated her feelings then I would love to remain with her, as it is I'm about ready to drop it

  • (16) Kenny , October 7, 2009

    Man hunts! Woman drops hanky. And responses to previous posts.

    "Same boat": You got it right - men pursue. Technology has changed since Adam and Eve, but human nature has not. Women may drop a handkerchief, but they should never pursue - the man will run. If a woman must initiate a call (and she mustn't), it should only be to drop a handkerchief - she should not ask him out. (If a man has left a message asking the woman out, she may call back to say yes and plan the date.) Anonymous (12): It's not that men are afraid of commitment, it's that they have no exit strategy once they realize that the other is not the one (especially when things are going well). Anonymous (5): after you've been dating awhile, maybe she can make a picnic, but at the beginning, a man should be the man. Anonymous (4): Right. When either party figures out the other is not the one, move on as fast as you can. Don't miss the one in front of you while you're still looking behind. Wish you the best! Loretta: Stop having coffee! Don't hang out! Put your friends to work - ask each of them to set you up with a friend who might be interested in dating you. Women, take it slow. Men don't cool off if they are actually interested.

  • See All Comments Add Comment

About the Author

Rosie Einhorn, L.C.S.W. and Sherry Zimmerman, J.D., M.Sc.


Questions for Rosie & Sherry can be sent to
datingmaze@aish.com. Due to the large volume of questions received, they are unable to answer each one.

Rosie Einhorn (a psychotherapist) and Sherry Zimmerman (a psychotherapist and former family lawyer) are the authors of the books In the Beginning - How to Survive Your Engagement and Build a Great Marriage and Talking Tachlis - a Singles?€˜ Strategy for Marriage, published by Targum Press. They are the founders of Sasson V'Simcha (www.jewishdatingandmarriage.com), a non- profit organization that provides programs and services in North America, Israel, and Europe to help Jewish singles and the people who care about them.

Related Articles

Sponsors

    Aish.com Features

    • Chanukah: December 12 - 19, 2009
    • What's new at aish.com
    • Candlelighting Times
    • Kaddish & Mourning
    • Your Hebrew Name & Birthday
    • Programs in Israel