click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Coming On Too Strong?
Dating Advice

Coming On Too Strong?

I thought things were going amazing when she out of the blue called it off. What happened?


Hi Rosie and Sherry,

First off, I really enjoy your articles on! They are a true inspiration and the advice is very well worth listening to. Thank you!

I just experienced a truly unique dating situation. Can you please help me understand what happened after only a few dates? The story starts a couple weeks ago when I was introduced to a young lady by a mutual friend. We’re both in the same profession and the setting seemed perfect for a relationship. I eagerly agreed to meet her.

We went out for coffee for the first date and things seemed to be going well. We discovered a mutual passion for our Jewish heritage. We even discovered that we had gone to the same Jewish summer camp. Our activity levels were the same as well and since I like living as full a life as possible, that was important to me. I thought we were perfect for each other!

After another date, I offered to take her out to dinner to celebrate her passing her professional licensing exam and she seemed appreciative and excited. I even got her a small gift. A couple days before our planned dinner, she sent me a text out of the blue saying she wanted to stop seeing each other. I told her I respect her decision and that I hope we can stay in touch. Now I'm stuck feeling disappointed and rejected.

This was a tough blow because I was dating patiently for the last couple years. I live in a small city and often to meet Jewish singles, I would have to drive over an hour to Philly or New York. Usually, the relationships I did have couldn't withstand the distance. I also felt like I couldn't truly get to know someone. I was so excited to meet a like-minded person who lived so close by. I'm worried I came on too strong because of my excitement. Plus, she’s just beginning her career and I’m more established. I am further along in my career than she is. Did she feel overwhelmed by the prospect of dating someone more mature?

I still have feelings for this girl. Is there any chance we can work it out? Should I try to contact her again after we both cool off? Can you give me some advice so that I don't make the same mistake twice?

Kindly appreciated,

Hopeful and encouraged! Down but not out.

Rosie Einhorn, L.C.S.W. and Sherry Zimmerman, J.D., M.Sc.

Rosie and Sherry's Answer:

Thank you for writing to us. There could be a number of reasons why the dating that seemed so promising to you ended the way it did:

She may not feel ready for marriage and realizes that you are.

Your enthusiasm may have scared her; you were coming on too strong. Many times when one person quickly develops positive feelings about their dating partner and the other person feels more neutral, the more neutral dater gets scared off. They don’t know how to handle the difference in

emotions, worry that they may never get to the point that they feel the same way, and think that it’s not right to continue dating because of this.

You may have "pushed a button" that turned her off at some point. She may have decided that you aren’t what she's looking for, even though you have a lot in common and your dates were positive.

We understand that you’re disappointed because you liked her and saw potential she may not have seen. Even though you only went out twice, it will take a little while to work through your feelings of rejection and disappointment. It's important to realize that things might not have progressed simply because you are not right for each other, and to learn what you can from what happened.

What can you learn? First of all, if there's one woman who has a lot of the qualities you’re looking for, there's got to be another one. The fact that you connected so easily can be a bit of an ego boost for you if you’re had your share of slow-starting relationships. (The right relationship may end up being a slow starter, but it is nice to sometimes have a very positive experience on the first two dates.) We hope you also learn not to take this personally; the reasons for her breaking things off are probably completely out of your control.

It is a good idea, in the future, to hold back your excitement and enthusiasm a bit. You may be able to pace yourself better if you had a dating mentor to speak with about this.

Finally, it's important for you to be able to move on at some point and not carry around the hope for what could have been. It may be a good idea to wait until you've processed your feelings a little more. Then you can decide if you'd like to have a third party ask your former date if there is an issue relating to the reason why she ended things that you can address so that she'd be willing to out with you again. If the answer is no, then accept the fact that you have to move forward. If the answer is yes, then we suggest you talk about what you can do differently with a mentor.

All the best,
Sherry and Rosie

October 26, 2014

Submit Your Dating Advice Question (Click here)

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 10

(10) Dave, January 13, 2018 2:59 AM

Men are Criticized Either Way

A gift celebrating a Major Accomplishment isn't the same as a Gift given because of romantic feelings.

In today's messed up world of Internet and Social Media Woman are extremely confused about what a Good Man is all about.

If he didn't do anything nice for her, She would have viewed him as Cheap or a Jerk,

Just Saying

(9) Shlomo, November 25, 2014 2:58 PM

If there is a chance...

You said that you met through a mutual friend who prosumably is still in touch with her. We have no idea why she broke it off with you but if it was because she panicked because you were going too quickly for her and she wasn't sure if you "were the one" then your best aproach is keep cool, move on and find your next date. If she's at all interested in you then she'll know and realise that she may have missed on a great guy and make it known through this friend. If not then you are already moving on to the next possibility. Whatever you do, don't wait for her...

(8) Anonymous, November 11, 2014 5:28 AM

No gifts.

Too early for gifts - that's coming on too strong. Having similar likes is not a sign of much. Find out about her goals in life, her values, how she relates to family, how she feels or acts towards kids, etc.

(7) Akiva, October 31, 2014 9:55 PM

It may not have been anything you did

The young lady may have met you during a break-up but decided to stay in her other relationship. In that case, she probably wouldn't want to share any details. My wife is 8 years younger than I, she's from the East Coast, I'm from the Left Coast, she's an indoor type, I'm an outdoor type and so forth - we've been married over 38 years and have 3 children - so, go figure - don't over-think minor issues - above all, don't try too hard, be yourself, be genuine - ladies can sense it when you're trying to put on a "good first impression" and you don't want to have to be on stage for the rest of your life.

(6) Rocky, October 30, 2014 6:45 PM

There Was Someone Else

I agree with TMay and Anonymous. There could be unresolved feelings from a recent breakup, and she is not ready to move on. Or she has a guy who has repeatedly treated her like garbage but she cannot break away because he is manipulative enough to say he is sorry every so often to keep her around. Both situations are sadly all too common. So keep you head up, stay enthusiastic, and at some point you will meet someone who does appreciate you. Good luck!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment