click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Dating Maze #368: Just Text Me
Dating Advice 368

Dating Maze #368: Just Text Me

Our entire relationship consists of text messages. Is this normal?


Dear Rosie & Sherry,

I live in New York and have been tele-dating a guy from the Midwest. We met once for three days. He's very much into texts and does not call that often. He told me he would be ready to discuss “moving forward” for my birthday this past July, but now he says he’s not ready to talk.

He still texts me a few times a week, and if I let more than a day go by without replying, he makes sure to send me another message asking if everything is okay.

What's going on? What should I do?


Rosie Einhorn, L.C.S.W. and Sherry Zimmerman, J.D., M.Sc.

Rosie and Sherry's Answer:

Dear Jill,

At first glance, your letter describes a dilemma that many others have struggled with. You see possibilities with the person you're dating and would like to move things forward, but he is unsure. Since you know that people become invested in a relationship at different paces, you let him take the time he needs to get clarity. That time has long passed, and now, you're tired of being in limbo. You want to know what you can do to get this man to say something (anything!) about where he sees this relationship going.

Perhaps the problem is that he isn't ready for serious dating. Ideally, someone who isn't ready for marriage shouldn't get involved with those who are dating for marriage – and they should make this lack of intention clear from the beginning. And certainly, if one person is eager to move forward, the other shouldn't give false hope by saying that he's ready when he isn't, or by setting a deadline he’s not determined to meet.

We have seen people succeed at “making themselves ready” for marriage, but not by giving themselves an arbitrary deadline. They’ve done it by taking a break from dating, figuring out what they need to accomplish to be ready for marriage, making a plan for how to do it, and then getting it done.

Texting is a poor substitute for phone calls, Skype, and even email.

The other major reason why people get stuck is that they aren't sure how they feel about the person they’re dating. Sometimes, they're grappling with an issue they need to resolve, such as whether they can be okay with a dating partner's personality trait, or with something about her background or health. Or they may be worried how she'll react to something they haven't yet told her. Or they may worry whether a major difference in goals, values or lifestyle can be reconciled.

Another possibility is that one person isn't where he needs to be at this point in terms of attraction and/or emotional connection. This is likely what's happening with the man you're dating. Because he uses texting as the primary means of communication, he's barely gotten to know you, and his expectations about where he should "be" are premature. In other words, the texting has actually kept your relationship from developing.

Texting is intended as a way of short, spontaneous or emergent messaging. It's ideal for confirming appointments, quick updates ("on my way" or "running late"), or a brief "thinking of you," "good morning," or other one-line messages. It's not a way to carry on a conversation – it's not an alternative to an actual date, and it's a very poor substitute for phone calls, Skype, and even email.

People who use texting as their preferred form of communication lose out on the opportunity to discuss a subject in depth, the way we do in a face-to-face or phone conversation. There are no long talks or opportunities to express thoughts and feelings that enable you to get a sense of who each other really are. Instead, your communication is by nature brief and superficial – encouraging people to replace "depth and subtlety in their thinking with quick mental facts that only skim the surface." (Dr. Gary Small, Psychology Today). Think of like a situation comedy – observations and cute one-liners, but not much more.

The nuance of spoken words, non-verbal cues, and chemistry are all missing from a text exchange.

Communication doesn't only consist of the words we use. During a face-to-face meeting, we observe another person's facial expressions, gestures and body language. We hear the tone and nuance of the spoken words. We can see if the other person is paying attention or is distracted. We can learn to read and respond to each other's non-verbal cues. We pick up on a person’s nervous habits, as well as their endearing ones. These are the experiences that enable us to feel a sense of chemistry. All of this is missing during a text exchange.

This man may think that the few dates you had over a three-day period was enough to build upon, and that things can continue with the help of cyberspace. He's mistaken. Those first few face-to-face meetings were only helpful to decide if you’re comfortable enough with each other's appearance and manner of relating.

Texting can be abused as a way to pass the time without really becoming emotionally invested or involved. Author Emma Gray calls texting “the pygmy of communication methods. It's a Post-it note, a P.S. It's minimum investment, minimum effort. It's often cowardly – a way to avoid face-to-face contact.'"

By texting, this man is stringing you along. He may even have a number of these “relationships” going at once – biding his time, without making any commitment, just waiting to see what pans out. It’s also possible he has no intention of any of these relationships becoming more than they are now.

You need to pull this relationship out of its rut. Tell him that so far you’ve enjoyed the texting, but now you need more face-time.

The first step is that he needs to clarify to himself whether he's ready for a serious relationship that may lead to marriage.

After that is resolved, the next step is to decide if the two of you have potential.

We're not surprised that this man can't make a decision about what he wants to do. Texting has kept you from learning about each other on a deeper level, developing the beginning of an emotional connection, and enabling any physical attraction to grow. No matter how many months you've been texting, you are still at a very early stage in the courtship. It's too early for it to be a statement that he's getting "serious."

What you need is another long trip to see each other – an opportunity to learn more about each other and how you relate. Think of it as the 4th, 5th and 6th dates.

Limit texts to a quick "hi" in the middle of the day.

We recommend that you arrange to see each other within the next few weeks for face-to-face dates. You need to interact in different venues – doing varied activities, and talking about topics in-depth. This will help you see different sides of each other and develop a shared history that enables you to form an emotional bond. During the stretches of time you can't be together, telephone and Skype can help you continue the momentum you started to develop.

In between, talk on the phone or Skype a few times a week. If he feels uncomfortable transitioning away from text, start with 15-minute calls, during which you can each talk about your day, something you saw in the news, what you're looking forward to, or an interesting experience. From there, move on to longer, one-hour "phone dates."

As for texts, limit those to a quick "hi" in the middle of the day. For while texting can be a good way to convey short messages, it's not a good way to build a relationship.

We wish you success in navigating the dating maze,

Rosie & Sherry

October 12, 2012

Submit Your Dating Advice Question (Click here)

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 7

(6) Sandy, December 17, 2012 1:24 AM

Tell him

That seems so sad. Texting can never express what you really feel and can't even convey the guy's sincerity through his gestures and the look in his eyes. Better tell him that you need more than texting and if he is really serious with you, he will immediately grant your wish and accept your concerns. For the better ment of your relationship, tell him everything and surely he will understand. The result will not be instant but surely this will improve your bond if you let him be aware of his shortcoming, but tell him in a good and friendly way.

(5) L.S., October 26, 2012 8:46 PM

he's not into you

sad to say, he's not that into you. move on and find a man who is into you; real men call! hatzlacha!

(4) Anonymous, October 19, 2012 2:41 PM

Please consider

As usual, the comments and advice, from the experts, are excellent. May I suggest that you consider something that might serve you long term? May I suggest that you already know the answer to the questions that you posed. I would venture that you are really asking what is keeping you hanging on to the faintest hope. What is the string that is holding you? You know the story of the powerful elephant being held by a rope. The elephant can easily tug at the rope and escape but we know that the elephant stays. That rope keeps the elephant in place. What is the rope, within you, that keeps your heart in prison. You see, the cruelty of this is hard to explain. You know what you must do, but first you must find out why you are holding on to that string. You know that he will not marry you. It is a love lost and so find a way of grieving and burying it. It is perfectly fine to let go. Life is open. There is no such thing as "if I let this go then how do I know that there will be something else?" That type of thinking, in a relationship, leads to misery. Love yourself. Treat yourself well. Let go of any fantasies that you may entertain. Is this texting life for you? Do you wait for that next magic text? Is it heaven when it arrives and then misery for days? Read "Waiting for Godot" and see how the metaphor applies to your present life. Know what keeps you imprisoned within your own self. Know your own worth. This way you will not be kept on a string, text, next time.

(3) ST, October 19, 2012 1:32 PM

Just stop texting

The solution here is simple. Tell the guy texting isn't working for you, and that you prefer your communication over the phone. If he won't do that, move on. Women need to stop making excuses for guys who treat them poorly and don't show them respect.

(2) Anonymous, October 18, 2012 7:41 PM

So much to say ...

... and surprised there is only one comment posted ... EXCEPT that we should distance ourselves from the raven (especially timely as we prepare for this week's parsha). Still, I will try to turn my own negative experience into something that might help another. The good news is this young woman is hopeful and has focused on the good potential of her relationship with this man. Please retain this hope as you follow the provided advice and move forward. Wishing all of us all the best. And thank you to the writer for requesting feedback; I know a lot of us can benefit from the advice!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment