click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Join 400,000 Aish subscribers
Get Email Updates




Dating Maze #341: Getting Over the Hurdle
Dating Advice 341

Dating Maze #341: Getting Over the Hurdle

My fiancée doesn't want to spend what I think is necessary quality time. It's starting to freak me out.

by

Dear Rosie & Sherry,

I recently became engaged to a woman I've been dating for many months. I'm hoping that we can be a happy couple and raise a family together. But we have a problem that I don't know how to handle, and I hope you can give me some advice.

Both of us are busy professionals. "Anna" handles her work load differently than I handle mine. She needs a lot of time by herself to prepare her lectures and to "recover" from heavy schedules. We are so much apart that some time I have the feeling that I'm being excluded from her life. We live 30 minutes away, but to me it feels as if we’re in a long-distance relationship.

When we're together, Anna is devoted to me, but I don't think we're together often enough. She said she loves me, but I feel as if there’s a gap in our relationship – that I’m here for her but she just “appears” to be there for me.

I am trying to find the strength to bear this situation. I respect Anna and don't want to make demands on her. I would like to have the right attitude and be a good partner. But I feel our relationship isn't balanced. We've spoken about this many times, and yet nothing has changed.

I'm suffering a lot and it's affecting my work and well-being. Is there something going on here that I don't understand?

Brian

Dear Brian,

At first glance, your letter describes the struggle of many couples who need to strike a balance between their individual lives and their life as a couple. When someone who is accustomed to packing their life with work, hobbies, activities and friends is in a serious relationship, it is a challenge to figure out how to spend more time with their significant other. They may think it is just a matter of juggling their schedule. Or they may believe that their “couple time” can fit into the same schedule as when they were going on dates once a week.

However, their partner expects – and their relationship requires – a bigger share of their time and attention. If they want the relationship to continue to develop, much less survive, they have to learn to reshuffle their priorities.

How does a busy person know which comes first and which second?

Honoring work commitments, eating, sleeping, errands, exercise, friendships and continuing one's education are all important – but how does a busy person know which comes first and which comes second? The question reminds us of the Aish.com film about a teacher who filled a large jar with rocks, and asked the students if the jar was full. When they agreed that it was, he proved them wrong, first by adding gravel to the jar, then sand that fit into the spaces, and then pouring water into the jar.

Some students thought that the purpose of the demonstration was to show that no matter how busy their life was, they could always fit in something else. The real message, the teacher explained, was that if you don't put in the big rocks first, there will never be room for them.

Accommodating Differences

That's a message many on the dating scene need to absorb. Once casual dates blossom into a relationship, particularly one of an engaged couple planning to build a life together, we have to make time for each other and then fit the rest of our lives around that. We need sufficient time to do things together, to converse, relax, and share emotional support. We also need some private time for ourselves, to pursue our interests, and connect with old friends.

Some people are able to adapt quickly to this new phase of life, but for many that adaptation is not easy. When we see a couple struggling to sort through competing interests, we often suggest they arrange a few meetings with a couples' counselor, who can help them strike a proper balance.

It sounds to us as though there's more than this to your particular situation. Your fiancée has told you that she needs time to prepare for her lectures and to unwind after a hectic day, and you have a hard time understanding why these take so long and interfere with your time together. It seems that the two of you have different energy levels, and that is another aspect of your relationship that you need to fine tune.

This, too, happens quite often. Think of how many couples you know where one is a night person, and the other a day person. Or one partner is very neat and orderly, and the other more casual about neatness and order. Many couples figure out how to accommodate these differences after a bit of trial and error. It helps if each of them is somewhat flexible and can respect the fact that they have different bio rhythms and organizational skills and needs.

It is unfair to expect that she will fulfill all your needs.

It's also possible that the two of you have different expectations of how much time two engaged (and married) people should spend together. Sometimes as a couple grows close to each other and solidifies their relationship, one of the partners begins to expect that the relationship, as well as the other person, will fulfill all of their needs – for companionship, social life, leisure time, and helping them achieve a sense of fulfillment and happiness. It's important to understand how this is an unfair expectation, and places undue demands on the relationship. While marriage must be the priority, each partner must also see themselves as individuals who have their own interests, careers, friendships and personal needs. One of the biggest challenges of a new relationship is how to balance couple needs and personal needs in a realistic and mutually satisfying way.

This is an issue that you need to address together. You don't want to expect more from your fiancée than you should, but it sounds as if instead of trying to understand her needs and work together to find a solution, perhaps you are over-focusing on Anna and putting unrealistic expectations on her. Or at least more than she is willing to give.

This is another instance in which a couple's therapist may be able to help you express your feelings and process what your partner has to say. And to know that you yourself have been heard. That's a valuable communication skill for every couple, and is the first step to finding a solution you can both be happy with.

Working through Difficulties

We also have suggestions about how you might be able to find more time to be together, even though you live a half hour apart. In addition to the time you set aside to have fun, try spending an evening once a week, just being together while she prepares lectures in the library, or running errands together on Sunday morning. You might also meet at each other's work location once a week and go out to lunch together. Try brainstorming with each other to think of other ideas.

Once you're married, you'll treasure just sitting down to dinner together after work on an ordinary day, or taking a break in the middle to share the moment over a cup of coffee. This isn't much different than that.

We imagine that someone reading this column might think, "This is too much work. Get out of it," or "You love each other… don't worry, this will work itself out." Neither attitude is correct. Most engaged and newly-married couples spend a period of time working out differences like the one you described, and the presence of these differences does not mean the couple is incompatible. It means they're normal.

One last thought: The first year or so of marriage, and often the months of engagement, are a time of transition – learning about each other and making mutual accommodations. The problem isn't that couples have to go through this; the real problem is that nobody tells them that it’s part of the process of growing together as a couple. Unfortunately, many marriages end in divorce because the couple doesn’t realize that working through difficulties – even serious difficulties – is part and parcel of any long-term committed relationship. That’s reason enough to enlist the help of a couple's therapist.

We hope our advice has been helpful, and we wish you the very best.

Rosie & Sherry

Published: September 3, 2011


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Submit Your Dating Advice Question (Click here)

Visitor Comments: 12

(10) Anonymous, October 10, 2011 6:33 PM

Run Away

Dear Brian, I hear your pain, i strongly suggest you to close your eyes for a minute and envision yourself 5 years from now, do you really think that her actitud will change? chances are NOT.. dont get stuck to the idea that someone will change, chances are that your will be sad for your choice in the long run,

(9) Tammy, September 11, 2011 8:52 PM

Not enough time

It sounds like this women may be an HSP which stands for highly sensitive person. I am one of these. Do a google search if you don't know what this is. I require a lot of time to myself and it takes me awhile after being out and about to unwind. HSP's senses seem to get much more stimulated then the average person's and if this is the case with this mans fiance then this will never change. This is something for him to think about and consider before marrying her. Its not that she doesn't love him or want to be with him its just that she needs the time to herseff. Before I knew this about myself my husband wanted to constantly be with me. I barely had a moment to myself and it was driving me crazy. It almost ended our marriage at one time. But once he realized that this is how I am and I am not going to change, then he backed off and allowed me my space and room to breath. Things were and are fine now. He respects it about me and gives me the time I need and the room to breath and just be with myself. It is no offense to him, I love him dearly and can't imagine life without him but I just have to have time to myself as well.

(8) Anonymous, September 10, 2011 9:06 PM

I cannot see this relationship being a happy one in the long run

I believe what the two of you need emotionally is too different to be satisfactory for the two of you. You want a warm, caring relationship with good communication whereas I can see your girlfriend being more remote and very private in her need to be a lot by herself

(7) Miriam, September 8, 2011 4:39 AM

Counseling sounds like a good way to go.

Maybe you're too demanding; maybe she's not ready for a committed relationship. Or maybe you guys could make it work. I agree with Rosie and Sherry: the only way to find out is to go for the counseling and see what comes out of that.

(6) Pauline, September 7, 2011 12:24 AM

Concern your self with the bigger problem.

It is not clear here if the male could be on the suffocating side or if the female could be on the dumber than dirt or ice queen side. (The quantity of time and calls with each other are not mentioned.) But this is what I think is the biggest problem. It's mentioned that this topic has been discussed SEVERAL times, with NO change or improvement. My thought is that in marriage there will be many differences of opinion, and bigger challenges too. And as the other comments mention, adding kids multiplies the difficulties times 10. If a couple that is newly in love can not find a way to listen with their hearts, and hear each other and work out differences now, in a way that is mutually satisfactory, then later it will be a nightmare. Imagine spending your life discussing the same problems over and over with someone who seems never to get it, or who just plain does not care how it makes the other feel. Or how it feels to be with a person whom no matter how much time and attention you give, it's never enough, a virtual bottomless pit draining you dry. Either way can make one feel as if they are never good enough, either to be loved, or at loving. If a mutual understanding is not found within one session with a counselor, then they need to move on separately. He is already being negatively affected by this probably toxic relationship.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!