click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

My Fiancée’s Son
Dating Advice

My Fiancée’s Son

She doesn’t want to get married until her child is ready. Should I wait?


Dear Rosie and Sherry,

I am a 38-year-old European Jew. Last February I met a Jewish woman of my age, who lives in another city; she is divorced and has a 9-year-old son. When we met, I was applying for aliyah to Israel but we fell in love (or at least I did), so I decided to put that on hold.

After three months bliss, she started to postpone the decision to introduce me to her family. Later, she decided she didn't love me and broke up, only to come back after two weeks and finally say she was sure about us and she eventually introduced me to her son and her family. Everything seemed to work, and I felt like I was in heaven.

Her ex-husband is still jealous of her, although they separated seven years ago and she has a get (Jewish divorce papers). He told their son bad things about me. Nonetheless, the situation didn't look bad, and this summer she told me that in a few months, we would decide on a wedding date.

But recently, her son asked her to go and stay with his father for a week, and then for another week. My fiancée started to panic, and I admit I didn't immediately realize how painful the situation was for her. She is now consulting a therapist to get advice and help. She says she understands that her son is having a normal reaction for his age, and she knows it will take a lot of time for him to come to terms with the new situation.

What worries me very much, though, is that until a few weeks ago, she was telling me how worried she was about her biological clock and how we should get married as soon as possible, but now she tells me that six months or a year delay will make no difference and that I should not press her to get married, until she feels okay about the situation with her son. Now she is telling me that a woman can easily have children even in her early 40s!

I love this woman and I am doing my best to make the relationship work. But I can't give up on having children. Is she right in not wanting us to move on, while we're helping her son? Couldn't we do both things at the same time? How can I help her cope with the situation? Should I wait for her, or break up right away?

Thank you for any help you may give me.


Rosie Einhorn, L.C.S.W. and Sherry Zimmerman, J.D., M.Sc.

Rosie and Sherry's Answer:

Dear Louis,

Based on our extensive experience in working with parents who want to remarry after divorce, it seems to us that the woman you have been dating has made a very wise decision. She needs to have a stable situation for herself and her son, both for their own well-being and for the well-being of her future relationship with you. She’s also made the right choice to work with a therapist to learn how to deal with a little boy who may be caught in the middle between her and a jealous father. And we also feel that she was right to request that the two of you delay wedding plans until her situation with her son improves.

Blending a family is a challenge, made even more difficult if a parent remarries before she or her child are “ready.”

When divorced or widowed men and women come to us for advice about dating and remarrying, we always advise them to make sure that they and their children have healed from the divorce and that the parent-child relationship is comfortable enough for the parent to bring another adult into the family. As it is, blending a family is a challenge, but it can be even more difficult if a parent remarries before she or her child are “ready.” Many times, a therapist can help this process along.

Even though the woman you’re dating hasn’t had her ex in her life for many years, she didn’t anticipate that her relationship with her son would take a turn for the worse once she became serious with you. It doesn’t matter if the stress that prompted this was her ex’s attempt to sabotage her becoming serious with you, or because it is difficult for her son to accept the fact that she’s involved with someone who isn’t his father. Her having to address this situation puts her in a similar situation as someone who’s only recently been divorced – she needs to strengthen her son and their relationship, even though it means that your wedding plans need to be put on hold for a while.

We know this is difficult for you for two reasons – you love her and want to move forward in your relationship, and you’re concerned about delaying starting your family. However, if you really want this woman in your life, the best thing you can do now is to accept the fact that what she’s doing now will ultimately help the two of you have a smoother transition to a blended family, and to genuinely support her efforts. Both of you can acknowledge to each other that you feel frustrated that you have to wait, but know this is the best thing for your future.

We can’t speak with certainty about how a delay of six months to a year will affect your ability to have a few children together. We do know that since she’s already had a child, she has a better chance of being able to become a mother again in her late 30s and her 40s. You can also consider that it’s more difficult to conceive under stress and that if you delay your wedding plans so that she can improve the situation with her son, this will be to your benefit.

Of course, if you’re impatient about the wait, you can decide to break up and move on. However, if you feel that this woman is right for you, treat this period of time as an opportunity to strengthen your emotional connection with her and to slowly build a relationship with her son.

We also suggest that the two of you work with a family therapist to advise you the best way to do this. In fact, we recommend that any time a man and woman plan to blend a family, they work with a family therapist who can help guide them through the process. This is especially important because you haven’t been a parent before, and you can’t slowly grow into your role the way the parent of a new baby does.

We know that waiting longer will be a challenge for both of you, but if you are able to change your mindset about this and appreciate how much it will benefit the woman you are dating and your future family life together, the wait will be easier.

We wish you all the best,

Sherry and Rosie

November 3, 2013

Submit Your Dating Advice Question (Click here)

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 27

(15) Louis, November 10, 2013 10:25 AM

I have to move on

It's being now two weeks since she decided to break up. I am trying to overcome the shock. I really did believe she was the woman of my life, and I was ready to face any struggle, but she is very clear about her decision.

I put too much pressure on her because I wanted us to decided on a date, while helping her child to cope. This scared her away.

Maybe, if I look at it rationally, I am the one who should have broken up. But instead the only thing that's really broken here is my heart!

But I can, must and want to look forward. HaShem will provide me a wife, one with whom there can be mutual respect and love and possibly we will be blessed with children and live in Eretz Israel.

Thanks everyone for all the different insights and help. Thanks Sherry and Rosie.


Roch, November 21, 2013 1:20 PM

Any appreciation for you?

Thank you for sharing. We can see this is painful but lesson learned that a relationship that is good for each of the partners should bring out the best in each of you, that you are good for each other. Yes, the practical aspects have to be worked out but what you went through was abusive. We do not do that to those we love. We can speculate on reasons why she may have done or not, but that is a waste of time and energies. A friend had told me long ago, her Rabbi had said, "these things are known within a 'season'"--being flexible on how a season can be variously defined! Once again, the practical nature of life may have us stretch the term a bit, but never into years and years. Post 7 years she undoubtedly knew you were reasonably going to leave and broke it off. There are probably also other things she was not telling you. There are a whole lot of lies here. Do not try to justify all this. In all this, never once did the mention of 'appreciation' for who you are came up. 7 years is a lifetime and not a season. Have to understand that some people are drama-obssessed and continually use other people to validate their existence and create a gravitas for themselves. Just think of your life elsewhere for 7 years and you should be grateful this is over this quickly! This is life. We all have a version of this. Press on. We wish you the best.

Anonymous, November 21, 2013 1:26 PM


Forgot to say, that if she comes back, do not go back. It is over. Soph. It's a possibility and you may be hurting, lonely and tempted. If not possible in 7 years, then no way it is not manipulative. and 7 years is longer than a good number of marriages. My dad would say, you can never go back and he was right. Not kosher.

(14) Louis, November 7, 2013 10:54 PM

Thank you for so many advices

To be fair, the reason why she divorced is that her ex turned out to be a gambling addict and he refused to get help. She hardly gets any money from him.
But for other things you say, you are probably right. I still feel in love, but maybe I must face the fact that she doesn't love me. Only I don't understand why she would keep up our relationship until now (certainly, again, not for financial interest, because I am not rich).

CJ, November 9, 2013 5:45 PM

Move on.

I am a social worker and have worked in mental health for many years. The choice is up to you but I advise to move on. There is obviously indecision and manipulation going on between this woman, her ex and the son. It's been 7 years. Do you want a life filled with drama, heartache and very possibly a lack of your own biological children? Fertility can be a huge issue for women in their late 30's and 40's. There is a condition called "secondary infertility." Secondary infertility is defined as the inability to become pregnant, or to carry a pregnancy to term, following the birth of one or more biological children. Because a woman has gotten pregnant once does not mean she will be able to conceive a child in her late 30's or 40's. if your goal is to settle down in a successful marriage, have children, along with a stable and drama free family life, look elsewhere.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment