click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Jessica #26 - Nice Jewish Boy?

Jessica #26 - Nice Jewish Boy?

The knight-in-shining-white-overalls overcomes Jessica's overactive mouth.


It's no small wonder that I went into TV production and not on-camera journalism. Write my thoughts down, I can always do. Speak them aloud? Hello, nitwit mouth.

I can just imagine me reporting from the scene of some horrible crime.

Anchor: "And now to Jessica Shaeffer, live at the scene of today's heinous but ratings-boosting criminal act!"

Cut to me, spacing out.

Anchor: "Jessica?"

I look up, startled.

Anchor: "Uh, Jessica, can you tell us what's going on at the bloody scene, or maybe grab one of the victim's relatives to sob on camera while you ask ridiculous questions like 'How does it feel having found your mother bludgeoned to death?'"

Me, looking sheepish after stammering a few nonsensical words: "Uh, sure, Bob... perhaps I could just e-mail the viewers the details.'

Cut to me, real-life, standing outside Rick's office door, trying to formulate in my head what to say.

I'd been planning this for two weeks, too chicken to openly ask him out. Then he sent me a cute little package expressing interest.

It was very adult of him, and brave too, but my secretary had delayed giving it to me for a few days. So now I was trying to figure out how to best acknowledge his interest, return it, and simultaneously explain that I'd gotten the package late.

I stood there, trying to blend into the wall each time someone walked by.

I stood there for about four minutes, a seeming eternity, trying to blend into the wall each time someone walked by. I nearly had two sentences formed when the door opened -- and naturally it was he, looking at me strangely.

--"Jessica!?" he said, looking surprised but pleased to see me tarrying in the corner. "Uh, what are you doing?"

My brain skipped first gear and lurched into fourth.

"I'm trying to find the words to ask you out and also tell you that I didn't get your package until this morning and I wasn't playing games," I blurted.

He laughed.

"Oh, man," I sighed to myself. "Verbal stream-of-consciousness yet again trumps any facade of cool."

He was still smiling. Good sign.

"Before I sound any more idiotic, can I take you for lunch? I still owe you a thank you for changing my tire," I said feebly.

"Sure, Jessica. I'll gladly have lunch with you," he said.

We ended up grabbing sandwiches at a sub place and sitting in a small park nearby that I'd not known existed.

"Downtown Phoenix is much nicer than a lot of people realize," he told me. He lived in one of the revitalized historic neighborhoods, in an old Craftsman bungalow that he'd spent the last few years renovating.

I was surprised that there was any dwelling in the Valley that could be called "old." From my observation, anything older than a quarter-century was knocked down to make way for more white stucco condos or another strip mall with a Ross superstore, Best Buy and a Black-Eyed Pea restaurant, all surrounded by an ocean of parking.

We compared growing up in Phoenix in the 1970s, when everything was clean and the city was smaller, to growing up in Philly during the same period, when the city was fighting the twin urban blights of poverty and decay.

I emailed Alison when I got back to the office: He's really nice and interesting, but nothing major to report yet.

Either he is a caffeine addict, or he was itching to see me, too.

Until that week, I never realized the entertainment value of courting someone who works in the same building. I found myself repeatedly venturing to the coke machine across from the elevator. Several times, he happened to need to slake his thirst at exactly the same moment. Either he is a caffeine addict, or he was itching to see me, too.

Finally, at the third rendezvous, he smiled conspiratorially. "Maybe I'll stop buying Dr Peppers and just start leaving notes in your locker."

My blush of infatuation was tempered with my recollection of a promise I'd made to my sister Beth: After it took me four months to see that Harris wasn't the most giving puppy in the litter, I'd committed to pay more attention before I fell for someone.

After all, if the point of dating is to find out whether this is "someone to build a life with," I had to pay attention to what kind of person he was -- in addition to whether I liked being around him (I definitely did).

After two more weekday lunches, we made the big move to an "evening date" on Saturday night. We went to a movie and then to a coffeehouse with live music. I commented that this was much more my milieu than the place in which we'd first met, where I'd been dragged against my will.

The point of dating is to finding out whether this is someone to build a life with.

I didn't know what to say.

"Some guys are interested when women are haughty and distant. I liked that you seemed real and genuine, at least from a distance," he continued. "So when I saw you, I figured it was worth trying to strike up a conversation. I was surprised that you were rude and snobby after all. But then my attitude changed the night your tire was flat. Anyway, my secretary is the one who convinced me to ask you out. She told me how you pumped her for information about me."

"Oh, no! She spilled it?"

"Sang like a canary."

There was a moment of slightly uncomfortable revelation, that electricity that happens when people let down their guards and are real with one another. I felt suddenly shy.

"At the very least," he said, "I'm glad that my initial impression was right. And I'm glad that we're becoming friends."

"Friends?" I said, taken aback.

"Well, I hope more than friends," he said quickly. "But I think becoming friends is the most important part of being more than that. And I hope we're becoming more than that."

Whew. Rick Miller is nothing if not honest, I thought. Honest, emotionally available and really nice. Since my guard was already down, I decided to tell him that.

"Rick, I want you to know that I admire how open and honest you are," I said, self-consciously. "I decided recently that 'nice' is a priority for me. And you are really nice."

I thought nice was a killer for a guy.

"Uh-oh!" he said. "I thought 'nice' was a killer for a guy."

"Not for me," I laughed. "Nice is good. Very good."

"Well, I guess what they say about altar boys is true," he said, smiling.


"About altar boys... that they turn out to be nice men," he said. "And I was a Boy Scout, too."

Altar boy?? I knew this was too good to be true. This "nice Jewish boy" is nice, and he's a boy... but he's not Jewish!

November 11, 2000

Article 26 of 66 in the series Jessica's Journal

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 5

(5) Benjamin Bensimon, November 25, 2000 12:00 AM

While this piece gets at a key Jewish dating issue, ie. the importance of focusing on a prospective partner's character, the 'revelation' that Rick isn't Jewish made me squirm; way too Hollywood. In reality, someone who appeared to be so bothered by Rick's alter boy/Boy Scout past would certainly have made it a priority to find out if Rick was Jewish while she was already 'pumping the secretary for information'.

(4) Anonymous, November 23, 2000 12:00 AM

too bad he's not jewish

It's too bad he's not jewish. The rate of intermarriage is over 50%. Hopfully, you'll come to your senses before its too late. I'm a convert but in Delaware, but can't get dates with Jewish girls. Its a shame, but that's the way it is...

(3) Anonymous, November 15, 2000 12:00 AM

what a cute story!

Dear Jessica,

That has got to be about the most gratifying story that I have read the long time. Firstly, your writing style is completely engaging - intelligent, sensitive and funny. It says a great deal about you. Rick Miller is a man's man - he can change a tire and he can renovate a house. But there is a corporate-guy aspect about him as well so he's definitely not blue-collar. The little coke machine vignette- how well you describe the subtle yet tantalizing little mind games of the early stages of courtship. 0h, that horrible jerk Harris. By his actions, he's taught you to be so guarded, the situation that makes it harder for us genuinely nice guys. "Nice Guys" - I recently read an interview with a woman in her mid-20s was quoted as saying "There is a very thin line between a guy's being sensitive a guy's being a wimp". I think that statement holds a lot of truth for a lot of women but since you've already established that Rick's a "macho" kind of guy - a man who knows how to work with his hands - it's OK. "Too good to be true" - yes indeed, because, unfortunately, nice guys usually finish last. It's always a conflict between the body and the spirit. Jessica, you were attracted to Rick because of his good looks "i.e. symmetrical face, height, etc." the qualities which you equate (with the force of eons of evolution - in your feminine subconscious mind) with the ability to produce healthy offspring, ensuring the passage of your DNA to the next generation. He can change a tire and renovate a house so clearly he's good with tools - just what a cavewoman needs - yes, build that fire and provide shelter - so first you can survive yourself and then replicate. Jessica, isn't your ideal man somewhere between an ape and an angel? You are the producer of a TV fashion program - so the focus of your career is basically trying to make people attractive to the opposite sex, isn't it? So, where's the spiritual side of you? What about the homely, nice guys who don't work with their hands? Jessica, to my sensitive ears you've mixed a lot of fact from your real-life, an effective technique which every good writer cultivates, with a lot of fiction from your libidonous ego-driven core. Well, you certainly got the ending right. Your story is a far cry from the reality of the dating and mating game. It's too good to be true.

(2) , November 13, 2000 12:00 AM

I saw this coming a mile a way. What was she thinking? She lives in ARIZONA? I hope to follow this closely, because I am hopeing that her resolution to this will make for an excellent opening to a class for my middle and high schoolers!

(1) Yoni Gershon, November 13, 2000 12:00 AM

To "Jessica"

You write very well about the dating "game"!

If you;re ever in NYC there's an awesome class going on which boosts people out of the dating game and into marriage. Deep Jewish insights into love, dating and relationships, 313 W 83rd street, Wednesday evenings by Rabbi Dovid Clyman

I (Yoni Gershon) also give a class Wednesday nights on Jewish Spirituality.
I cover some of the deeper material on male/female issues as it relates to the soul etc.

Hope to see you there!


Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment