click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Jessica #47 - Carbon Monoxide Fashion

Jessica #47 - Carbon Monoxide Fashion

Jessica's world is beginning to cave in. Will Marc be there to save her?


Well, my office staff approves of Marc.

He arrived after a meeting he had downtown, and the secretary, our new segment editor, and Ian, my assistant producer, had all given me some sort of surreptitious thumbs-up as we walked through the small office.

I was a little embarrassed by their fussing -- and a bit annoyed at Marc, for causing the fuss.

"Maaarc," I had whined once I got him away from their prying eyes into my office, "did you have to make it so obvious ?"

After a few more weeks of dating, I was still ambivalent toward him. When I was with him, I had fun, but something ineffable just hadn't yet clicked.

Marc seemed a bit hurt by my whine but was polite nonetheless. "I should apologize anyway," he said, "for dropping in on you with so little notice in the middle of the day. "

"No, no..." I said, "I am glad you came -- you can come with me to the state capitol."

He looked at me blankly.

"To the Israel solidarity rally..." I reminded.

I had told him about it, but he'd apparently forgotten. I was doubly glad he came, though, because he'd interrupted what was about to become a very unpleasant meeting. I had (perhaps impulsively) nixed a segment of an upcoming show that Ian had put together.

It was based on a fashion ad campaign that features glassy-eyed women.

From the time I first saw it a year or two ago, it stirred something in me. It was more than just heroin chic. These women looked dead. And they were selling shoes.

We rarely do shoots of our own, but Ian had been hungry to get creative, so I'd let him. And now I saw that he'd basically reproduced the ad's look for a series on Back to School fashions!

These women looked dead. And they were selling shoes.

Ian had emaciated 12-year-olds made up like corpses wearing clothes that some fashion editor in New York had decided were the new Ivy League look.

"I am not exactly sure what you're objecting to," Ian sputtered when my disgust became evident. "These are the clothes..."

I nodded, trying to collect my thoughts. What was horrifying me? The clothes themselves? The styling? Or the fact that the segment looked like it had been filmed in a room filled with carbon monoxide?

"Ian, those girls look dead," I said simply.

"Well, of course they do. That's the whole point!" he said emphatically, remarking on the bold styling and reiterating his praise of the "beauty of rawness."

I remembered the first ad in what I considered to be the series, one from years ago. In it, a woman has apparently fallen down the steps, and lies backwards, staring vacantly at the sky.

How did she fall down the steps, you are forced to wonder? Maybe she was pushed?

I am about to send this out to an audience of teenaged girls.

These are violent images, I thought, and this is what is selling couture dresses. This is what is packaged as "beauty." And I am about to send it out to an audience of several hundred thousand -- most of them teenage girls.

Ian didn't seem ready to believe that I was going to scrap the series, and I wasn't sure I could either. He was starting to get upset when Marc wandered in and headed off Ian's incipient hissy fit.

Back in my office, I showed Marc some stills. He shuffled through them aimlessly.

"Isn't it disgusting?" I sighed, inexplicably feeling sad. "Whatever happened to fresh-faced teens? A little tweed? Wind-kissed cheeks?"

"Well, for whatever it's worth," he said, "I don't find them particularly attractive."

I laughed. I gathered my things, went and told Ian that I would make a decision about the segments next week, and left with Marc. We drove through the skanky neighborhoods toward the capitol. I was surprised to see that a group of Palestinian students from Arizona State had come to counter-protest at the Israel rally.

I was particularly captivated by a woman who'd just returned from visiting her daughter in Israel.

"We are all under attack," the perky little woman had cried into the microphone, "An attack on Tel Aviv is an attack on all of us -- and it's up to us to fight back!"

She gave a list of organizations to support and people to write to and ended her speech with a fiery, "Am Yisrael Chai!"

You don't really think one person can make a difference, do you?

Marc rolled his eyes when I started clapping enthusiastically.

"A little melodramatic, don't you think?" he asked.

"No," I said. "Theatrical maybe, but what's melodramatic?"

"Oh c'mon," he rejoined with a half-grin, "you don't really think any of the stuff she said really matters?"

We ended up sitting on the lawn in front of the state house, the Palestinians chanting behind us, discussing whether one person could really make a difference.

"Marc," I said, speaking as soon as the thought came into my head, "Do you really think that one person can't make a difference? Or maybe you just don't care..."

"Not really," he shrugged. "I have enough things I need to worry about in my own life. I just don't think one person makes so much of a difference that it's worth it."

"But what about doing something if only because you couldn't live with yourself if you didn't?"

"Look," he said, "I can secure funding for my company's new projects... I can't save Israel."

Another speaker began, cutting off the conversation.

I listened with one ear, while continuing to think about our conversation.

"It's like you're content with things the way they are," I told Marc later, trying to figure out why his words bothered me so much.

"What, you want me to be the Che Guevara of the Jews?" he laughed.

I shook my head. It wasn't an issue of political activism -- it was a matter of reaching beyond one's comfort level. Of striving for something great, something profound, meaningful, umm... transcendent?

He leaned back in the grass and smirked. "This discussion is a bit too heavy for me right now."

What, you want me to be the Che Guevara of the Jews?

On Sunday, Ellen called and to ask how it was going with Marc and whether I'd found a synonym for "misogynist" yet.

"Misandry," I'd discovered from a few little birds. On the former, I just wasn't sure.

It was funny, she said, she'd been dating her new guy for months longer than Marc and I had been, but it seemed like we knew each other so much better. I told her about Coach Rina and her targeted conversations.

"I guess she's right. You can hang out forever without really getting past the superficial," Ellen said. "You're keeping each other company and passing the time, but it's not doing anything to solve the real loneliness you feel or to move forward in your life."

Moving forward, I realized, means you have to take risks. You have to know what you ultimately want out of life and be fearless about expressing it.

You have to know what you want and be fearless about expressing it.

You also have to be ready follow up on it – meaning that you have to be willing to put yourself on the line and do something about it. And, if you're focused on moving your life forward, you have to see the fruitlessness of remaining in a relationship with someone who doesn't share those same ultimate goals -- no matter how much you like them.

The first step, Ellen opined, is achieving real clarity about what your own needs and goals are.

The next morning at work, I was preoccupied with these thoughts, but snapped into reality when I opened an e-mail from the publisher's assistant in New York congratulating me on the brilliant Back to School segment.

--What?! I looked closer. I hadn't yet told Ian that I'd decided not to run the vile thing he'd produced, but I certainly hadn't sent anything to New York.

But somehow, it had gotten there.

Then I realized -- Ian had gone over my head.

He was backing me into a corner.

My instincts raced. What should I do? Let it slide? Or put up a fight?

September 8, 2001

Article 47 of 66 in the series Jessica's Journal

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 7

(7) Anonymous, September 20, 2001 12:00 AM

yes put up a fight

put up a fight I say, with Ian and with Marc. Fight may be the wrong word, though I do believe that there is a way of saying things in a polite yet firm way. Ask your coach, Rina, is it, how to speak without sounding accusatory. She, if she is an experienced coach, will show you how.
Marc is someone who as you said so well, does not want to reach past his comfort zone. That is probably why the two of you did not click.
I say, Marc either needs to grow up a little and look past himself or take a walk. I do not know if immaturity is keeping Marc from supporting something like the speakers at an Israel rally, but, again, Rina, your coach may give you insight on that.

(6) Jessica Flanagan, September 12, 2001 12:00 AM

You SHOULD NOT let it slide. Stand up for what you KNOW is right!

I am a teenage girl myself, and I admit that we are easily influenced. I think that ad would be horrible to show to the public. It can subliminly put things into your head. Just by seeing it over and over again. In the world that we live in today, we do not need anymore reminders of death.

(5) Anonymous, September 10, 2001 12:00 AM

Who can make a difference?

it is interesting, in the same "episode" Jessica has the opportunity to make a difference (by nixing a sick fashion spread) and discovers that her current beau may not be motivated enough to try to make a difference in anyone's life but his own. How does that song go, ani v'atah neshaneh et haolam... you've got to believe, we can change this world around...

(4) Anonymous, September 10, 2001 12:00 AM

Dump Marc

Marc is a self-absorbed cretin who will never be the person you're looking for. Attending the Israel solidarity rally seemed important to you and his reaction to the rally demonstrated that he is a totally different person than you. Dump him now - there are plenty of good men out there.
-A Different Marc

(3) Anonymous, September 10, 2001 12:00 AM

kudos all around

Well,well,well,even Ellen wakes upto the fruitlessness and lack of true sattisfaction in eternal small talk. And the question remains-will Jessica ever get her act together enough to realize what's important to her and then go for it feircely? It's a repetitive event that she goes out with a guy,likes him enough to get to know him better and only then gets this sneakity feeling of-oh,THIS is important to me and the guy couldn't care less! Kudos to Ellen for her unexpected insights. And to Jessica for her unexplained desires towards trancendance in the form of being an active,caring part of Am Yisrael. I liked the explanation Jess gave about following up on what you really want in life and having a partner who won't stop you and who you won't stop. It was put well.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment