click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Commitment: A Four Letter Word

Commitment: A Four Letter Word

Fear of commitment is epidemic. But you need to face that fear and conquer it.

by

I have looked fear in the face... and then it turned and ran.

Come to think of it, actually, it looked a lot like my ex-boyfriend.

This is not an unusual experience. Unless you were married off at the ripe old age of 21, chances are you've encountered a dating partner who is terrified of commitment -- or you've discovered it in yourself.

Or both.

It shouldn't be surprising.

Our culture doesn't exactly encourage much relationshipial fealty.

There's a not-so-subtle cultural undercurrent that tells us that what is new (be it the latest-model Palm Pilot, sunglasses, or boyfriend) is better.

We're encouraged to want it all and, more saliently, to believe that "getting it all" is possible.

We tend to relate to one another in the cadences of sitcom humor, attaching nicknames to people we date as if they were recurring characters on "Seinfeld" and can be dispatched just as quickly, with no regrets (since they'll probably land their own sitcom or at least get a career bounce from being known as "the girl with the big hands").

We're subtly encouraged to think that we can find -- and deserve -- a guy with washboard abs -- who doesn't spend all his time in the gym; a woman with a fantastic, demanding career -- but of course we're her priority; or a man who dresses with perfect style and panache -- yet isn't the slightest bit vain. Along the way, no one bothers to mention that all of this is highly unlikely.

No one tells us that finding the perfect person is highly unlikely.

Plus, there's not much of a societal imperative to settle down anymore. And that lets us flit from relationship to relationship without much self-evaluation.

You can be in the throes of a wacko case of commitment phobia and not really even realize it for years.

But then all of a sudden you do.

IT FEELS REAL

Were you ever in a relationship and you suddenly feel as if the walls are closing in on you?

As with any phobia (fear of heights, for instance), your body may produce a physical reaction to an emotional response.

Your heart starts to beat fast. You feel panicky and anxious. Your stomach aches.

There is a very real sense of fear.

Your initial, Darwin-mandated response?

FLEE!

Run away from the thing -- the person -- causing that response.

And like a helpless chipmunk escaping a bobcat, you then feel sense of relief.

And you hold onto that relief to validate your –- totally rational, intellectual -- conclusion that terminating the relationship was the right thing to do.

There's only one problem: you're not a chipmunk.

SIT WITH YOUR FEAR

It's entirely possible that your chipmunk-bobcat union was, in fact, not right. But you can't possibly judge that when you're in the grips of a fight-or-flight instinct.

Your response came from anxiety.

Anxiety is an emotion that passes.

And you have to resign yourself to the fact that anxiety and other uncomfortable feelings are a part of any real relationship.

You are not a chipmunk and dating shouldn't be Darwinian.

Getting close to another person in a meaningful way is a scary thing. It means opening yourself up and making yourself vulnerable. It means making the space for the other person to open up to you, and making an effort to understand him or her.

It's not supposed to be "comfortable." It's supposed to be significant.

Once you reach the level where that meaningful connection is turning into commitment, it can be simply terrifying.

The fear can grip both partners at different times.

A friend of mine who knew she had commitment issues nearly ran out of a restaurant when a boyfriend first brought up commitment. He actually used the m-word -- something like "we need to decide if we are moving toward marriage."

She looked around in a panic, thinking, "Check, please!"

But she forced herself to stay in her chair. They had a long talk and she felt they came closer together.

It was a visceral reaction to how much was being given up without seeing what would be gained.

When he brought it up again a few weeks later, she pressed herself into her seat and had to concentrate on pacing her breaths to combat her racing heart.

It had nothing to do with how she felt about him.

It was a deeply visceral reaction to the notion of being pinned down, to how much can be given up, without seeing how much is to be gained.

Ironically, months later after the commitment had been initially made, the boyfriend fled.

HISTORY REPEATS ITSELF

My friend understood that most of her commitment issues were related to baggage she was carrying around from the past. So while they were dating, she worked on addressing those fears, and especially not allowing them to interfere with their relationship.

During her moments of panic, she stayed put and tried to figure out what she was feeling and what, specifically, was frightening her. She later sorted these feelings out with a trusted, older friend.

The same friend helped her sort through her feelings about her boyfriend: what qualities he had that were problems for her, and what qualities he had that she valued.

She understood that he couldn't meet every "want" she had, but decided that he met all of her "needs." She also understood that her fears about commitment weren't specific to him.

What you want and what you need aren't necessarily the same thing.

The boyfriend's approach was less seasoned.

He was emotionally present while they dated -- a really good guy at heart -- but some time after they committed to each other, suddenly decided that "something didn't feel right." Without much more of an explanation, he broke it off, declining to go with her to speak to someone about it.

It's entirely possible that they weren't meant for one another and that, in the end, he was right. But the fact that he wasn't willing to go talk to someone about their relationship suggests that his decision was fear-based.

SEEK GUIDANCE

My friend understood that she lacked the perspective to sort through the complicated emotions that go along with relationships -- particularly when commitment issues are involved.

Be wise about who you seek to help you.

Don't go consulting your cubicle mate who thinks "Sex and the City" is a source of meaningful wisdom. Seek help and guidance -- preferably before panic sets in -- from a rabbi, counselor or someone else reasonably sagacious.

Be aware that some of the best-intentioned friends often can be more harm than help. They want the very best for you -- but may be caught themselves in the 100-percent-or-nothing bracket.

Some friends of mine have never understood how one friend "settled." The guy she picked is not a career superstar, nor the life of the party. He's just a caring, decent man who loves her very much. They thought she should hold out for someone better: flashier, wittier, wealthier... closer to perfection.

Of course, she's happily paired off... and the rest of us are still looking.

COMMITMENT MEANS ACCEPTANCE

No, no one is advocating that we "settle."

But if that is "anything less than perfect," guess what? We're going to have to settle.

We all date with heads full of fantasies, with edited memories of past loves by which we measure the current one. We're looking for the perfect one: with Fred's sense of humor, Ted's sensitivity, Ed's earning power, and Ned's perfect physique.

(But without Fred's need to be the center of attention, Ted's touchiness, Ed's disappearing acts, or Ned's self-absorption.)

Maturity means forming a long-lasting bond with the unique and very human and imperfect person you've chosen.

Maturity means forming a long-lasting bond with the unique and very human and imperfect person you've chosen. It means focusing on the long-term, not the short-term foibles that seem larger and larger as you get more and more scared.

Beware the Pimple Principle. You know how sometimes you don't even notice a blemish on someone's face, but then once pointed out, it's all you see?

When you're not scared about a relationship, you don't even notice the tiny bit of peach fuzz on your girlfriend's upper lip. When you are, she starts to look like the Motorcycle Guy from the Village People.

When you're relating normally, your boyfriend's tendency to tell silly jokes is endearing. When you're in flee mode, it's a waving red flag of driphood. And why oh why, would you stay with a drip?

DEVELOP YOUR AGENDA

My friend who conquered her fear of commitment was able to sort through the real fear issues from those that were unimportant or anxiety-driven. She knew why she was dating and knew what she wanted in a partner.

Responsible, thoughtful daters figure out what they want and what they need (they're not necessarily the same thing). And if they start feeling panicky, they go talk to someone to sort it through.

Vague generalities are warning signs. "Something isn't right" is not a good reason to end a relationship. "I don't think he would be a good father" is. "Something is missing" isn't. "Our long-term goals are not incompatible" is.

The fear-conquering friend knows now that, however things ended with the fearful beau, she has the sense of achievement and pride that comes with conquering the obstacle of her own fear.

Along with all the other downers when we give in to fear-inspired flight, is what happens to the other person. My friend triumphed over panic, but the good-at-heart boyfriend broke her heart.

That's a heavy price to pay because you're afraid to stare down fear.

Published: September 29, 2001


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 27

(26) Travis, April 3, 2008 1:06 AM

Thank you so much!

I had the feeling that I was afraid of commitment. I was felt like I should look for someone else or I shouldn't be with this person and I started realizing I am. Im afraid of commitment. I want to thank you because your article has made me feel so much better. Ive realized that the girl Im with is all that I need and more. Thank you!

(25) Michelle, February 12, 2008 9:55 AM

good point about sitting with fear

i am a complete commitment phobe about all kinds of things--men, jobs, where to live....how to use a free i-tunes card...name it! anyway, i find that your advice to just sit with the fear rather than running out the door is actually wonderful and empowering advice. no matter what you decide to do about the relationship, job, etc, you still learn something about yourself!

(24) Anonymous, January 14, 2008 5:02 PM

i just found out last night that my boyfriend is scared of commitment

I recently discovered that my boyfriend is scared of commitment. i always heard about this happening to other people,but never would i imagine this would happen to the man i have fallen deeply in love with. I am in a very uncomfortable situation right now because i dont know what to do.I mean does he want to go out and date other woman?

(23) Anonymous, November 7, 2007 12:37 PM

I never thought I'd be this type

This article really made sense to me. It touched on the negative feelings I've harbored about my current partner. Growing up all I ever wanted was the white picket fence love story, now that I may be able to have that I am freaked out. "She's has a kid, She's doesn't have the BEST career, and her jokes sometimes seem like she's trying too hard" when in all actuality she treats me the way I deserve to be, she's sweet, kind, respectful and loves me more than anyone ever has.

I remember thinking this all to DEATH one night and waking up feeling panicked. I called my best friend and she gave me really good advice and calmed me down.

I don't know if this has happened to anyone else but I've always remembered being like this. I feel in love with the unattainable and discarded the ones who really cared. I always pick them apart and only see the negative. With the unattainable, I glorify even though deep down I know they are assholes.

Very interesting. At least I now know what's wrong with me...haha

Anonymous, September 25, 2012 9:12 PM

Did I write this?

Boy can I relate. If you are wondering if you are along, you absolutely are not. I have just met someone amazing who wasn't what I thought "my type" would be. Turns out that the ones I have been going after are unattainable, abusive train wrecks of women. I have always discarded the good ones, and I have regretted it every single time. I am doing my best to not run, and to stay with the feelings. My current girlfriend is unbelievable, and I really want this to work. I will be damned if I will let my irrational fears derail the things that I want in life!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!