click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Tzav
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

This Guy Is Not For Me

This Guy Is Not For Me

Q&A after a bad date.


Dear Aleeza,

Last night I went out with a guy who is not for me. He is too talkative, lacked warmth and we didn’t have much in common. Overall I can tell he is a good and pleasant person, but he isn’t what I’m looking for. I told him that he isn’t a match for me. He texted me later asking what he could do better in the future. He’s a growth-oriented person and wants to know if there is anything in particular he needs to work on. Here are my questions:

  1. Is it appropriate for me to be honest and tell him why he isn’t for me? If yes, how should I reply?
  2. What are things people should try to improve on after having a series of unsuccessful dates and what things should be left alone?
  3. Should I ask him if there is anything I can improve on? I wonder if it’s only fair to let him give me feedback too.


Not for me

Dear Not for me,

I like that you articulated why he isn’t for you. You gave a few specific reasons that identify differences between the two of you that make you incompatible. One of the most important things you said was that you don’t have much in common. It sounds like you aren’t similar, yet you aren’t opposites either. You are just two different, good people who ended up on a date. While it’s nice to date a good person, it’s wise not to continue dating a good person with whom you don’t share a baseline of commonalities.

You asked three great questions. Let’s talk about them one at a time.

Q: Is it appropriate for me to be honest and tell him why he isn’t for me? I don’t mind that he asked, I just want to know if and how I should reply.

A: Let’s clarify. He asked if there was anything he could do better in the future when on a date. Telling him why he isn’t for you is specific to you, not him. He is asking a question relative to him.

Was there a flaw in his dating technique? You mentioned that he is a good guy and a pleasant person but just isn’t for you. Off the bat I’d say it’s not his technique that you aren’t drawn to; it’s his personality in addition to a lack of things in common that was not for you, not his character traits or social graces.

If you do want to share something, how you say it is crucial. After mentioning that it was nothing he did so he is aware that it’s not an inherent flaw but simply an incompatibility, you can share what you are looking for and why you honestly said no. Letting him know that you can see that you are both good people, just not compatible, confirms he has much to offer to a date.

As for your other reasons, you can share that you are looking for someone who you share more common interests and life goals. It’s always good to sandwich information that isn’t so nice to hear with pleasant comments. So start off by saying you two are good people, just not compatible. Move on to the specifics of why and end with a reminder that although you two weren’t the right fit you know he’s a good guy. Giving over information in this way isn’t only good for him to hear -- it’s the right way to develop good habits of speech.

Q: What are things people should try to improve on after having a series of unsuccessful dates and what things should be left alone?

A: The number one thing to improve is who you choose to date. I’m of the philosophy that we are all works in progress. Over the course of time people grow and change, both naturally and with great effort. If there is one thing you can count on, it’s that you won’t be the same person 10 years from now. If you personally see a major flaw or several people you know and trust tell you there is something big you need to work on, work on it. If you’ve had a series of unsuccessful dates, I’d prefer you look at who you are choosing to date first and then afterwards see if you need to make an improvement. See if you are choosing the right type of person to match who you are today. If you are dating people who don’t match who you are today, it doesn't matter in what ways and how much you improve -- you still won't match.

Q: Should I ask him if there is anything I can improve on? I wonder if it’s only fair to let him give me feedback too.

Do you really want to hear his suggestions? Do you trust his advice? If you think you will value his input, then it may be worth asking. However, you risk dragging on a post-date conversation which may not be healthy. Sometimes it’s best to be short, sweet and cut contact with dates that didn’t work out. This is not a matter of being fair.

May your inner wisdom guide you and may you have the right words at the right time.

Dear readers, I'd love to hear your opinion. Has this ever happened to you? How would you reply if you received a question like this?

January 10, 2015

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 16

(11) glenda, January 29, 2015 4:52 PM

feedback from one date guy

I personally think you are a snob.
He is not for you???
It is rare that a guy after the first date wants feedback, and is willing to improve(?) on what you are finding fault with?
He is a 'tier nashua ' and perhaps has met other women like you, who have rejected him after the first date, and the nice guy that he is, is thinking this is his fault, and not who he has been fixed up with.
If you have a shred of humanity in you, please give this guy a second chance, or perhaps
you are doing him the greatest favor by not seeing him again.

(10) Gedalia, January 19, 2015 2:44 PM

Sometimes you need to give a bad date a second chance

Approximately,ten years ago our younger son,Eli, went out on a date that was a total flop. He and the girl he went out with were totally mismatched. Eli called the girl to tell her that as far as he is concerned there is no point in going out again.
His date had the courage, maturity and conviction to say
"I know our 1st date went badly, but I see a potential here. Let's try it one more time."
Eli showed the flexibility to go along with her suggestion.
The next date was a little better and the one after even better. They got engaged after dating for three months and B"H have been happily married for nearly 10 years. As a result, their maturity and flexibility they gave us 5 wonderful grandchildren.
Sometimes you need to give a bad date a second chance

Rickie, January 19, 2015 7:50 PM

try one more time

You should surely give it a second try, especially if you saw that he is a good person.

(9) noureddine, January 16, 2015 8:37 AM

fix the goal of the mariage

every body must ask himself why we marry The marriage is like project investment, sometime we win and sometime we field, few critters must exists to fulfill the project, among these critters which is very important for relationship and married couple, the faith if partner hold faith in his heart, sure he knows the rights and duties vis a vis his partner than all secret is here reading holly Quran you will find a way of life in it s vey important good luck for all the newly couple married

(8) Michy, January 15, 2015 7:52 PM

One more question

If he's a good guy, can you set him up with someone else? Maybe he's not for you but he's right for your friend, coworker, or neighbor. You may eventually find your match this way!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment