click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Breaking Negative Cycles in Marriage

Breaking Negative Cycles in Marriage

Don’t let the past rule your response to the present.

by

Arguments occur in every marriage and quite often reflect a deeper discord of underlying issues. The cause of conflict may be simple. For example, Rick leaves his socks on the floor even though Sara repeatedly asks him not to. But a bigger piece of the puzzle is the meaning Sara gives to what just happened. This is known as the 90/10 principle: 10% of the problem is in the here and now, while 90% is based on past associations and experiences. Those socks are a trigger point.

Take these two examples:

10% of the problem is in the here and now, while 90% is based on past associations and experiences.

Jake is looking at his cellphone while Rachel is talking to him and she gets upset, angry and withdraws. Rachel’s sharp, critical comments to Jake make him feel emasculated and disempowered, so he stays at work later. Although many women feel irritated when their husband’s attention is elsewhere, for Rachel it is particularly painful because her mother was emotionally cut off and not available to listen to her. Jake is deeply affected by Rachel’s criticism because his mother was controlling and domineering.

Allie doesn’t follow through on practical stuff which she promised to do, and this upsets Steve. He feels let down and alone, and becomes distant and sighs heavily. This causes Allie to feel resentful and despondent. Steve’s father was kind but unreliable; Allie’s behavior makes Steve feel insecure and anxious. She comes from a family where emotions were not clearly expressed, so Steve’s sighing is threatening to her. Allie and Steve’s responses to each other are amplified by their previous relationship experiences.

Every relationship has its negative cycles and sore points where partners hurt each other. In these examples and with so many couples I’ve worked with, the parallels between current difficulties and past dynamics are remarkably apparent.

What is behind this dynamic? Why don’t we choose a more effective, updated response?

According to Imago Relationship theory, we unconsciously choose the same type of relationship challenge, firstly because it feels familiar, but also because we actually seek to work through the original problem. We can only do this by being in the difficulty again and finding our way out of it, by transforming the hurting relationship into a healing one.

So how do we break out of the negative cycle? Here are some ideas, at the risk of over-simplifying.

Try to identify or become conscious of your own sensitivity and where it comes from. In this way you will take responsibility for your part of the problem and not put it all on your partner, even though the difficulty exists in the relationship also.

Look at how your behavior or response fuels the negative cycle.

See the cycle as having its own life story. This will reduce the blame.

Try moving away from the ‘who started it’ cycle. It really doesn’t matter and generally it’s a chicken/egg story.

Try seeing the problem in less global or all-or-nothing terms.

Try discussing the issue in a less emotional, accusatory way. Try to gain some perspective on the problem, including your own part in it instead of attacking your partner.

Keep in mind that your spouse has his or her own emotional reality which is also valid, even if it is different to yours.

You may not reach complete agreement but you can attempt to be genuinely interested in your partner’s experience.

Hold onto your own truth even if your partner tries to invalidate it.

Instead of trying to be right, try to share, listen, and understand. View yourself as two parts of a whole which can complement and work together rather than as one having to be valid and true.

Sometimes professional help is needed to help identify the negative cycle and untangle the knots of which actions, thoughts and words triggered off which responses. This can be an intricate, fascinating and potentially extremely rewarding and growing experience!

May we merit to constantly grow in understanding ourselves and our partners and create a closer relationship.

August 27, 2016

Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 4

(3) Marny CA, September 3, 2016 10:16 AM

"3 Rules for a Happy Marriage"

My husband and I made up these 3 Rules by which we lived our lives together, daily.

Although marriage is a commitment, we found it easier to make the commitment to our rules.

1. When having an argument or a heated discussion, the person who is right must apologize immediately.

2. We must make each other laugh at least once a day.

3. Remember: Relationships are like living in southern California. If you find a fault, don't stand on it.

There are stories about each ... but I won't go into those here.

(2) Reuven Frank, September 1, 2016 10:55 AM

Communication, Communication, Communication

Talk it out! Why do we have to be stuck in ANY cycle.
To me, a marriage is a journey together made with course corrections along the way.
How do the two of you know that it's time to make a "course correction"?
You talk about it.
I always manage to get into the conversation, as early as possible in the relationship that, just like realtors say,
"Location, location, location"
so, too is a marriage.
The three most important things are:
"Communication, Communication, Communication".
If you keep the lines of communication open, and your relationship loving and open with trust, and
each of you KNOWS that you are
ON THE SAME SIDE
then anything can be discussed, and
the course corrections made all the time
in love and growth and in Oneness.

Best wishes for a happy, loving, communicative relationship
in growth and in God--Amen.

(1) Mordechai Shuali, August 28, 2016 11:38 AM

On the Mark, yet missed the target

Wonderfully written. Great points. Excellent advice. Focused guidance. The only issue with the article is the following. In it the author writes, "According to Imago Relationship theory, we unconsciously choose the same type of relationship challenge, firstly because it feels familiar, but also because we actually seek to work through the original problem. We can only do this by being in the difficulty again and finding our way out of it, by transforming the hurting relationship into a healing one." We rarely, if ever "choose" the relationship or set of circumstances. All (certainly most) of the situations we find ourselves in, the challenges we face, while undoubtedly in order to test us to offer us the opportunity to change, to grow, are not our choices, but rather HaShem, in His ultimate kindness, orchestrating things for our ultimate benefit. Imago survey aside, we need to seize the moment and grow. Thank you for helping us all see how that can happen.

Jenny Shain, September 14, 2016 5:19 PM

Yes

Thankyou, I agree it certainly is Hashem who chooses our partner, the incredible thing I have seen is how often this 'choice' connects to previous struggles in our earlier relationships. Image theory says it's our unconscious choice...but I agree with you!

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub