click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Back to School Challenges
Mom with a View

Back to School Challenges

It's not only the kids who have a hard time. Anyone who carpools will totally relate.


Aah! Back to school. Images of rosy-cheeked children bursting with enthusiasm, freshly minted notebooks and pencils, smiling mothers holding lunches packed with homemade specialties…

No wait; that was a novel I was reading!

Back to school is filled with moments of excitement and moments of dread – for both parents and children.

There is the thrill of seeing your friends again – and the pain of discovering that some of them have been switched to another class.

There is the excitement of learning subjects – and the distress of not getting the teacher you wanted. There is homework and responsibility and that ravishing after-school hunger.

Parents have equally mixed emotions and experiences. It is moving to watch your child progress through the educational hierarchy. And that is concurrent with anxiety and concern about their social and academic competence. Will they make friends? (Most probably yes). Will they fight with their friends? (Most probably yes). Will they remember to do their homework? (Sometimes) Will they do well on the test? (They would have but the teacher put in questions that they never studied!)

And there are new pressures – early rising and the rush to get ready, lunches (worthy of a loud groan and an article of their own), nights to devoted to homework in subjects we thought we’d long left behind, and, for those of us who don’t live within walking distance of the school and whose state doesn’t have the funds for buses, there’s carpool.

I see some of you quaking in fear and acknowledgment.

Carpool is, of course, the most efficient way to transport children back and forth to school. It saves everyone time and both the children and adults may even make new friends in the process.

But, unfortunately, the opposite is also true and it isn’t always friendships that result!

Carpool poses two inherent challenges – other people’s children and other people themselves!

To begin with, not everyone operates with the same time sensibilities. For a child that moves slowly, the early honking of the horn may provoke anxiety, along with the risk of arriving at school without a crucial piece of homework or clothing. For the family that errs on the side of strict punctuality, waiting for the more laidback carpool driver to arrive may be extremely frustrating and aggravate concerns (rational or otherwise) about late notes and other assorted penalties.

Additionally, not everyone comes straight home, or directly to the car. Some kids linger, chatting with their friends, as you sit drumming your fingers on the steering wheel and grumbling about lax parenting. Some drivers (most likely the ones with the aforementioned lingering kids) stop and do errands on the way home as you rush back and forth to the window worrying about your child’s late arrival and anticipating their black mood.

That’s just for starters! The many challenges in the carpool situation range from the trivial – jealousy of what the other family is having for dinner – to the more serious – have you ever driven home a car filled with sweaty, tired adolescent boys? In the winter when you can’t open the windows? I’ll say no more.

We want to be there for our friends and neighbors. But when does it cross a line?

But for me the most frustrating piece of all is something alluded to in a recent Wall Street Journal piece. The author, Jeffrey Zaslow, interviewed many parents who were unemployed, worked from home or were stay-at-home parents. Most of them were kind-hearted people who were happy to help out their neighbors whose jobs took them away from home. They didn’t mind being asked to drive the odd extra carpool and to do some babysitting in an unusual emergency situation. But they began to feel taken advantage of. They began to feel the assumption was that if you’re home, you’re available. Their time and occupations seemed to have no value. This puts many of us in a real dilemma. We are a people of chesed, doing kindness. We want to help out. We want to be there for our friends, our neighbors, our community. But when does it cross a line? When is not a special favor but just an assumption?

Why are there some parents who can never drive – not to school, not after school to work on a special project, not for school programs or school trips – because they are too busy “working”? And why do they expect (frequently without even asking) that the other parents will pick up the slack?

I try to be a mensch (maybe you think I don’t sound like it!) I certainly take other children that need rides even if they have uncooperative parents because why should their kids suffer? But I’m confused that they don’t acknowledge their own responsibility. I’m puzzled by their lack of respect for other people’s time? I wonder why it never occurs to them to respond with a simple “Thank you”.

If you don’t drive carpool, you probably think I’m a grumpy curmudgeon. But if you do, you’re shaking head knowingly – and thinking of that one family that never takes their turn.

It bothers me that when I send my older daughter to pick up one of her siblings from a school event, half the neighborhood piles into the car even none of them thought to ask – or offer.

Naturally I will keep driving carpool – not just for school but so my children can be full participants in extracurricular activities or just spend time with their friends. But I would certainly appreciate it if some other parents stepped up to the plate.

I’m working on loving my fellow Jew. I admit I need to work harder. Maybe other parents could help me by not constantly putting my resolve to the test!

September 19, 2010

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 4

(4) SusanE, September 28, 2010 4:39 PM

Kids are Lazy

Emuna, My kids were 10 years apart, so I saw 2 generations of kids growing up spending a few hours a day sitting in a car. I am of the mind that Kids are Lazy. I've watched them being driven up to our HIGH school, these are 15 to 18 year olds. The line of autos might be 10 to 15 cars piled up in line in front of the school. The kids sit like lumps until the car is directly in front of the door. It stops and everyone gets out. Then the next car stops directly in front of the door and those kids Fumble out, and the kids in the car directly behind that one are still sitting like lumps till the car in front moves on. What's the matter with the kids getting out and walking 20 feet to the school door? They are like mindless robots who can't think ahead. The athletes and sports kids mostly drive to school cause they get parking permits for after school practice. I've often wondered why the track kids and the football players don't run or walk to school in the morning. Or would that make too much sense??? I didn't have to work while raising my kids, so I had the time and a car large enough to drive my own and other kids places that were too far to walk. It's the character of the child that determines whether they say a thank you. Some did and some never did. My husband and I used to walk down to the doughnut shop in the evenings and back home. About 1 mile round trip. Not a hardship. Every child should walk to school if it's only a mile or so. They walk that far at the mall. They sit outside for 3 hours in the rain and snow at football games. No time to walk?.... get up a half hour earlier in the morning. 5,280 feet is not a hardship. Carpooling?.. never saw it work perfectly for everyone involved.. Can you think of a solution?

(3) Another Rachel, September 27, 2010 2:58 AM

You must be from New York!

Subways and buses are not always options "out of town"! Also, an "older daughter" is not necessarily a teen. Thanks for an accurate portrayal, Mrs. Braverman. I do, now, understand the non-carpoolers. With my first and second daughter I was known as the bus driver - volunteer, that is. But my situation has changed and now I have switched sides and my next two daughters are ofter among those that hop along with others. Occasionally I do send my older daughter (not a teen) and she takes a vanfull of girls home. I hope to be back at it again very soon...

(2) lilian russak, September 22, 2010 6:42 AM


I am nodding in agreement while reading this article! So true! Can you please write the article about the school lunches????

(1) Rachel, September 21, 2010 7:25 PM

Carpool alternatives

Public transportation is an even more efficient solution for older children. My daughter took the subway and my son a public bus. Even better was when we lived in walking distance of the school, but then the school moved to a new facility further away. I'm kind of shocked that when you send your older daughter to pick up a sibling, other kids get driven home too. In many places, teen drivers are not permitted to transport other children except for siblings -- and it's a good rule even if it's not the law. The best would be if every state provided free transportation to and from private as well as public schools -- this is New York's policy (and is constitutional, just like providing sanitation and police services to private schools is constitutional.) Alas, in the throes of recession, I don't think we'll be able to get this when states are struggling with obligations they already have....

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment