click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Littering the Holy Land
Mom with a View

Littering the Holy Land

Thank God, the streets of Jerusalem are alive once again. There is bustle and energy, hope and joy. And sadly, lots of garbage.


When people want to make fun of California, they like to joke that there is an 11th commandment here: Do not litter. While there are certainly many aspects of life in this state not to be taken too seriously, I'm unsure why not littering is the target.

I would think that, in line with the responsibility to tend to the earth the Almighty gave us, is an imperative to keep it clean, to let its beauty shine through.

I would also think that it is befitting the aura of dignity and constant consciousness that we want to convey not to throw our trash on the ground. Call me by any Freudian neuroses you like, I'm appalled when I witness someone litter. I can't fathom that action or attitude.

Given this perspective, and given the fact that Californians are, in general, careful not to litter, I was painfully stunned on a recent trip to Israel to witness all the garbage on the ground.

I don't know who does it (and can thereby avoid speaking gossip) but it is such a desecration of the Holy Land and, in particular, the holy city of Jerusalem.

My husband, a kinder soul than me, suggested that perhaps due to bomb scares there weren't public garbage cans. It was a noble effort but I spotted them on every street -- with the trash lying all around them.

I don't think it matters who the perpetrators are (you can use those Freudian names again, but it is a crime to see the streets of our holiest city covered in garbage); we have a responsibility to clean up.

Thank God, the streets of Jerusalem are once again alive with tourists (when in doubt, blame the maid). There is bustle and energy, hope and joy.

And garbage.

I don't want to point fingers. I would just like to solve the problem. Besides giving the land of Israel extra holiness, the Almighty also gave the land tremendous beauty, which is frequently obscured by soda cans, candy wrappers and the foil from Krembos. We need to clean it up.

If everyone took responsibility for their street, their sidewalk, their apartment entranceway, we could make a difference. We could create an environment where littering, while not having the stature of the Ten Commandments, is frowned upon. We could create an environment where our appreciation of the land, and of the privilege of living there, is demonstrated through simple concrete actions.

We could create an environment that highlights the physical and spiritual beauty of the land.

It's not feeding impoverished children or bringing peace to the Middle East, but it's a small action that says "I care," a small action that brightens our little worlds, a small action that affirms that this land is indeed my land.

December 9, 2006

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 13

(13) Anonymous, February 12, 2016 12:22 PM

so sad to see so much garbage

what is up with all that garbage in the Holy Land??? just returned from Israel and Wow! it was a very amazing and spiritual journey but broke my heart to see all the garbage :( we had a young man in our group that tried so hard to pick up the trash in the streets but he was fighting a battle there. I was so sad to see all of that trash.

(12) Anonymous, December 14, 2006 12:59 PM

Thnak you.

Thank you for bringing this up. I went once to EY and the most disappointing thing was the litter in the streets.
I thought "This is our beautiful land and why are people not tending to it".

(11) pinchasbaram, December 13, 2006 10:24 AM

Israelis' lack of midos

Israel needs LOTS of signs and longterm inculcations to change its (deserved) reputation of gross behavior and bad national character, like DO NOT LITTER, NO SMOKING, DO NOT HONK NEEDLESSLY, TORAH WITHOUT DERECH ERETZ IS A CHILUL HASHEM, ONLY CRUDE, UNCULTURED PEOPLE SAY MA PITOM AND LO ICHPAT LI ALL THE TIME-- DON'T BE ONE!..... and so forth. I hope your article waters a plant that grows, but I fear it's but one more drop of water which will evaporate in the desert... good wishes, Pinchas B. in Tzfat and Brookline, MA.

(10) LisaWeber, December 11, 2006 11:31 PM

Telling it like it is!

Just like everything in life: learning to appreciate nature/throwing away garbage/recycling paper,glass,plastics -all has to be learned and modelled in the home.We are blessed to live in a beautiful but limited world - provided by an Unlimited G-d. It is our sacred obligation to care for this'gift' we call our home - the earth.

(9) angelaGarcia, December 11, 2006 9:12 PM

I´m a jew who lives pretty far away from home (jerusalem). I live in south america, in Colombia and for Last pesaj, me and my mother had the opportunity to visit jerusalem, and my mom´s biggest dream was done : she took a broom and sweept out Meah Sharim. everybody there was amazed!!! I don´t understand how can we throw garbagge in Hashem´s home!!! maybe when we are not able to live there , we appreciate it more. Please get concious!!!!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment