Imbuing Real Self-Esteem
click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Imbuing Real Self-Esteem
Mom with a View

Imbuing Real Self-Esteem

Our kids are too smart to fall for counterfeit praise.

by

In an age where the self-esteem movement rewards "just showing up," teaching our children that self-respect comes through action and that everything we have is a gift from the Almighty is no easy task.

Don't we need to build our children up? Of course we do. But not falsely, not meaninglessly, not in a way that is unconnected to who they are and what they did. Our children are too smart to fall for that. In fact studies show it is more damaging to their ultimate success as adults to receive empty praise than it is to experience constant criticism. I am certainly not advocating the latter path. I'm just suggesting a little perspective.

Children know when they have worked hard. They know when they are working at or close to their potential. And they deserve recognition accordingly (even if it leads to a "C"). They are only confused and later learn a sense of entitlement when they are rewarded for doing nothing.

These young men and women initially experience entitlement, later cynicism and ultimately despair.

In an extreme example of this, the documentary "Born Rich" interviews some college students who are children of the extremely wealthy. They know that because their parents have given a large donation to the school, they need only attend one college event (not necessarily a class!) and they will be promoted to the next year. These young men and women initially experience entitlement, later cynicism and ultimately despair.

So the praise needs to be connected to real action, to significant effort on the part of the doer.

The other crucial element in raising children who have healthy egos but lack arrogance is to constantly remind them that everything comes from the Almighty. The Talmud suggests that doctors are particularly prone to receiving a hellish afterlife. That seems surprising. Aren't they engaged in humanitarian acts? The challenge for doctors is to remember that they are only the Almighty's messengers, that He has endowed them with their particular wisdom and skill and that He is the ultimate arbiter of life and death. The doctor's challenge is to see his work as a privilege and constantly ask the Almighty for His assistance.

This is obviously not a struggle solely for medical practitioners. While dealing with life and death issues may make us feel God-like, any time we accomplish and don't credit the Source we face the same danger. If we succeed in business, thank God. If dinner is delicious, thank God. If a child does well on an exam, thank God. While some balk at this robotic response, it is the most effective tool for taking everything back to the Almighty.

So how do we imbue this in our children? If our son comes home excited that he did well on a test, what could we say? "I'm so proud of you; you used that head the Almighty gave you exactly as He intended." If your daughter doesn't study, and her grades reflect that fact: "What a shame. The Almighty gave you the gift of a good mind and you're wasting it." Your child doesn't study and does well anyway: "How lucky you are that the Almighty made school work come so easily to you."

None of this will work, however, if we ourselves are modeling a completely different perspective. If our husbands brag about their deals, their stock tips and their business acumen. If we boast of our organizational skills and culinary abilities. We need to constantly reflect everything back to the Creator.

In teaching our children, we will be teaching ourselves as well. And in our recognition of the true Source of our good and in the thoughtful use of the gifts He has bestowed upon us, will real self-esteem take root.

Published: December 22, 2007


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 8

(8) Beverly Kurtin, December 29, 2007 9:50 PM

What do you mean I'm fired?

When these kids hit the real world they run into people like me. I demand excellence, honesty and showing up on time.

One young "lady" consistently came in whenever she jolly well felt like coming in, constantly toyed with her finger nails and then tried to pass her work onto others to do.

I took as much of her behavior as I could for two weeks, called her into my office and asked her why I shouldn't fire her.

"Well! How dare you ask me that question? I showed up, didn't I? My work gets done and besides, my daddy is the mayor of (a small insignificant town )."

Yes, you do show up eventually, get others to do your work and I could care less who your father is. Get your stuff together and get out; you're fired.

She actually could not believe SHE could get fired. She hadn't the foggiest idea of how things work in the real world.

Did I enjoy firing people? Nope. But do I enjoy having a thief on my payroll? NO. Anyone who comes to work and then doesn't do the work and LIES about it, is stealing as certainly as if she stuck her hand into the cash register.

(7) Jack, December 27, 2007 11:42 AM

Great Article but one comment on Rich Kids

This is a great article. One comment, I know some of the rich kids in the movie. The article and movie present a skewed view. The ones I know are hard working and searching for meaning. One has recently become more religious, and no, he does not go to one class - he graduated his Ivy school with honors and is now in an ivy grad school. He is now a modest, very nice person.

(6) Alan Kushner, December 26, 2007 9:55 AM

Don't limit praise just to children

TYhis article is terrific. But should not be limited just to children. We should, must, give our spouses the same praise that we should our kids. "Yes, dear, thank God for the skill He gave you to make such a lovely supper". "THank God that He gave you the capability to but just what we need for the week's groceries".
It will give them the feeling of accomplishment as well as acknowledge that all things come from the good Lord.

(5) Anonymous, December 26, 2007 8:06 AM

Teaching a Child Self Esteem is truly a challenge

in especially in wake of a divorce. The child feels blamed for the divorce, and whenever he/she feels that the trouble is their fault. I contantely have to tell my child that it is not their fault. That he is loved, and when my child sees people dregrading me, I have to build both of us up, not for arrogance but that we are worthy to serve Hashem's Mitzvot. One can follow the Pirkei Avot of being humble, but still feel that have merit in this society. And Merit should be measured by Middiot, and not the size of one's wallet, their looks, or educational level/ status. Just value a person's menstchkite. I know this is very naive of me to think we can act this way but one can have Emunah in Hashem that we are capable of this?

(4) esty g, December 25, 2007 6:43 PM

wow

i am so glad i read this because it's east to forget and the reminder is just what i needed.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!