The World Upside Down
click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




The World Upside Down
Mom with a View

The World Upside Down

Just when you thought it can't get more perverse, a PBS series suggests moral equivalence between the Nazis and the Allies.

by

When President Bush spoke in the Knesset recently, he reiterated the long-standing commitment of America to Israel. He linked the countries in goals and ideologies and suggested that in the fight against terror, Israel is not alone. The 300 million citizens of the United States stand with her. Israel and America have long shared similar world views.

On September 11, 2001, Israel and American had something new to share -- the pain and fear of terrorism.

It seems that it is not only the positive vision that unites us but some negative and tragic experiences as well. With the PBS' television presentation of "The War of the World" we now have another, also unwelcome, bond -- the sense of being in a world that has been turned upside down.

We have watched through the years as acts of terror are described as struggles for freedom, as nations have boycotted and condemned the victims instead of the perpetrators, as out and out lies have been promulgated as truths ,as pictures of mercilessly beaten yeshiva boys have been captioned with a description of Jews murdering Arabs.

We have listened and watched in amazement and horror. We have torn our hair out in frustration. From the British journalist who saw the "green line" years ago and blamed the Jews for grabbing the most fertile and lush part of the country (need I remind everyone it was green because we had worked the land?) to the fabrications of massacres in Jenin, it hasn't stopped.

Each lie makes an impact. Those who don't know better believe them. The cumulative effect is destructive and devastating. And our own psyche takes a blow with each new distortion.

Even the Russian liberation of Auschwitz is impugned.

With The War of the World, thinking Americans now have a taste of our pain (not something I wished on anyone). Here is a series that suggest moral equivalence (sound familiar?) between the Nazis and the Allies, that attempts to rob those who fought the good fight against Hitler of the nobility of their cause.

Even the Russian liberation of Auschwitz is impugned -- because of the murders committed by Stalin. If you are scratching your head in puzzlement, you are not alone.

Unfortunately these types of presentations have an impact. Younger generations who don't know better may be fooled. Their respect for their parents and grandparents, for their country, may be diminished.

As Jews we are, unfortunately, used to these calumnies; we have some ability to dismiss them. Although not without a price.

Americans aren't used to it yet. Our defenses aren't as developed. And it's scary to see this type of revisionism granted credibility. It bodes ill for the future.

How do we respond to a world gone mad? To a world where truths are turned on their heads and lies cloaked in intellectual argument?

The first line of defense is a rigorous probing to determine the truth (although few will take the time and trouble). This requires a healthy skepticism and a willingness to look beneath the surface and read between the lines.

The second line is to strengthen our ability to stand up for our convictions -- for our countries and our people -- immune to peer pressure and propaganda.

And the third is trust in the Almighty, belief in the coming of the Messiah. We look forward to a world where tearing out our hair will no longer be necessary, because the truth will be revealed and clear. We know that this confusion and fog is only temporary. We know that this is a world of illusion and that a better day is promised.

The days seem to be getting darker. Dishonesty, perversion of truth, outright lies, seem to dominate. There is no clarity; but there is hope. For the darker it gets, the sooner the day will come. I guess in some way I'm glad about this PBS special. In a world where the Allied victory in World War II can be morally impugned, where the valiant soldiers can now be vilified and condemned, where a distorted and false perspective can achieve prominence, then dawn must be on the horizon.

Published: July 5, 2008


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 20

(20) jacobo lashak-korogodsky, September 21, 2008 11:46 AM

the world upside down

yes is thrue , in some countries in latin america , the conservatives were the people wo figth for democracy and freedom , and the liberals are the dictars. the world upside down.

(19) Beverly Kurtin, July 14, 2008 7:20 PM

Palestinian Broadcasting System

That sums up my attitude towards PBS.

(18) Anonymous, July 10, 2008 3:37 PM

Nice diatribe- now can you tell us about the program?

One thing I look for from Jewish commentary is the interpretation of current events from a Jewish perspective. That doesn't just mean producing another "the goyim and liberals are being immoral and mean" diatribe. It means that events and facts will actually be presented, and THEN the interpretation will be provided. Sadly, Ms Braverman manages to avoid presenting a single fact. The only thing close is a statement that the PBS program "suggests" a moral equivalency between Auschwitz and what the Soviets did. Well, I'd kinda like to know- how does the rogram "suggest" that? or is Ms Braverman simply reading this in? I know that paranoids do occasionally, in fact, have enemies. But still! Don't we have enough of this kind of knee-jerk, relentless "they're all out to get us" school of propaganda coming out of the Jewish right-wing? It's time to raise the level of discourse here to at least occasionally well-reasoned, well-supported arguments. That used to be the Jewish way. If you don't believe me, try the Talmud some time.

(17) e-dub, July 9, 2008 10:02 PM

It all depends on where you start from

Moral relativity has its roots in one thing the desire to play G-d and from that perspective it's very easy to say Churchill, Roosevelt, Stalin, and Hitler are all the same. However, if you are a little more humble and try to look back in history and judge each from their own vantage point things become a lot clearer. The fire bombing of Dresden is as understandable as Sherman's march to the sea. Hitler wanted to street to street fighting to inflict the maximum damage to the allies. The allies had a moral duty to protect the lives of the men before protecting "innocent" civilians. I have no doubt a many good and nice people died in the fire bombing of Dresden many of whom If I ever had the chance to meet we could have been friends but the allies moral duty was not to protect the German people. Contrasting with Hitler, he plunged his people a war that nearly destroyed that killed 72 million people and the only thing Hitler had to do to avoid that was – nothing. Hitler's choice do nothing and save 72 million people. Churchill's choice live on knees or die on your feet.

If were going to start making moral comparison's lets compare to the choices that had to be made back then and a lot of this moral relativism smacks of blame the rape victim.

(16) Steve, July 9, 2008 3:10 PM

Did you see the whole program?

This is, to say the least, a gross oversimplification. Ferguson does not make a claim for moral equivalence. In fact, he specifically addresses the issue and explains why the allies and nazis were not morally equivalent. But you would have had to watch the entire episode (of 3) to know that.
Having seen the first 2 installments shown in the NY area, folks should know its quite the masterpiece of explaining the last 100years of history and conflict.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!