click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Bo
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Don’t Interfere and Defend Your Child
Mom with a View

Don’t Interfere and Defend Your Child

We will almost never be successful, and we may do more harm than good.

by

Some lessons are learned the hard way. One of them in my life was to stay out of the fights between my children and their friends. This was brought home to me when one of my daughters was in 5th grade, a grade that will forever be associated in my mind with a unique mean-spiritedness on the part of those pre-adolescent girls. My daughter became the third friend to a pair of prior best friends.

And suddenly she was coming home from school every day crying. When I probed, she informed me that one of the girls resented her relationship with her friend and made fun of her or was otherwise cruel to her every day. Despite prior warnings not to get involved, despite common sense telling me to stay out, I let my daughter’s pain govern my actions – to a point.

I decided to call the mother of the girl in question. But even though I was sure (!) that my daughter was in the right and hers was in the wrong, I did not approach her that way. Instead I adopted a more conciliatory tone. “I’m sure my daughter is playing a role in this,” I began, “but it’s painful to everyone and maybe we can work together to ameliorate the situation.” Or words to that effect. I had hoped that this opening would lead to a similarly even-handed response on the other mother’s part.

I could not have been more wrong.

Instead she began to yell at me. “My daughter has done nothing wrong; it’s all your daughter. Everything was fine until she insinuated her way into the friendship.” And on and on…

Needless to say, I was taken aback. I had reached out with calm and good will and was instead of the receiving end of a very personal attack. There was little left for me to say and the call ended soon after.

The girls soon repaired their relationship but there was tension between the mother and me for many years to come. I learned three things that day:

  1. Don’t interfere.
  2. The kids will get over it quickly.
  3. The mothers won’t.

I thought of this situation the other day when my friend’s married daughter was placed in a very awkward situation. It seems that she had told the after-school art teacher in the small town where she lives that her prices were a little out of reach for her and her friends and offered her the option of either lowering them or explained that, regretfully, they would have to look for another teacher. That night she got a call from the teacher’s mother (yes, the teacher’s mother!) yelling at her for taking business away from her daughter and adding that my friend’s daughter’s husband (did you follow that?) makes a lot of money so they could afford the rates.

My friend was furious on her daughter’s behalf. But one mother in the mix was already one too many so she stayed out. Ultimately the daughter apologized and I think she had words with her mother about the situation. In her desire to defend her daughter, not only had the mother potentially damaged her daughter’s relationship with other women in the community, she had probably damaged her own relationship with her daughter as well.

It’s not easy. If someone does something hurtful to one of our children, our first desire is to hurt them back (I’m just being honest here). Our second desire, and one we can more easily justify, is to call them up and either defend our child or tell them what we think of their behavior or, in the noblest of scenarios, try to make peace.

But we will almost never be successful. And we may frequently do more harm than good. As much as we are like mother lionesses, always ready to leap to the defense of our children, roaring loudly as we do so, it is not always the right strategy. In fact it frequently may not be.

So what’s a passionate, loving mother to do? Support our child to their face and teach them the skills to deal with situations like this on their own. It’s initially a lot less emotionally satisfying but ultimately much more gratifying.

In the former case, our children remain just that – children. In the latter, we can take pleasure in having created mature, responsible adults.

January 14, 2018

Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 5

(5) Anonymous, January 15, 2018 4:19 PM

I follow this advice, but...

when I try to stay out of things with my daughters social challenges - and brainstorm about how to deal with things or encourage her... she feels I don't care because if I did - I would "DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT" As of yet I don't think she is happy with any of my explanations about how my job is to give her tools and that she can handle it...

(4) Nancy, January 14, 2018 5:50 PM

Two different situations

Re: The art teacher. The people in this situation were ostensibly adults. That teacher's mother was way out of line in her financial comments. Re: The fifth grade girls. Sometimes they can handle situations on their own, and other times they need a lifeline. IMO, the other mother acted inappropriately when she became so accusatory.

(3) Anonymous, January 14, 2018 3:15 PM

Author is only half correct

You are right. NEVER call the other child's parent, ALWAYS call the school.

(2) cee, January 14, 2018 2:42 PM

Not so sure

I was one of those mothers who did not step in to defend my daughter. It was a mistake. My lack of involvement hurt my daughter. I respectfully disagree. I think every mother has intuition when to step in and when not to. However, in this day and age of facebook and other social media, it is very important for parents to be vigilant and to step in more often than not.

(1) Anonymous, January 14, 2018 2:36 PM

Sometimes your child needs you to intervene

There are exceptions. Especially with bullying

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub