click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Don’t Listen to Anna Wintour
Mom with a View

Don’t Listen to Anna Wintour

Who says we have to accept society’s definition of beauty?


“You look skinny,” my young grandson said to his mother recently.

“Thanks!” beamed his mother proudly.

“Why did you say thanks?” he asked.

That stopped her in her tracks. Of course we all know why she said thanks but her son didn’t know it was a compliment. He hasn’t yet learned to adopt a particular societal definition of beauty, a particular goal established by the fashion industry or Hollywood or whoever it is that is the arbiter of style and size. For him, it was just a simple statement of fact. He had no agenda, positive or otherwise.

If we didn’t know it before, this confirmed that the standard of beauty that rules society today is not innate. (Yes, I know one young boy’s comment does not constitute a scientific study – but neither is this a piece for Scientific American!) It is dictated from outside. And we have accepted it. We have allowed others/the world/Anna Wintour to determine our standard of beauty. And we’ve all paid a price.

Of course I am not referring to health. We are not discussing the situation where weight is putting a heavy burden on the heart or other organs. That is a medical situation requiring intervention. I’m referring to the average human being who, whether slightly overweight or not, strives to be, in the words of my grandson “skinny”. I’m referring to the majority of young girls and women today who are never satisfied with their weight, with what they see when they look in the mirror, who try every diet under the sun in the quest to achieve that illusive – and, dare I say? – inappropriate goal.

In recognizing the idea that the goal is simply a creation and not a reflection of the human condition, perhaps we can free ourselves of it. Perhaps we can appeal to our own rebellious natures and decide not to indulge society’s definition of beauty. Perhaps we can achieve independence by making peace with our body types and sizes instead of constantly striving to be thin. Perhaps.

I know it’s not easy. But I also know that the one “out of the mouths of babes” comment was, in its own way, a wake-up call. I’m not proud to have bought into an external societal-prompted definition of beauty. I’m not proud that I spend so many of my waking hours trying to achieve this goal. And never quite getting there…in fact, I know I never will get there because the goal itself is unrealistic.

While we don’t have to return to the shtetl of Anatevka where the widespread poverty made plump women the envy of all and Tevye wanted a “rich man’s wife with a proper double chin”, there is a happy medium, emphasis on happy.

Perhaps we could adhere to the Rambam’s philosophy of (and I paraphrase) “everything in moderation” and apply that to both our eating habits and our diet. And take the shame, the pain, the obsession, the striving out of our eating and our (furtive) glances in the mirror.

I’m not presuming to solve the issues of weight in one short article; I only mean to get us to ponder what the true definition of beauty is. Just as the Almighty is the only arbiter of what is good, just as He is the only one able to give us an understanding of the objective reality of what being good is, so too does the Creator of the world define ultimate beauty.

What is His definition? Modesty – a sense of dignity and innerness. I’ll leave you with that thought to ponder…the one thing I know for sure; it has nothing to be with weight and size and Anna Wintour!

October 14, 2017

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 6

(4) Anonymous, October 18, 2017 8:14 PM

Great article!

Thanks for this article. It's a very important topic and I find it so sad how much emphasis our society places on being "skinny." I love that story about the little boy who stated that fact to his mom. Recently my teenage brother actually said something similar- one of my sisters was teasing him about a specific girl and asked him, "you like her?" And his response was, "Nah, she's too skinny."
I'm not bashing on anyone who happens to be petite at all. I just don't feel everyone should fall into the same category of thin bodies. If God wanted that, He would have made us all look the same!

(3) Deborah, October 16, 2017 7:41 AM

The Fashion Industry Is a Death Racket

The kind of skinniness promoted by Anna Wintour has driven many girls to addiction, eating disorders and even death. The fashion industry has blood on its hands. Most of its models look near death, camouflaged by makeup. Generally speaking, most people should aim to have a higher ratio of muscle to fat. This will produce many different body shapes due to genetic factors.

(2) Anonymous, October 15, 2017 10:23 PM

well written commentary

thank you for this great article.

(1) Anonymous, October 15, 2017 3:10 PM

Taking it one step further

Don't contribute to publications that only show bone thin Caucasian women. Voting with one's wallet can make a big difference. Beauty comes in ALL shapes and sizes.

Roda, October 16, 2017 3:26 AM

I can't vote with my wallet because I don't buy beauty publications. I believe my own eyes when it comes to beauty.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment