click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Guinea Pig Kids
Mom with a View

Guinea Pig Kids

The gender-less baby: There’s a bit of Kathy Witterick and David Stocker in all of us.


By now, you’ve read the headlines: Parents keep child’s gender under wraps. You’ve had the typical sophisticated reaction: “These parents are nuts!” Or as Dennis Prager says, “You have to go to college to be so stupid.” And then you’ve either forgotten about the story (our lives are busy after all) or smugly reflected on the fact that you would never fall prey to such idiocy.

And you probably wouldn’t. Yet I think there is a lesson in this story for all of us. It’s not a cautionary tale because it hasn’t been played out to the end – although we can only imagine what that will be! But there actually is something important we can learn from the behavior of Ms. Witterick and Mr. Stocker.

Don’t make you children the tools to work out your issues – be they a psychological theory, a political theory, emotional pain, frustration, unfulfilled dreams, revenge or loneliness, to name a few possibilities.

The parents in this story didn’t make the decision quietly and privately. They sent out an announcement in all their friends. They wanted everyone to know about the grand choice they were making. Perhaps they were even anticipating their 15 minutes of fame. At their innocent infant’s expense…My heart breaks for any child who is the lab rat for his (or her!) parent’s experiment. But these parents aren’t the first.

My heart breaks for any child who is the lab rat for his (or her!) parent’s experiment.

Parents try out alternative schools, living arrangements (remember the children’s houses on the early kibbutzim?), unusual (to say the least) parenting techniques (how about Skinner’s box?), treating their children as guinea pigs. Do they really think deeply about the ultimate consequences?

But there’s more. I’ve seem far too many divorce cases where children are the pawns, the tools to exact revenge on the other side. The children’s minds are poisoned with vitriol about one parent, their relationship with them frequently destroyed. Parents lose sight of the fact that these are little souls they are responsible for and only see a way of causing further hurt to their former partner. Rare (and impressive) are the cases where parents speak only positively about their ex-spouse, whatever their real feelings, placing their concern for their children’s welfare ahead of their own pain.

Even in intact marriages, family therapists speak of triangulation, the phenomenon where one child is really the messenger between the parents and helps them avoid confronting each other and dealing with uncomfortable issues. No one thinks about the toll it takes on this child.

Or how about the all too common desire to have your child live the life you couldn’t, to experience vicariously what you missed out on in your own past? Is this really in your child’s best interests? Is this about their needs, goals or strengths? Do they want to go to Harvard, be a doctor or even a Torah scholar? Or is that actually your dream?

The list goes on and on. I know of more than one situation where men who didn’t marry until their late forties/early fifties were held back by one specific reason. Or should I say one particular person? Their mothers – who wanted their only sons constantly by their side, always at their beck and call. So no girl was every good enough and the grip was too strong.

I don’t understand these mothers. I don’t understand hurting your children that way. I don’t understand only seeing your needs and not theirs. But it happens – a lot.

And there’s more. I’m sure everyone has a “friend” who isn’t always supportive of their children, especially if their public behavior isn’t ideal. They allow themselves to be embarrassed by their children or to believe the critical words of an acquaintance or teacher over their own offspring. Their social acceptance takes precedence over their children’s emotional needs, over our responsibility to provide unconditional love.

Children are a precious and awesome responsibility. And our job is, to the best of our abilities (we are human after all), to do what what’s good for them, what allows their unique potential to be achieved and to shine.

It’s too easy to read about this Canadian couple and “tsk tsk” in smug disapproval. It’s more productive to be thoughtful and introspective. There’s a little of Kathy Witterick and David Stocker in all of us.

May 28, 2011

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 15

(10) Pauline, June 5, 2011 11:18 PM

I didn't see the original article. But in general, this unusual announcement makes me wonder if the baby was born with genitals that make it unclear as to if it is a boy or girl, as does rarely happen. And perhaps, rather than just doing a surgery guessing at one over the other now, the parents will let the child choose later.

(9) Sara, June 3, 2011 2:49 PM

To AnnaLee

She didn't say anything of the sort. She's not referring to discipline for bad behavior, which is often necessary, but to name-calling, criticism, or emotional abandonment because a child isn't fitting into the parents' image of an ideal child. (Such as a child who is overweight, is struggling with religion, struggling in school, or merely wearing strange clothing.) I would say it's a fine line between the two, but the truth is that it's not so fine and for the average, emotionally healthy adult, it's easily discernible.

(8) MABSH"Y, June 2, 2011 3:09 PM

Not the only screwed up kid

Still, this kid will probably grow up less screwed up than little Adolf Hitler Campbell. Remember him? Google him, if you don't.

(7) suzzanne nemick, June 2, 2011 1:50 AM

Don't project your or your projects onto your children.

A parent needs to be less controling and more guiding. Ignoring poor behavior and rewarding good behavior a lot, feels righht to me. I know it works in other circumstances.

Alan S., June 3, 2011 9:23 AM

Really? Is it possible that you condone it when a parent ignores poor behavior? Perhaps thought processes like yours can help to partially explain why the jails are full.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment