click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Join 400,000 Aish subscribers
Get Email Updates




Hanukkah is NOT Thanksgiving
Mom with a View

Hanukkah is NOT Thanksgiving

Why Hanukkah is the most anti-American holiday of all.

by

I have to confess that I don’t understand the whole Hanukkah/Thanksgiving dilemma. Perhaps it’s because I grew up in Canada where Thanksgiving is a holiday of recent creation, added to the calendar in imitation of the Americans. It never caught on, perhaps due to its lack of historical antecedents. I led a deprived childhood, missing out on roast turkey, cranberry sauce and yams with marshmallows. So I don’t really get all the fuss, not the mention the fantastical numerical calculations about the infrequency of this occurrence.

As you may have been noticed, it is not unusual for Hanukkah to go head to head with another, more widely celebrated holiday. And, unfortunately, it often gets lost in the shuffle. It gets trivialized or downplayed or treated as a simple children’s celebration.

And that’s unfortunate because it’s a profound holiday with many important messages.

I like to think of Hanukkah as the holiday of Jewish pride – we place our menorahs in our windows to publicize the miracle, to proclaim to the world that the Almighty takes care of His people – and to express our gratitude.

It is, ironically, the most anti-American holiday of all (don’t jump on me yet; I like living in this country and am very appreciative). Why? Because America is all about assimilation, about fitting in; this is a country that prides itself on being a melting pot. Sociologists have even developed a model for the stages of assimilation – including some Malcolm X-style anger and national pride in the middle – with the ultimate goal and resolution being a seamless participation in American life, a quiet loosening of the ties to other countries, other values, other customs (unless it’s something quaint to be trotted out in a yearly festival of costumes and food but otherwise invested with no daily significance).

There is even a course like this taught in grad school. In my class, everyone had to map their personal or family’s trajectory, starting with their immigration to the United States. But the model just didn’t work for me. I didn’t assimilate. I chose to live differently, separately. My people’s laws and customs infuse my daily existence, with each holiday offering deeper meaning and significance. I couldn’t contort my belief system, my national heritage and identity, to fit the sociological paradigm. So I got a B in the course!

But that just fueled my Jewish pride. Maybe it’s the rebel in me but I was happy to be different, to make my own choices, to stand apart from the crowd. But maybe it’s not just me. The Torah mentions over and over again that we are a stiff-necked people. That’s why the Greek’s initial strategy didn’t work. They tried to forbid the learning of Torah but that just got us annoyed. Even people who weren’t learning previously wanted to participate!

Thanksgiving is a nice holiday. It’s about gratitude and family – and lots of pie! There’s nothing not to like about it (except that over-stuffed feeling).

But Hanukkah is about transcendence, about elevating our lives, about focusing on our relationship with God, about using the material to accomplish the spiritual. The Greeks may have been known for the Olympics but the truth is it’s no competition at all; Hanukkah wins it hands down. I’m grateful to live in America but it’s a privilege to be a part of the Jewish people and to have a covenant with God – and to proclaim our pleasure through our blazing Hanukkah lights – the lights of hope, the lights of wisdom, the lights of intellect, the lights of Torah. No turkey-shaped menorah for me…

Published: November 23, 2013


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 48

(31) Suzanne Israel Tufts, November 30, 2013 12:41 AM

Thanksgiving has parallels to Chanukah -- deliberately so

Alas the article, although uplifting regarding its focus and commentary on Chanukah, betrays a striking ignorance of the origins purpose and meaning of Thanksgiving. This is not surprising given the political correctness rampant in American education. However the author would be interested I think to know that the Mayflower passengers came here to escape government restriction of their religion, they chose to live separately, they attributed their survival to G-d'S intent --- and they regarded themselves -yes -- as Maccabees and "pilgrims" cing to a "new Jerusalem." Rightly or wrongly they crafted the first Thanksgiving around both Chanukah and Pesach themes. I've had the opportunity to study very early Colonial history and to interact without flower descendants Nd never cease to be amazed at the early Pilvrims' knowledge of our history and texts. The focus on football and pie and shopping is a modern secular focus and not in keeping with the "original intent. " Chanukah and Thanksgiving have many historical parallels in terms of the triumph of the religious over the State and the profane.

B, December 7, 2013 3:04 AM

Thank You

THANK YOU!!! Well stated.

(30) Manya, November 27, 2013 5:22 PM

Thank You

I 110% connected with this article. Thank you Mrs. Braverman for putting into words how I am sure many Jews feel about "Thanksgivinkah". I also feel that it is very ironic that most assimilated Jews celebrate Hanukkah, a holiday that is so anti-assimilation. I think the people who get offended by your article do not realize that Shabbas observant Jews celebrate Thanksgiving atleast every week on Shabbat if not everyday appreciating and being thankful for all that HaShem has blessed us with in our lives (i.e., friends, family, food, shelter etc.). I hope to keep reading articles you publish!

(29) Karen, November 27, 2013 12:19 AM

Inflammatory Title

Even after reading the article, I feel really sad when I consider the title. And the inflammatory nature of calling Hannukah an anti-American holiday- that just seems scary to me. Yes, there is a lot of assimilation in the US, but I would rather be an observant Jew here than in any other country (besides Israel, of course). We only have to consider what is going on in Sweden, Poland, France and the Netherlands, to name a few countries, where people just want the Jews and Jewish culture to disappear completely. We are so very fortunate to live here. I agree with you about not having a turkey menorah. And I so very much agree with you about what Hannukah is, but please, Mrs. Braverman, please choose another way to describe Hannukah!

Anonymous, November 27, 2013 7:17 PM

Relax

The tile is probably more inflamatory than it needs to be but her point is just that American culture treasures assimilation. A key feature of our national identity is our ability to "Americanize" immigrants from the world over. A Hannukah is exactly about the opposite, as Ms. Braverman points out. She's right. We can be proud observant Jews and grateful Americans (who happen not to buy into the need to assimilate to also be a proud American). That's all she's saying, seems to me.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!