click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Is AIPAC’s Influence in Decline?
Mom with a View

Is AIPAC’s Influence in Decline?

If it is, here’s an important Purim silver lining.


“Has AIPAC lost its mojo?”

That was the headline I awoke to. It’s all over the news. Defeated in the battle over sanctions on Iran, the doomsday predictors swamp the media. What is the future of AIPAC? And what is the future of the state of Israel without AIPAC/US support?

These are important questions and AIPAC is an important organization. I am a supporter of AIPAC, and have defended the organization from attacks from the right and the left. If they have indeed lost their mojo, if they are not as effective as they used to be (and that's a big if), perhaps we can find a silver lining.

The Purim story has a timely response to this situation. When Esther heard of the King and Haman’s plot to kill the Jews, she formulated a response. She asked the Jewish people to fast for three days, after which time she would approach the king and plead on their behalf. For those of you who remember their Sunday school training, the king had an interesting policy. If you presented yourself to Ahashveirosh without being asked, you were risking your life. At the moment, upon seeing you in his doorway, he would either lift his scepter and allow you entry or keep it lowered, sentencing the supplicant to death. This was the situation awaiting Esther. So she ordered a three-day fast. Why?

Esther wanted the Jewish people to recognize that everything is in the Almighty’s hands.

Esther wanted the Jewish people to recognize that everything is in the Almighty’s hands. Fast days are an opportunity for introspection, for atonement and for connection to the Almighty. She wanted the Jewish people to cry out in pain and desperation for the Almighty’s help.

And to highlight this, to augment this recognition, she added an important component. I don’t know about you but after a one day fast, I certainly don’t look or feel my best. I can’t begin to imagine how I would appear after a three-day fast, if I could stand at all. One would think that, in approaching the king with so much at stake, the goal would be to look your best. Shouldn’t Esther have hired a make-up artist and a personal shopper? Shouldn’t she have rented jewelry from Harry Winston and a gown from some hot young designer? (Oh sorry, I’m getting confused with the Oscars!) Wouldn’t that have been the way to put her best foot forward?

Instead, she approaches the king after three days of fasting, looking pale, wan and sickly. Why? She was trying to convey an important message to the Jewish people. She was afraid that they were overly confident. They knew that she was in the palace. They were probably relying on her to save them. Their prayers wouldn’t be so heartfelt. Their dependence would be on her instead of on the Almighty.

That just wouldn’t do. So Esther took matter into her own hands by clearly taking them out of her hands! She fasted, she prayed, she asked the Almighty for help and she went to meet the king looking like – well, like someone who has fasted for three days!

As the story goes, she found favor in the king’s eyes. Given what her mirror told her, this was miraculous (so the Talmud reports). This only came about through Divine intervention. This was a response to her prayers and those of her people.

Perhaps we have a similar opportunity right now. If AIPAC really isn’t as powerful as it used to be, maybe it will force us, nudge us, encourage us to turn to the Almighty instead. Maybe this is our turning point, our moment to recognize that everything is in His hands and to ask Him to save us. Maybe it’s a gift. It can’t be a coincidence that it’s all coming to a head right before Purim.

March 8, 2014

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 3

(3) Susan, March 9, 2014 9:55 PM

Going to AIPAC

Emuna, how many Aish members in LA went to AIPAC and showed their support? I don't know if the Greenbergs are still part of Aish but that's all I saw. Beth Jacob had over 60 members and so did YICC. I saw a few people from Beth Am (3) and that's it. So when your representative Karen Bass doesn't vote for Iran sanctions or to make Israel most favorite nation status, you have only yourself to blame. Rabbi Cohen and you should encourage your members to go next year. That's what Rabbi Rembaum's going to do and it'll make a difference. Karen Bass needs to hear from us.

(2) Anonymous, March 9, 2014 6:58 PM

No AIPAC has not lost its MOJO!

It may look or seem as that might be happening but that is only because we have not had such a deceptive and anti-Israel administration in the white house since President Carter. This President's administration try's to put forth a Pro-Israel stance but what they really want is to pressure Israel into a two state solution at any cost. They are naive enough to believe that this is the solution to the struggle with the Muslim conservatives who will never accept Israel's existence... Thank G-d that Bibi leads Israel against her enemies and her friends...

(1) Rachel, March 9, 2014 5:25 PM

AIPAC vs Prayer

I'm glad to see that your final thought was that we should put our trust in Hashem and not just in human organization.

I am not an AIPAC member because I think they are too closely identified with one US political party. I contact my members of Congress regularly when I think AIPAC is right, and when I make campaign contributions, I make sure to include thanking my candidates for their pro-Israel commitments. I also let them know that other matters of importance to the Jewish community (such as day school education, a federal leave policy that allows Sabbath observers to make up the time on other days) are equally important to me.

And like all observant Jews, I "talk" to Hashem daily about Israel!

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment