click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Mounting the School Barricades

Mounting the School Barricades

Advocating for our children.

by

I preface this with a proviso: The majority of teachers are caring, kind and dedicated to promoting the happiness and self-esteem of their students. They are usually underpaid, underappreciated, overworked, and continue in spite of that, because they love their profession.

Having said that, rare are the parents who have not, at sometime in the school lives of their children, felt torn between what they feel is their civic responsibility to be supportive of the teacher, and their gut instinct that it is their child who they should be supporting. If we can’t be perfectly balanced at all times, on the side of which should we err?

Everyone has his story to tell. I hope I can help a few parents by opening with one of ours, and the epiphany to which it led me.

One of my daughters, who I’ll call Sara, was only eight years old when we moved to a new city and she was in a new school, a little scared and insecure. I walked in one day and saw her gym teacher, who was directing an aerobics line dance in the hallway, grab Sara violently by the shoulders and fling her to the back of the line, shouting at her to move faster.

I will never forget the look of shame and devastation on my daughter’s face. I went up to the teacher, and said, with quiet fury, “Don’t ever lay a finger on my daughter again.” I looked up to see the principal standing in the doorway. He had seen the whole thing, and the shock was registered on his face. Sara was apparently not her only victim, and some time later, she was fired.

As another school year looms on the horizon, I think of an issue that, in our lives as parents, should play one of the most intense and critical roles in raising children. It is a role at least as important as being sure that they eat healthy lunches, do their homework, clean up their rooms and make it to jazz or soccer practice on time.

It’s about advocacy.

The word “advocate”, like the French “advocat”, means “attorney”. And that’s exactly what we must be – attorneys for our children. There is nothing we can do for the school lives of our children that is more important than mounting the barricades for them.

Why “barricades”? Because sometimes that is exactly what a school feels like – a fortress, with concentric ramparts protecting the inner sanctum, that are composed not only of physical walls, but also of personnel (secretaries, division heads), of outside forces (parents’ committees, school board) and, most lethal of all, of ingrained assumptions and philosophies that may or may not be relevant to this century, to our philosophy, or – worst of all – to our children’s personalities.

There can be problems in any city, any country, and any educational system. No one is immune and no parent should be complacent.

I write this also on the backdrop of my 30+ years experience in both formal and informal education. I recognize the frustrations that teachers face every day. Sometimes the pressure is crushing, and they get it from all sides. Teachers and principals are only people, and they make mistakes. But, like we learned in kindergarten, the best way to deal with a mistake is by, first, saying that you’re sorry.

Advocacy is not just about preventing wrongs; it’s also about getting your child the best education he deserves, and recognition of his strengths.

By the time my children were in the higher elementary grades, I had formulated my own erudite philosophy about schools, and it went like this: “As long as the school doesn’t destroy my child’s self esteem, or his natural curiosity to learn, it will be enough for us.” Now, after our youngest graduated high school, I still believe that.

A sampling of things you can do to advocate for your child:

  • Never tolerate any excuse for physical violence against a child.
  • Never tolerate any excuse for a teacher to say something to a child that will make her feel degraded or stupid.
  • Never tolerate any excuse for a teacher to embarrass a child because of what the teacher perceives to be a parent’s shortcomings. (As in, “Tell your mother not to send me notes on a torn piece of paper.” Or “Doesn’t your father care enough to come to parents’ night?”)
  • Never accept the excuse that your child is not being called on, or given a role in a school project, or tested for gifted programs because, “He sits in the back and is quiet”. Advocacy is not just about preventing wrongs; it’s also about getting your child the best education he deserves, and recognition of his strengths. An expert in giftedness once told me, “Giftedness is Special Education, no less than LD and AD(H)D.”
  • Always believe your child. And if deep down inside, you have doubts, always tell him that you believe him, anyway. Many years after nobody will remember (or care) who threw that piece of chalk at the blackboard, your child will remember that you trusted him. And even if he didn’t “deserve it” that particular morning, it will (hopefully) become a self-fulfilling prophecy in the future.
  • Never assume automatically that a bad teacher’s report means that there is something wrong with your child. Check out his behavior with other teachers, including those who teach art, gym, music and other “non-academic” subjects. Do some detective work to determine if there are other children in the same class receiving similarly negative reports. Maybe the problem is the teacher. (Sometimes an incompetent or emotionally abusive teacher will lead a whole class of parents to believe that the problem is only with “their” child.)
  • If you believe your child has been treated unfairly, don’t hesitate to speak up. If you believe your child has been abused in some way, don’t hesitate to contact the principal, a regional supervisor, a lawyer, a clergyman, or the police. Even if the teacher apologizes, or the story is less serious than you thought at first, your child will remember that you pulled out all the stops for her well being.
  • Always be respectful when interacting with teachers or with school officials. This is also a message to your child, one that only you can give.

And as for Sara? Today she is happily married with children of her own and with a degree in Special Education. One day, out of the blue, she said to me, “Mom, you were always ready to mount the barricades for us. Thank you.”

Being our children’s advocates, especially when we are young parents, demands courage, perseverance, and sometimes audacity, but it will pay off in their feelings toward us, and, even more important, in their perception of their own worth.

And it’s possible that an educator out there may learn something from you, in the process.

Published: August 28, 2010


Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.

Visitor Comments: 6

(6) Sally, September 18, 2010 2:16 PM

Advocate

This article brought back many sad memories of my daughter's school years. I remember how excited she was to enter kindergarten only to have her joy killed by a teacher that was cruel and uncaring. My daughter was teased and bullied by classmates and I shall never forget hearing her teacher say, "kids will be kids". I complained to the teacher, the principal, asked for my daughter to be moved to another classroom to no avail. At that point my daughter was doing poorly in school and was even told to "lower my expections for my child, she is obviously not that bright." Finally in desperation, I removed her from public school and enrolled her in a private school. My daughter was immediately happier, she was learning thanks to the help of loving, caring teachers. These teachers loved their children and loved their job. A good teacher can make such a difference, a good advocate for a child is a must! Speak up for your children, you must be their champion. School should be a place of learning and joy, not a terror filled place.

(5) Toby Klein Greenwald, September 7, 2010 7:25 PM

Ms. Dagen: I suggest you read more carefully

You are of course entitled to your opinion but unfortunately you appear to have missed the point of the article. It is not about letting children "get away with" anything; it is about not allowing verbal or physical abuse of a child, and when it happens, it is about not backing up the teacher blindly when a child is obviously in pain for having suffered abuse at the hands of an educator. Best of luck to you, TKG

(4) Barbara Dagen, August 31, 2010 2:06 PM

I disagree with this parent.

I think this parent has it wrong and some of her ideas are what has totally empowered 3 year olds and up to be as rude, disrepectful and unruly as they are. Certainly a child should never be abused in any way by any one , but to rally the troops so that will be what your child remembers from the incident and not that his behavior was unacceptable is just saving the parent from their own child. Where does that leave the teacher in terms of having the responsibilty of protecting all the children? There is nothing teachers are allowed to do now to discipline children. Rather than supporting her child even if she suspects her child might be wrong, wouldn't this parent serve every one better by finding out what happened and then deciding on a course of action. By telling your child I will support you no matter what you do , tells that child she can do whatever she wants and get away with it. That is what is wrong with our society.

(3) Anonymous, August 30, 2010 7:52 AM

Children do need parental advocates...

When my children were small, I was very afraid of confrontation. However, when I saw several instances of abuse or neglect from teachers toward my kids, I learned to get my teeth apart, in a respectful and courteous manner but also in a direct manner. I made sure to let teachers know that I knew what their legal responsibilities were concerning my children and even went so far as to observe the classroom for one of them because I suspected that there was behavior going on in there that was detrimental to my child (and my suspicion was confirmed).I also did go to the principal. It was the teacher's responsibility to make sure that the classroom and school environment was safe for all the children in her class and in the school. I understand that most teachers do try very hard to do that, but there are some who feel that nasty peer pressure is a good way to "tame" a "wild" spirit or "overly busy" child. That is not true, however, in many instances. Children can be very mean and can do irreparable harm to other children with their behavior and comments. So parents do need to be vigilant advocates for their children to protect them from bullies, whether other children or teachers or other authority figures. That being said, it is also necessary to know one's children so that when they do need discipline that we don't interfere with just consequences for their own behavior. It is a delicate balance and both things are evidence to our children that we love them dearly. The guidelines of the author are absolutely correct. However, it is not going to eliminate all problems our children will face in the educational system. When they don't, then we need to teach our children that teachers, administrators and other people in authority are first and foremost, human beings and fallible. That does not make them unworthy of respect, but that they can and almost always will make mistakes. They usually try to do the best they can for everyone and that is a big job.

(2) Rachel, August 29, 2010 8:24 PM

AND: Never tolerate bullying by other students

Schools are getting better about this, but when I was a child/teen in the 1970's, I was miserable in school most of the time not because of my teachers, but because of my classmates who hurt me physically and emotionally. Yet as long as they didn't inflict severe physical harm, the school's policy (and even my own parents' thinking) was "kids will be kids, and you need to learn to ignore them." It's hard to ignore when your self-esteem is shredded and you're being tripped, bumped into walls, having your hair pulled, etc.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub
Sign up today!