click here to jump to start of article
  • Torah Reading: Naso
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

Rabbi Akiva’s Parenting Tip

Rabbi Akiva’s Parenting Tip

The secret is gentle dripping water.


Dripping water. That’s how a parent has to speak. Like a slow and constant drip. Think of the child as a crop. There are different ways of watering crops. You can pour on them with rotary sprinklers, a whirling deluge, or you can conserve your energy and work on the roots, gently through a network of connections, drip irrigation, which was invented here in Israel. You can drip on your children.

And one day they will grow in the direction you have guided them.

I learned this concept of gentle parenting recently when a woman told me something very important, something I wish I had known when I was parenting little kids. But it is still relevant for parenting older kids:

You just keep saying it. Whatever it is. Ad nauseum. You just keep saying the same thing. The kids don’t have to buy it. They don’t have to do it. They don’t even have to listen. But if you keep saying it, eventually it will seep in. Maybe not now. Maybe when they are 20. But they will hear your voice.

Isn’t that what a parent is anyway ultimately? A voice inside of a child.

Think of our religion, how we say the same things over and over—the weekly Torah portion, the prayers. The hope is that those words one day will enter us, define us, change us, slowly.

God after all created the world with words. And he didn’t have to yell to create. The Zohar says that he whispered.

This gentle method takes a lot of pressure off of the parent. She doesn’t have to get her way. She just has to define her way, describe her way, articulate her way, know her way and just by uttering her way, she plants a seed within the child that can lead to movement.

We usually think of movement as quick: quick obedience, rapid listening. But children aren’t built for rapid response to their parents. How often it is that they don’t respond, at least not the way you want them to.

I remember when my kids were little I would ask them to stop screaming. I would ask them again. I would tell them. And then I would scream at them stop screaming. I would lose it. I was Crazy Mom.

But as we moms grow up, we also learn. There is no need to force things. I learned this lesson in a very painful way. My son was murdered when he was 13. Before he was killed, I used to force the matter at hand with my children. I wanted them to do what I wanted them to do. Now. Not later. Not tomorrow.

But losing a child make you revaluate your priorities. Makes you reevaluate everything. You don’t expect things to go your way. You don’t expect. You know that you can do your best and the worst can happen. All you can do is try.

So now when I hear parents yelling at their kids I am a little bit shocked. I used to get into crazy power struggles with my kids. I wanted them to clean their rooms and do their homework and brush their teeth and sit at the table and go to sleep at a proper hour and I wanted them to obey me. After my son’s murder, it was so clear that the control I thought I had was false. I had no power. Now I was happy because they were alive. I truly appreciated them. I wanted to be with them, just to be with them. I didn’t need them to listen to me.

It’s amazing that the power struggles stopped. Now for me to get into a power struggle with a child is rare, very rare. Yes I occasionally lose it but I don’t have to be right and I don’t have to force my will. I can be like water dripping on a rock. The great sage and scholar, Rabbi Akiva, a man who first studied the Torah when he was 40 and had no confidence that he would be able to learn it, noticed the way that water had hollowed a cavity in a rock. He said something to the effect that if gentle water could hollow a rock, then the words of Torah (which are compared to water) could also penetrate him.

Our words are water and sometimes our children are rocks. But rocks can be sculpted. Especially if you willing to wait.

Sherri Mandel is now judging the Stories from the Heart Contest at Click here to enter.

September 1, 2012

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 12

(12) Ilana Z., April 2, 2017 2:23 AM

Thank you for your very encouraging article, it reminded me as well my grandmother who used to gently telling me same thing over again, I listened but words seem to fall on closed ear, after she was niftar , I was over 40 years old, I finally heard and keep on replaying the message. And this realisation helping me to gently persist with my kids. Ty

(11) Anonymous, June 21, 2013 1:56 AM

i just had a really hard day with my children... and lashed out at my daughter (4 yr old ) when she started to command and tell me what to do... i don't know how to deal with her and how she talks to me at times... i know i am very authoritative... and scream a lot and demand a lot but don't know any other way... i was brought up this way... i use threats to get my kids to do things which i know is terrible... i need a change... i am so lost...this article was definitely helpful... but i need something more... any recommendations would be greatly appreciated... i need to control my frustration and anger and channel it the right way... i don't know how

(10) Aliza, April 28, 2013 6:20 AM

thank you

After a particularly difficult morning, complete with screaming from me and my children, I got online to find something to encourage me and maybe help me be a more successful mother. I found your article. Thank you for this amazing perspective. I cant even imagine the pain that must come along with your situation but my frustration at my children just melted into appreciation. I hope that Hashem sends you only love and bracha and positive experiences for the rest of yours and your childrens lives. Thank you.

(9) Feigele, October 1, 2012 5:06 PM

Echoing our points!

I can’t imagine who would do such thing to a 13 yrs old—I can’t even voice the word for it. How awful and inconceivable. I see, as mothers, we all do the same things with our children, basically because we want to protect them and make sure they will escape most of the life problems if we show them the right way to do things. I have always repeated all those advices, and still do, and in English and in French to make sure it sticks to their brain. Unfortunately, it doesn’t always work that way and they must bear the consequences of their actions, as we all did. I keep repeating to myself that it is their life and thus as such they will go thru what we went thru, and there is nothing we can do about it.

(8) Anonymous, September 6, 2012 2:54 AM

Parenting style

This occurred to me today when contrasting my parenting style with a more authoritarian style. What if G-d parented us in a more authoritarian style, if I were to get an immediate feedback (electrical current to the tuchas) every time I broke a command I would behave perfectly. I would learn not to step out of line. I would learn, but I would learn out of fear - not love. I could spank my child each time that I saw him doing something I disapprove or dislike, but I would lose that opportunity to teach using natural consequences. Or the way that he will learn in the "real world". A co-worker will not spank him if he doesn't complete his projects, he will have earned a consequence, but it may not appear for some time. Quick, effective discipline must be imposed when children are being destructive or dangerous to themselves or others - or to the property of others. I like your gentle toungue method of correcting minutiae of a child's character.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment