Aish.com Weekly Email - 260,000 subscribers



Aish.com delivered
  e-mail
  Aish Mobile

See More


The Mother Daughter Dance
by Evelyn Prero
I've always been blessed with my mother's love. It was my mother's like that I yearned for but seldom achieved.

    Email this Print this

It takes two to tango. Doesn't it?

My mother and I have almost nothing in common. It took me many years to realize this, after extended periods of bumbling efforts to forge a bond with ingredients that couldn't be found in our reserves.

I am as expressive as an emoticon while my mother harbors the post-Holocaust mentality of keeping it all holed up, probably since she was brought up by a survivor of Majdanek. While I have always been blessed with the security of my mother's love, it was my mother's like that I yearned for but I felt I seldom achieved. After I got married and began my own family, my penchant for a blissful maternal/daughter bond amplified. But so did the fighting. Every visit turned into a verbal spar rooted in deep-seated personality differences.

Every visit turned into a verbal spar rooted in deep-seated personality differences.

My husband was rather manly about the whole thing. "Give it up," he said. "She'll never be who you want her to be."

"Ha!" I said. "I'm not giving it up. She needs to understand blah, blah, blah. She needs to see blah, blah, blah. She needs, she needs, she needs."

"Okay," my husband responded, wisely keeping quiet.

And so it continued. Each visit was a mixture of joy and incessant frustration. My mother didn't like the way I kept home, she didn't approve of my husband's choice of profession, and she thought that my children should receive their education elsewhere. She slathered hurt upon hurt that slid into my open heart like a burning salve. And I erupted in return, spewing my own molten lava that streamed down the insidious cliff of our relationship.

"I can't take it anymore," I cried to my husband. "I don't have to take it anymore. I don't want to visit her anymore."

"That's one choice you have," my husband sagely offered.

"One choice? It's the only choice. This is emotional suicide. What's the other choice?"

My husband looked at me. "Change."

"I know," I said. "We should both change. We should compromise. We should learn to accept each others differences."

"Nope," my husband said. "You change. Only you."

I looked at my husband, certain at that point that men were cretins from another galaxy. "Why should I be the one to change? She's the one who finds fault with everything I do."

"You can't depend on her changing, but you can depend on yourself."

I was skeptical. My university education and my master's degree in psychology had taught me that it takes two to tango. Change can only be implemented in a relationship when both parties are willing and able. If I enabled myself into a willing partner, then who would I partner with?

Apparently the Jewish view was different. Judaism posited that I was responsible for my part and held full culpability for modeling positive behavior within the relationship. Every person who is brought into your life is specifically tailored for you. Sometimes that person is there to help you grow in ways you never knew possible.

Honoring your parents is one of the cardinal tenets of our religion. Even the ornery parents. Even the ones who make mistakes.

Besides the fact that I disliked the acrimony, honoring your parents is one of the cardinal tenets of our religion. Even the ornery parents. Even the ones who make mistakes. By giving me life I was bound to my mother with an eternal and indispensable debt of gratitude.

Since I was fortunate enough to be blessed with a loving and selfless mother with many sterling qualities, could we possibly learn to iron out the kinks between us through the toil of only my own heart?

It couldn't hurt to try.

"Just keep a low profile," my husband said. "When she's negative, change the subject. If she's right, think about how you can change to smooth things over."

It was a Herculean effort, mired in disappointment. I felt like I was going up the down escalator. I would swallow three fiery comments and then detonate when it came to the fourth one.

I had to get serious. I valued this relationship too much for it to go up in smoke. If she wouldn't meet me halfway, then I had to go the whole nine yards on my own. I put a mental clamp on my tongue and started over.

It started to work. When my mother wasn't meeting my emotional needs I looked towards other valued relationships in my life to fill them. I realized I had been pigeonholing her into a space she didn't fit into. When my mother said hurtful things, I changed the subject or firmly let it be known that this topic was off limits. When she criticized, if the comment was extraneous, I set it free. If it was helpful, I tried to make the necessary changes. I became more considerate of the things that mattered to her in her home; order, cleanliness and sleep, even when those things were lower on my own priority list. I did an about face, and it was astounding what my new view provided.

Things improved dramatically and quickly. My mother's visits, once so bittersweet, became enjoyable. I learned to focus on the things we shared, and I filled the empty spaces in between with other people and other interests. Slowly, the barbs became less frequent and the work all that much easier. The relationship had evolved to a point of mutual understanding, only the effort expended had been one-sided.

In the last ten years my mother and I have had only one noteworthy argument over the span of much shared time together. I can scarcely remember what things resembled before my resolution. I used to think it takes two to tango, but now I know that one can accomplish an exquisite dance performing solo.

Published: Sunday, August 31, 2008

If you would like to receive "Aish Weekly update" or other features via e-mail, please enter your email address here:

Top of article Submit comment Email this Print this

VISITORS COMMENTS: 13

(13) Anonymous, 27/10/2008
thanks for the words of confidence and help
Thanks for this story, I have just finished another tearful conversation with my mom, and her telling me once again how she is so disappointed in me and she doesn't know me ,and other belittling things. I had such a successfu lday at work too and was really feellig good about myslef more so than in a longtime, and of course my mother took that feelilng away. But I will try your suggestions and try to change to this approach, Thanks, hopes it helps..

(12) Ellen, 8/10/2008
something to think about this yom kippur
My mother passed away almost 25 years ago, and until recently, I would have responded the same way as Marie had. My mom was a Holocaust survivor and though intellectually I understood her responses towards me, similar to the author's (loved me but didn't like me too much), were profoundly affected by her unspeakable Holocaust experiences, emotionally I'd run the same tape through my head of anger that she couldn't approve of me. I believe now that Hashem gives us what we need when the time is right, and I guess I needed to process our relationship for close to 25 years to finally "get it". I may not have been able to do what the author did in my mom's lifetime, but I now do incredibly appreciate her outstanding positive attributes and what she gave me and have learned to make use of some of it. And like a therapist recently told me when I was going through the "mother drill", he benignly said to me, "Well, maybe she didn't think you were such a bargain, either." Instead of being upset, I paused, and then laughed. He was right. And somehow, I was finally freed.

(11) shells, 8/10/2008
thank YOU
Evelyn this is such a precious lesson to share and I thank you with all my heart. I too learnt to have a closer relationship with my Mum after having children because I think it was only then that I understood the complexities and emotions that she carried and why it was so difficult for me to understand her point of view when I was younger... because I hadn't learnt how to live with children! Since having my two boys my Mum has become my Best Friend and Confident and the ONE Person who has helped me more than anyone. Without my Mum I don't think I would have survived on my own and so today I give thanks... for Mothers and that special Mother/Daughter relationship :0) ... shalom shells x

(10) Anonymous, 7/10/2008
Thank you
Our setting expectations can be empowering as well as destructive when we set the bar for others, our displeasure and disappointment are ours to deal with, not theirs. It is refreshing that the author's husband made her aware of her responsibility. I am blessed with parents who are alive and am thankful for every day they are here on earth, even when any of the three of us may be cranky or annoyed. I think that a lot of it has to do with the type of giver and taker we are. If we give of ourselves as we can best give, not just as a response to what others expect, it matters less HOW the taker accepts, even though we all respond well to appreciation. Likewise, we cannot and should not tell others how to give, though we can model posititve, productive and generous actions and behavior. Fear factors in, as well. At some point, the other party may be so afraid of not meeting an expectation and causing disappointment, real or imagined, that they stop trying. Try to always give someone a path to return and connect, even if it's not on your time schedule. You have a life to lead in the meantime, and you may just meet up at a better place. G'mar chatima tova.





About the author:



Like what you read? As a non-profit organization, Aish.com relies on support from readers like you to enable us to provide inspiring and relevant articles. Click here to support Aish.com.


If you would like to receive "Aish Weekly update" or other features via e-mail, please enter your email address here:


Our Sponsors:




Our Privacy Guarantee: Your information is private. Your transactions are secure.
Aish.com, One Western Wall Plaza, POB 14149, Old City, Jerusalem 91141, ISRAEL
phone: (972-2) 628-5666 fax: (972-2) 627-3172 email: webmaster@aish.com

Judaism