click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​

The Love-Your-Fellow-Jew Challenge

The Love-Your-Fellow-Jew Challenge

Do your part to repair the damage. Reach out to a Jew different than you.


Our Sages tell us that the Second Temple was destroyed because of baseless hatred – Jews hating other Jews. Just as the destruction of the Holy Temple really began three weeks earlier when the walls of Jerusalem were breached, so too the acts of hatred amongst Jews bring down our people and destroy our souls. I learned about the power of this three-week period of mourning firsthand on a teen tour of Israel decades ago.

There were many profound, moving and hilarious moments on our trip – visiting the Western Wall for the first time and swearing I could feel it breathe, sobbing with grief at Yad Vashem, and laughing hysterically when some guys on the trip, filled with Jewish pride, “reenacted” the raid on Entebbe with shaving cream cans as guns and underwear on their heads as uniforms. But one event, which happened during the three weeks preceding Tisha B’Av, would have the most lasting impact on me.

For some reason, our tour, consisting of teens mostly from Denver, kept running into another teen group from Atlanta that we just didn’t hit it off with. We had met many other groups from the U.S. that we enjoyed and befriended, but this Atlanta group seemed spoiled and snobby. While staying at the same youth hostel as this group, an intense rivalry built up. It finally ended when our “commandos” took the shaving cream cans they had previously utilized for their “courageous raid on Entebbe,” and instead employed them to “decorate” the Atlanta boys’ rooms.

After the din of the victory celebration died down, we heard our madricha (counselor), Tami, weeping. We asked her what was wrong, and in her most heartbroken, pained voice, Tami said, “What are you doing? We are all Jews here. They are Jews, you are Jews. How can you hate each other? Everyone else hates us; we have to love each other. How could you have done this? We are all Jews!”

Needless to say, we all felt ashamed. Her message sunk into my heart and has remained there forever.

I try hard not to be critical of Jews who think differently than me, and my heart breaks whenever I see Jews belittling other Jews.

I learned a life-changing lesson that day, the importance of Ahavat Yisrael, loving your fellow Jew. As a result, I try hard not to be critical of Jews who think differently than me, and my heart breaks just as hers did that day, whenever I see or experience groups of Jews belittling or badmouthing other groups of Jews.

Bottom line, we are all Jews. We are not “Denverites,” “Atlantans,” “Israelis,” “Russians,” “Ethiopians,” and so on. We are Jews. Our level of observance or non-observance, our political beliefs, our customs and traditions – these are all things that tend to divide us. So I want to issue a challenge: reach out to Jews who are not like yourself and find your commonalities.

We can respectfully disagree with Jews with whom we do not see eye to eye without resorting to name calling. Let’s work on eradicating the anger and distrust amongst different groups of Jews. This three-week period is the perfect time for us to reflect on ways to increase our Ahavat Yisrael.

Think of ways you can reach out and spend time with your fellow Jews who are different than you. It may mean inviting the family down the block over, having lunch with a co-worker, or just saying a friendly hello to your neighbor.

For instance, every year I am blessed to be part of the Jewish Woman’s Repertory Company. The JWRC puts together a professional musical production by women, for women. With members from the entire spectrum of Jewish practice, it's an opportunity to rehearse and perform with Jewish women from all backgrounds bringing us together and creating lasting friendships between people who otherwise might never have met.

So I challenge everyone, including myself, to use this time before Tisha B’Av to focus on the ways we can truly participate in the mitzvah of loving our fellow Jews. Let's do our part to help repair the spiritual damage that has been done. I encourage anyone with suggestions and successes to share them in the comments section below. Perhaps together, you can help me erase the damage of the shaving cream, too!

Published: July 10, 2010

Give Tzedakah! Help create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 55

(49) Igor Bartolic, July 23, 2015 7:23 PM

Tisha B,Av & Ahavas Yisrael

Thank You for this great e mail.Shalom and love.

(48) Ariella, July 23, 2015 2:01 PM

We all need this challenge, Even me, the friendly one

My heart has no joy to see Jews mistreating Jews. No joy in anyone mistreating anyone somedays when I see kindness missing in this world. This is a challenge we need daily. I go to the local market that's kosher and see many Jews unable to greet each other. I used to feel bad. I don't cover my hair so I look less religious to some. I don't dress fancy so I don't look wealthy, I don't wear makeup so I don't look trendy. Then I read an article like this and I immediately say I need the challenge just like the rest. Some days I don't want to talk to someone with a purse that looks like it could cost thousands. Some days I get turned off by tons of makeup and overly dyed hair. Some days I just feel insecure. There's a lot in this world out of my control.
So I need this challenge. Say hello and or smile at someone I wouldn't usually speak to. Will start right away. But truth be known, I'm usually willing to speak to anyone, no matter what they look like. Jewish or not doesn't matter. May G-d Bless the memory of Chaya - Mom who taught by example to not judge others by nothingness.. What you wear and how you dress in most ways is nothingness. It may not reflect who you really are.

(47) Anonymous, July 16, 2013 6:14 PM

Atlanta loves you

Thank you for your letter. You have an open invitation to come for shabbat in atlanta.

Batsheva, July 27, 2015 5:00 PM

I would love to!

Thank you! I have many wonderful, kind friends who either come from Atlanta or have lived for years in that warm, loving community. Who knows? May be some of those lovely Atlantans I've heard so much about from my friends recently were on that early Israel trip. Wouldn't it be great if I could spend a Shabbos meal with them? You never know!

(46) Moshe Herschel Halevi, July 10, 2013 10:13 PM

I still do even after being hurt so many times

I was robbed and taken advantage of many times because I wanted so hard to serve others in this mitzvah, loving each Jew no matter what their observance. I did not realize though through this I had been manipulated by other Jews, but I refused to hold anger towards them as they are Jews and if I have hate in my heart for my brother then we will never have redemption. Kol Yisrael is filled with Jews of all levels, but instead of labeling and trying to use this to pidgeonhole another Jew only perpetuates our lack of unity. I had been embarrassed and humiliated in a religious environment because I had just tried to figure out things. I had Jews repeatedtly try to break in and these were Jews, who come from frum backgrounds. After all that happened I still love the Jews and tried to tell them we are brothers and to hurt your brother is to hurt your self because one sin is placed on all of Israel. A Kiddush Hashem will be every time a Jew doesn't judge but does their best to love them and show them the same respect and treatment they would want back, since you are to love your neighbor as yourself. G-D cares most about how we treat our fellow man, but Israel is even more important in our love because loving someone who has sinned is tough, or hurt you. If you can fight that and see the good they do have then we are one step closer to moshiach and finally the restoration of the beis hamikdash and geula!

Love your fellow Jew! This commandment is loving G-D by loving your fellow man or woman. We must stop the labels though because that has been a problem for us for centuries and since our times before exile!

If you are a Jew no matter what you are my brother or sister and I love you like family. If I am not for myself who am I for? Love G-D and show genuine love and not with an agenda, and this will bring us closer together, from the divfision of Jews because we forget Hillel said love your fellow man as yourself and the rest is commentary!

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.

  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment