click here to jump to start of article
Join Our Newsletter

Get latest articles and videos with Jewish inspiration and insights​




Natalie Portman's Christmas Tree
Chief Editor's Blog

Natalie Portman's Christmas Tree

The actress's desire for a Christmas tree isn't trivial. It represents the contemporary Jew's struggle to hold onto her Jewish identity.

by

After 35 years, Natalie Portman’s dream is about to come true. The award-winning Jewish actress is going to have a Christmas tree in her home this year.

Not only that, she thinks having a Christmas tree is every Jew’s secret wish.

She told the Tonight Show’s Jimmy Fallon that since the first night of Hanukkah coincides with Christmas this year, her family has decided to celebrate both holidays together.

"It’s every Jew’s kind of secret wish to have a Christmas tree… Why can’t we have that too?”

“I was asking my husband, ‘Is it okay for your family if we don’t have a tree?’ and then my parents were like, ‘We can get a tree….'” Portman told Fallon. “So excited! Like my whole life no Christmas tree, and then all of a sudden they have this great excuse, because it’s every Jew’s kind of secret wish to have a Christmas tree… Why can’t we have that too?”

Without realizing it, Natalie Portman has captured how the battle of Hanukkah is being waged today. The December Dilemma, when Jews feel conflicted by the Christmas onslaught – especially this year when the first night of Hanukkah and Christmas eve coincide, is no accident. It reflects the Jews’ contemporary spiritual challenge that has its roots in the Hanukkah story.

The threat posed to the Jews living in Israel by the ancient Greeks was unique. It wasn’t a physical threat of annihilation that the Jewish people had experienced in the past. It was the first time the Jews faced a religious war. The Greeks weren’t aiming to wipe out the Jewish people; they wanted to wipe out Judaism and its belief in an Infinite God Who creates, sustains and is involved in the universe. This was a battle for holding onto our spiritual uniqueness and identity.

Major events in Jewish history have spiritual antecedents. In the words of the great Jewish commentator, Nachmanides, “The actions of our forefathers are signs for the children.” We can get a deeper understanding of events by examining their spiritual roots that are carving out patterns in Jewish history.

Rabbi Yitzchak Hutner (Pachad Yitzchak, Hanukkah, Essay 2) explains that the war between the Maccabees and the ancient Greeks stems from the incident of Jacob wrestling with the guardian angel of Esau. Jacob had faced physical threats to his life from Laban and Esau; this encounter was the first time he confronted a spiritual danger.

Only after battling with the angel and overcoming him, did Jacob receive the name Yisrael, Israel. “No longer will it be said that your name is Jacob, but Israel, for you have striven with the Divine and with man and have overcome” (Genesis, 32:29).

It is our Jewish identity which is at stake in this spiritual battle between Jacob and the angel, and between the Jews in the time of Hanukkah and the Greeks.. Will the Jews choose to assimilate and become Hellenized, adopting the non-Jewish worldview and reject their distinctiveness, or will they stand up for their Jewish identity with fierce pride and maintain their unique heritage?

We only earn the moniker of "Israel" and attain our Jewish identity by overcoming the non-Jewish influences that beckon us.

Hanukkah is not a one-time battle. Every generation of Jews is confronted with this same spiritual conflict during this time of year; only its outer garb is different. We only earn the moniker of "Israel" and attain our Jewish identity by overcoming the non-Jewish influences that beckon us.

Don't dismiss Natalie Portman’s desire for a Christmas tree as a trivial celebrity gossip item. It signifies the contemporary Jew’s Hanukkah battle to hold onto his or her Jewish identity and not assimilate into the larger non-Jewish culture that seeks to erase our distinctiveness. How sad and painful it is that this prominent actress is sending such a wrong message at exactly the time we need to embrace our Jewish identity and distance ourselves from the powerful influences of the pervasive non-Jewish culture..

Hanukkah is the time to take a stand for being Jewish, to be like the menorah's oil that stubbornly refuses to assimilate in to the surrounding body of water. It's the time to express your secret wish of bringing forth your inner light that is embedded in your Jewish soul and to ignore the Christmas lights that may entice but are not your own.

Jewish identity can't be created in a vacuum. It's forged by igniting it with the radiant source of light that stems from the Torah. As we light our menorahs whose flames represent the fire and wisdom of Torah, let's take great pride in being Jewish and ensure that we carry the torch to the next generation.

December 18, 2016

Give Tzedakah! Help Aish.com create inspiring
articles, videos and blogs featuring timeless Jewish wisdom.
The opinions expressed in the comment section are the personal views of the commenters. Comments are moderated, so please keep it civil.

Visitor Comments: 62

(49) Anonymous, February 5, 2017 6:08 PM

I'm an Irish/Italian grandmother of 3 grands who are half Jewish

So long as the children are taught and seek to acknowledge both Jewish and Christian heritages, any tree and all trees are the creations of our Creator. Todays society is diverse beyond what has ever been in past history. What needs doing, is to bring the meaning of our spirituality into being in everyday life and not make so much of the decorations.

(48) Les Brown, January 2, 2017 8:02 AM

Xmas is not the only pagan festival celebrated by Jews

There is also Easter - symbolised by eggs and rabbits.
The Mayan tradition of Piñata, dedicated to their god; Huitzilopochtli (extra brownie points if you can pronounce it).
Halloween, originally Samhain - a Gaelic festival.
All these holidays are celebrated by Ashkenazi Jews wishing to emulate their Christian neighbours.
Sephardim, on the other hand, having Muslim neighbours, did not see the need to adopt any pagan rituals.

(47) Chanie, December 27, 2016 3:14 AM

the tree is a pagan symbol nothing to do with christianity

The tree was worshipped by the Pagans, and when the early Christians were trying to attract converts, they were told they could bring along their tree. It has nothing to do with Christianity, as well as the other symbols, such as wreaths, mistletoe, etc. it's all pagan, aka Avodah Zara aka idolatry, strictly forbidden by the Torah.

Eva, December 27, 2016 12:50 PM

Interestingly, in Early Colonial America

the Xmas tree was forbidden by law, as it was Pagan!

(46) Mickey, December 27, 2016 3:13 AM

I'm a Christian but will protect the Jewish faith with my life. I've always been drawn to it. Just remember there are people that aren't Jewish out there that are standinding up for you.

See All Comments

Submit Your Comment:

  • Display my name?

  • Your email address is kept private. Our editor needs it in case we have a question about your comment.


  • * required field 2000
Submit Comment
stub